Liosan, on 21 May 2010 - 04:29 AM, said:
Galain, on 21 May 2010 - 03:55 AM, said:
I cannot decide if you are amazingly stupid, or are scum. Just in case its the latter.
Vote Shadow
You do realise, the only way we win this game is by lynching the Syndicate right? And you are wanting us to lynch one of two PI?
Galain, on 21 May 2010 - 04:03 AM, said:
Galain, on 21 May 2010 - 04:22 AM, said:
Shadow, on 21 May 2010 - 04:15 AM, said:
Galain, on 21 May 2010 - 04:10 AM, said:
Shadow, on 21 May 2010 - 03:44 AM, said:
Considering that the Americans have a victory condition to identify other factions, and they've already gotten some hypothetical points from doing it successfully, I'm inclined to believe that Korvalain was not merely guessing when he pronounced Kaschan as being European. And since the Europeans are currently in the lead, whilst I don't have anyone particularly pinging my scum radar at this time (at least not more than my experience tells me is perfectly normal for the average non-scum), I favour the option of voting for the European and hopefully halting that nationality's progress.
Vote Kaschan
Here where you said, that you believed Korvalain he wasn't guessing about the factions and said he was European. So your voting for a member of the town that is in the different faction from you trying to halt that nationalitys progess. Well thats how I read it anyway. Are you saying its something else?
Oh please, Galain, don't try to pretend that you think PI somehow means something other than not-syndicate. Me believing that Kaschan is European has no effect on whether he is syndicate or not. You, on the other hand, seem to be saying otherwise for some reason...
Unless you think he's a symp then he's a PI yes. Someone else has revealed that he's a member of the town (which you have said you believe) and then you have voted accordingly for that person, you have said you are voting for him because he's a member of town, but in a different faction. Not because he's a symp, or syndicate, which in IMO is wrong.
Which one is it? They were PI, you didn't say they were PI, and now they are PI again?
Let me run through it for you. First recall and its stated in the opening post, that its a town vs scum game, nor a mercenary game or anything. Its Town vs Scum. The spies (the factions) are the town, and the syndicate are the scum. If there are people
on the syndicate who come back as members of a town faction, they would be called symps, although there is one exception, noted below.
Shadow came on and said he was voting Kaschan, because Kaschan is European. He knows Kaschan is European because of the reveal of Korvalain yesteday which he accepted and mentioned in his post.
I said he was stupid in doing so and voted for him, saying that Shadow is voting for people he considers PI, after all he is voting them not for because he thinks they are syndicate, nor for being a symp which would be the main reason for voting someone whose faction came back as one of the town factions. Instead he is voting for them for being a member of the town (in the current winning town faction though).
If he made a case that Kaschan is a symp or is scum in some way to explain away the fact he believes Korvalain's reveal, then thats fine. But he didn't. He voted for them, for being a member of town.
I pointed out he was voting for people that are PI in his eyes, i.e he didn't think Kaschan was a symp or anything along those lines, despite having a town faction reveal. And also please note, Silanah was temped to vote for Shadow as well, and refered to Kaschan and Omtose as innos.
The last comment, "Unless you think he's a symp then he's a PI yes" I am talking to Shadow. I am explaining that unless he thinks people that have come back as American, Chinese, European etc, are not symps, then they would be PI's. In the last game, one member of the syndicate at level 2 could come back from an investigation as a member of town, that is true, which is why people can only ever be PI in this game, unless you know more about them from some other method.