[Tulas Shorn]

Well if thats true then this was a bit of an anticlimactic game

[Tulas Shorn]

So can we get a resolution?

[Path-Shaper]

Well only GK here for the moment.

Considering Mafia rules are you're dead when you have the correct numbers of votes, you're little bragging is to be ignored as the dead can't speak.

As his death or copied was the conditions for the innos after reload the game is over. And it was game over when Gamelon voted for Serc. But it up to gem if Bubba broke a rule by bragging after the game was over but not confirmed by a mod as other players had to assume game was still on until Gem or me says otherwise.

But it's definitely game over from the way I read the rules that Gem set out.

Man of the match I think should be Bubba but again that is up to Gem decision.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 04 February 2010 - 02:39 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Spoiler password is gruntle

[Tulas Shorn]

Well i would say that the game was certainly over as there doesnt seem to be any vote modification mechanics, so Bubba had already died before revealing. but i am a bit biased in this

[Path-Shaper]

Well that the way I read the rules, but it is Gem baby, all I can call is game over, I believe the no reveal rule hasn't been broken so it should be inno win but that up to Gem to decide.

[Serc]

I did get a bit over excited and posted, but I was waiting for the hammer for what felt like ages....I know but it felt like ages...lol

[Ampelas]

Am I good or what?

[Path-Shaper]

Hey I can understand why you posted but next time you're jester gloat about being said role after you're lynch is confirmed by a mod. That way you can be sure of getting the win lol.

[Serc]

Path-Shaper, on 04 February 2010 - 02:45 PM, said:

Hey I can understand why you posted but next time you're jester gloat about being said role after you're lynch is confirmed by a mod. That way you can be sure of getting the win lol.

I'm out for few hrs....

[Gamelon]

Ok then, guess we won us some mafia...

[Path-Shaper]

I'm here, let me check things out.

Gem

[Path-Shaper]

Yeah, so...that's an inno win.

Bubba played way too well, I'd definitely say he's the man of the match, although innos had insane luck aswell. Just check the spoilers.

YOu guys want a scene or something? Meh...this is what you get for making my game so anticlimatic. Yes Bubba, I'm looking at you.

Thanks for playing everyone.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 04 February 2010 - 03:40 PM

[Peanutbutta]

That was a straight, old-fashioned, inno beatdown on team scum. Bubba made himself killable and THEN made himself lynchable. Straight up Man of the Match, no doubt in my mind.

[MTS]

Haha cool. And here I was looking for a replacement. Now I look foolish

[Sir Thursday]

Man, I knew I should be on the lookout for people trying to push lynches, but the train built up while I was asleep and by the time I got back today the game was over .

From the start it was obvious that this game would be pretty damn difficult to win for scum, but we really shot ourselves in the foot with the immediate reload - it was always going to be tough once Trinity and Neo became lovers. Post reload there's no way the scum are going to make it more than one day unless Trinity is out of the way. It's so much easier to cast yourself as scummy when you have someone to accuse you. We really should have been trying to drum up as much stuff as possible to drown out Trinity's inevitable case on Neo, but nothing ever really materialised...maybe I should have been more pro-active Day 2 and really forced something down people's throats. I think I was guilty of reverting to my old 'fade into the background' tactics (trying to best The Dude and Shinrei - I used to be good at it), which is absolutely not what the scum should be doing in this sort of game. When it's easy for the innos to win by lynching, you have to step up and take control of the Days to stop them.


Sir Thursday

[Gem Windcaster]

If the initial provisionals for night 1 had gone through, it would have been a totally different game, I think. Instead of killing off Morpheus and a RI you got Neo. Not to mention how close you were to lynching off Trinity the first day.
I have to say, that even though it was over really fast, it was the most interesting day 1 of mafia I've ever seen, which I am feeling a tiny bit proud of. Great job guys.

[Peanutbutta]

Just a corollary to what MTS said, that is EXACTLY why you never second guess yourself in Mafia. You did it a bunch in a recent game (Kill Bill, I think), Thursday, and it killed you over and over to second-guess yourself.

Yes, I know that my hard case for Day 1 was on Trinity rather than the RI, Omtose, but second guesses without proof are just a good way to get yourself in trouble.

[bubba]

I was trying to play as a safe NK/smith target both days. The lynch on me day two was just to convenient to pass up.

[Sir Thursday]

Peanutbutta, on 04 February 2010 - 08:15 PM, said:

Just a corollary to what MTS said, that is EXACTLY why you never second guess yourself in Mafia. You did it a bunch in a recent game (Kill Bill, I think), Thursday, and it killed you over and over to second-guess yourself.

Yes, I know that my hard case for Day 1 was on Trinity rather than the RI, Omtose, but second guesses without proof are just a good way to get yourself in trouble.

Hehe, the Kill Bill game was bit ridiculous, but here I felt like my initial orders were random - there was little to no methodology behind them. It was pure luck that my initial order happened to be on Morpheus, so I don't really feel like I was second guessing myelf there. Of course, turns out my methodology for choosing a target later was off, but I really was convinced that Emurlahn was Neo on Day 1. Meant I was rather surprised when the reload happened that night, because I didn't think there was any way the other Agents would kill Emurlahn.

Sir Thursday