[Serc]

So where did the kill go Night 2? I was the Guard that night I and guarded Hoods Path.

[Barghast]

Either you guarded the vig, or you guarded a scum player.

Mockra is to my left

[Serc]

I have Alkend on my right and Ruse left. Ruse was replaced by Barghast.

Alkend must have been King or very close to the King Night 1. Guard was my first card and I wanted and I got it.

[Barghast]

Quote

If you decide to kill, you must both submit a kill action in your action thread. If you submit different targets, the kill will not succeed.

If one of you is guarded, your kill will fail. If one of you is dead, the surviving apprentice loses his killing ability.

From the OP right at the bottom, this is about the apprentices.

Edit: spelling

This post has been edited by Barghast: 22 January 2010 - 01:20 PM

[Serc]

If I guarded the Vig, then there would still be 2 Vig attempts left so I can't have guarded the Vig.

Either,
1) I guarded scum in HP
2) Healer healed the right person
3) Apprentice's had such good cards they couldn't not use them. I find this unlikely.

[Barghast]

Good point so the vig worked.

Right Let's say it was an assistant was hit. Then Kalse reaction makes sense, he lost his partner in crime, have to check the order of actions again.

Edit: Spelling

This post has been edited by Barghast: 22 January 2010 - 01:25 PM

[Barghast]

I think the guard sounds the most plausible of what happened last night.

[Serc]

What was Kalse's reaction? Also are you going to Vig Barghast? I am unsure of how the numbers play out, but since we had no lynch today it might not be that bad idea to try for HP.

[Barghast]

UNless someone rolled the lover on day 2 and used it?

In that case the two assistants couldn't communicate and thus had the wrong targets and lost their kill for the night.

[Thyrllan]

D'riss is looking weird now ive had abit of a re-read on the thread.

Quote

Posted 20 January 2010 - 01:05 AM

Two things that stood out to me:

1) Silchas - seems a bit eager to get everyone sharing, and I don't like it, especially considering people change places and the King changes everyday, so any attempt to manipulate the cards will fail, and scum will be able to get a better read on the game.

2) Kaschan's vote on Mockra. It was supposed to be a random feeler vote to kickstart something, but he goes for the person who voted for his fake master, and he died that night. I dunno what to make of it, but it stinks.

both Silchas and Kaschan are now dead, so this looks a little suspicious.

on day 1 i had the place swap and swapped with Bargy

day 2 i had Target finder and Kalse was my target he targeted no-one so either hes inno OR he or i was guarded anyone confirm guard on day 2?

Im back in doubt now about a couple things but ima let the game play a little more before i disclose my feelings.

This post has been edited by Thyrllan: 22 January 2010 - 01:33 PM

[D'riss]

Well, Alkend had the Vig on night 2 (I was Card Finder), I'm not sure whether he used it or not though. So you didn't guard scum in HP I don't think.

[Thyrllan]

serc who were you sat beside on day 1?

[Serc]

They can still send one message if they get a lover anyway so I don't think that would stop it.

[Barghast]

I'm seeing to it right now.

My old action was vig Olar, when I realised I might survive I changed it to no kill as there was not enough evidence in my opinion to waste the last vig.

Kalse's reaction was that D'riss named Kaschan and silchas ruin on day 2 and they died that night and was suggesting that it could have been coding for the scum on who to attack. Now I pointed out it hard to co-ordinate to that level when they can't chat to their master, so who takes who they were just as likely to take out the same person.

But if Kaschan or Silchas was an assistant then their partner may want to have a revenge lynch to make up for their lost power.

It's speculation.

[Thyrllan]

ive just read what i said about Kalse when i used Target finder, so if Serc used Guard on HP then Kalse must be an Inno. others agree?

[Path-Shaper]

It's a shame, but Olar Ethil has requested a modkill:

Quote

It sucks, but I can't get any time to play right now. Even then, my connection has been so crap, that right now has been the only real time that i've been able to get on...and I don't know how long that will last.
So, yah this is my unfortunate Modkill request.

Olar Ethil (Lokiman) is dead. He was a Card Player.


It is Night 3. There is 1 hour remaining.
10 Players still alive: Alkend, Barghast, D'riss, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Kalse, Mockra, Osseric, Serc, Thyrllan

Please submit your night actions.


Sir Thursday

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 22 January 2010 - 01:35 PM

[Hood's Path]

WTH, ok can a few innos put mayor to the top of your list now and not use it, because atm its just screwing us over so badly.

As people seem to like sharing seating order, i started with Osseric to the left and Emur to the right, then Amp, then Kalse.

On Serc guarding me, yesterday i got the lover card and woke up today with the notice that it was missing, i thought that this meant thief and it is possible that it still does but i suppose they could use the same notice for being thiefed and being guarded in that case.

[Serc]

Alkend to my right - if he had the Vig Night 2, it means he used it to Vig someone (and Vig was the top card on his list) - if we believe Barghast which I kind of do.

Therefore there is still a good chance I guarded scum Night 2 in HP.

On day 1: Ruse to my left. We were lovers in fact.
On day 2: Barghast to my right.

[Barghast]

Alkend had to have used the vig if he had, as it has one shot left.

So either one of the scum didn't put in a night action.

[Hood's Path]

Thyrllan, on 22 January 2010 - 01:35 PM, said:

ive just read what i said about Kalse when i used Target finder, so if Serc used Guard on HP then Kalse must be an Inno. others agree?

ok ive just got up, but im not following this, why?

Also if Kalse didnt target anyone it doesnt make him inno as PS changed the target finder rules earlier to just show the card target, which means that a null result from Kalse could mean he was the assistant as they wouldnt be targetting anyone with their cards