[Tulas Shorn]

Quote

'Chef' - Karosis

When I saw this, I immediately thought of a Klingon saying:

"Who the hell are you!"

"Name's Karosis.....Kitchenwares"

[Path-Shaper]

it is Day 5, 7 hours left

8 people still alive:
Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Tennes, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn

5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night

no one has voted

[Alkend]

Wee and only 7 hours left. How long has it been since Atrahal, Kaschan, Telas, and Thyrlann have posted?

[Alkend]

The last time all 4 posted was right around when night finished. That's about 17ish hours ago.

Telas, on 13 October 2009 - 09:52 PM, said:

Well we have you claiming Kalse was Kirk, and we have Tennes claiming that you are lying because Kalse was not Kirk.

Someone is lying.

As you say there was no pressure on you, whereas the day before Tennes was nearly lynched.
What I did not like was Tennes talking about who he thought Kirk really was. That is not a good inno tactic.
Thoughwith your reveal, I did not like that a reveal could take place afterdeath, though before it was not allowed. Contradictions.

Not sure at this point, definitely needs some looking over though.

Atrahal, on 13 October 2009 - 10:23 PM, said:

Yeah I have to run to class myself. I doubt that I will be back on tonight.


Cross post with the scene.

Oh the irony of Korv's last post.

Kaschan, on 13 October 2009 - 10:36 PM, said:

Path-Shaper, on 13 October 2009 - 06:32 PM, said:

It is Day 5

8 players still alive
Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis,Kaschan, Thyrlann, Telas, Tennes, Tulas Shorn,
5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night

Just for my reference

edit bah cross with PS

Thyrllan, on 13 October 2009 - 10:37 PM, said:

In all honesty, I'm feeling more inclined towards believing Atrahal. Or, at least I'm less willing to dismiss his reveal right away with his subsequent claims.

This is in all likelihood d-day, no? Surely if there's a Kirk out there he can reveal and we can take out a scum thus buying us time?

[Tulas Shorn]

I've got about 10 mins left, and then I gotta leave.

I will be back in 5-6 hours which is well before deadline, so if you want me around to help decide a lynch AND determine who should be guarded, don't get all hasty on me, plz.

[Tulas Shorn]

Ok, later peoples.

[Path-Shaper]

it is Day 5, 5.5 hours left

8 people still alive:
Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Tennes, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn

5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night

no one has voted

[Tennes]

Alright, interesting night, I have 13 minutes to do an assignment and then have to go hand it in, but I'll throw down a vote first. I don't like Telas, he's been under the radar all game, surfacing now and again to ping people's scumdar. I don't know why he's still around, but its time to:

vote Telas

I may be back before deadline, but don't count on it. It'll be tight.

By night, I of course mean RL night, the time when I slept through most of the conversation.

This post has been edited by Tennes: 14 October 2009 - 05:20 PM

[Karosis]

what about atrahal, or the inconsistency with tulas and myself? or even alkend? telas i barely have a read on. dinner time, though if we cant come to a consensus i am voting night.

[Alkend]

I think Telas is a good choice... but there's a LOT about Atrahal that just doesn't add up.

If it IS D-Day, we need 100% consensus to achieve a lynch.

On top of that, two players haven't posted since night and two players haven't posted since day began! It's guaranteed that AT LEAST one of them is inno.

[Alkend]

I'm not sure how I feel about voting night. It's Day 5 and if scum really only get a kill every OTHER night, then we aren't even in danger of losing today with a bad lynch (unless there's a vig or what not) because there won't be a night kill. On the other hand, it's quite possible circumstances have occurred that have prevented NKs.

What if Atrahal is a killer, for example, and was blocked Night 1 by Tulas, got a kill Night 2, and then got stopped Night 3 by someone like McCoy healing the right person, and then got a kill Night 4. This seems like a very feasible scenario, but without more reveals, we're very much unable to make that determination... even if we got more reveals and nobody said McCoy, it could mean that it was Korv.

So with THAT in mind, voting night would be beneficial to the town because it doesn't speed up the tempo of the game (unless there are suddenly two kills). But it basically relies on NAs to bail us out.

[Path-Shaper]

it is Day 5, 4 hours and 27 minutes left

8 people still alive:
5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night

1 vote Telas (Tennes)

7 people did not vote: Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn

[Alkend]

With 4 people still outstanding to reveal, it's possible a counter-reveal would surface for Scotty, but not THAT likely. As one of the first to reveal after day started, Tennes gains credibility because he claimed a character almost certainly to be in the game and if he's scum he's gambling huge that Scotty is already dead.

So IMO Tennes is the most likely person to be innocent out of everyone that has revealed.

He has voted for Telas. If it really is 3-to-5 right now, we have a decent shot at hitting a scum if we can start to PI people. If I take Tennes to be inno and myself to be inno, I have a 1-in-2 (3 in 6) chance of Telas being scum. If scum don't get a kill tonight, it's blocked, or it's not 3-to-5, then lynching Telas only hurts if he's town but it doesn't end the game. The only way we lose is if Telas is town, scum get a kill tonight, it won't be stopped, and it's 3-to-5.

But honestly, is it even possible to lynch anyone else at this point?

[Karosis]

Alkend, on 14 October 2009 - 06:00 PM, said:

I'm not sure how I feel about voting night. It's Day 5 and if scum really only get a kill every OTHER night, then we aren't even in danger of losing today with a bad lynch (unless there's a vig or what not) because there won't be a night kill. On the other hand, it's quite possible circumstances have occurred that have prevented NKs.

What if Atrahal is a killer, for example, and was blocked Night 1 by Tulas, got a kill Night 2, and then got stopped Night 3 by someone like McCoy healing the right person, and then got a kill Night 4. This seems like a very feasible scenario, but without more reveals, we're very much unable to make that determination... even if we got more reveals and nobody said McCoy, it could mean that it was Korv.

So with THAT in mind, voting night would be beneficial to the town because it doesn't speed up the tempo of the game (unless there are suddenly two kills). But it basically relies on NAs to bail us out.

if we do lose one person though it may make our lynch tomorrow more clear cut. I would like to see an actual case on telas before i vote. but if we are going to gamble, i would go atrahal first. if it seems like not everyone is going to be on i recommend letting day time out.

[Karosis]

Alkend, on 14 October 2009 - 06:06 PM, said:

With 4 people still outstanding to reveal, it's possible a counter-reveal would surface for Scotty, but not THAT likely. As one of the first to reveal after day started, Tennes gains credibility because he claimed a character almost certainly to be in the game and if he's scum he's gambling huge that Scotty is already dead.

So IMO Tennes is the most likely person to be innocent out of everyone that has revealed.

He has voted for Telas. If it really is 3-to-5 right now, we have a decent shot at hitting a scum if we can start to PI people. If I take Tennes to be inno and myself to be inno, I have a 1-in-2 (3 in 6) chance of Telas being scum. If scum don't get a kill tonight, it's blocked, or it's not 3-to-5, then lynching Telas only hurts if he's town but it doesn't end the game. The only way we lose is if Telas is town, scum get a kill tonight, it won't be stopped, and it's 3-to-5.

But honestly, is it even possible to lynch anyone else at this point?

i dont like that logic, but i cant fault the last statement. i doubt we could get a lynch even if we wanted to. i will be about for the next three or four hours. i want to hear from everyone else though.

[Alkend]

Well I'm a numbers guy, so that's where I base my logic, but ultimately, if I vote wrong and lose, then I am still disappointed in the outcome. I'm just trying to justify why it may be OK to get a lynch off today. But the amount of non-speakers left in the game has it way too up in the air.

Dunno where everyone else is... there's no modkill timer, just when the mods feel people aren't playing the game.

[Path-Shaper]

it is Day 5, 4 hours left

8 people still alive:
5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night

1 vote Telas (Tennes)

7 people did not vote: Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 14 October 2009 - 06:31 PM

[Karosis]

this is ridiculous, no one is here and voting. if you want that lynch, why not vote?

vote atrahal

i think if we trust tennes and i do, then kalse was sulu and atrahal is lying. his reveal didnt make any sense either.

[Atrahal]

RL has been really busy for me today. I haven't had a chance to read up on what has happened yet. I should be able to get on in little over an hour from now. Hopefully someone else will be on then.

[Atrahal]

Karosis, on 14 October 2009 - 07:22 PM, said:

this is ridiculous, no one is here and voting. if you want that lynch, why not vote?

vote atrahal

i think if we trust tennes and i do, then kalse was sulu and atrahal is lying. his reveal didnt make any sense either.

Hold up there big guy. Nice cross post.

What I want to know is why Kalse would claim to be Kirk to me if he was Sulu? That doesn't make any sense of course if you don't believe me at all then that doesn't matter. Then there is Tennes casually disregarding Kalses death scene. The only person who said that they weren't putting clues into the scenes was mental not GL. Then there is Tennes knowing that Kalse was innocent and letting him die. That doesn't add up to me at all. There are several players who played the last game enough to claim to be roles. I trust Tulas as he has played like a guard. But I don't trust any one else.