[bwgan]

@ DiBs - Well my opinion on Morgy is that the post I quoted is rubbish...and if that one is rubbish how many more are? So what reason would he have to lie? Ummmm,...

@ Bent - You are my favourite too you know that...believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

[bwgan]

Shinrei, on Aug 6 2009, 05:35 PM, said:

And kudos to bwgan for rising above her cuteness and biting back at people

Awww, I thought I was still being nice... ...night Shin...


Edit: Oh, bugger...there's me saying I try not to spam and what have I gone and done....

This post has been edited by bwgan: 06 August 2009 - 04:40 PM

[Bent]

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 12:38 PM, said:

.believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

Said while pming Spoiler heaven saying, "please don't be mad at me Bent, you know I am scum and have to say these things....

[bwgan]

Bent, on Aug 6 2009, 05:36 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 12:35 PM, said:

we also seem to be heading for the second non lynch whichis pretty annoying really

agreed.

I also agree, but if this is Dday I can understand the reluctance....especially as my paranoia this game is almost as bad as the last one...where I was still looking for scum and sending panicked pms to PS even AFTER we had won!

[drinksinbars]

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 05:38 PM, said:

@ DiBs - Well my opinion on Morgy is that the post I quoted is rubbish...and if that one is rubbish how many more are? So what reason would he have to lie? Ummmm,...

@ Bent - You are my favourite too you know that...believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

thats the thing, usually he has a case or two every game and he usually doesnt last this long, if bent hadnt of cleared him i would have been very suspicious.

[bwgan]

Bent, on Aug 6 2009, 05:42 PM, said:

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 12:38 PM, said:

.believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

Said while pming Spoiler heaven saying, "please don't be mad at me Bent, you know I am scum and have to say these things....

You are a cheeky, cheeky person...

[drinksinbars]

can we even get a lynch now? with shin gone theres only three of us left on.

[Obdigore]

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 11:43 AM, said:

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 05:38 PM, said:

@ DiBs - Well my opinion on Morgy is that the post I quoted is rubbish...and if that one is rubbish how many more are? So what reason would he have to lie? Ummmm,...

@ Bent - You are my favourite too you know that...believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

thats the thing, usually he has a case or two every game and he usually doesnt last this long, if bent hadnt of cleared him i would have been very suspicious.

That is assuming bent is a finder, as well as assuming morgy isn't a symp.

I mean... what if his masters are DIBS and Bent and they didn't know Morgy was their symp?

If you guys want to throw possibilities out there, put them all out there.

[Obdigore]

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 11:44 AM, said:

can we even get a lynch now? with shin gone theres only three of us left on.

Since SM is the one Anon User, and is just watching the game, we could.

Of course he won't post.

[Morgoth]

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 06:31 PM, said:

dont let me having a sore head affect you, i am interested in your opinion on morgy, cause he has been largely absent sonce the find result.

I've just had much more than I expected to do at work. One of the cases I've been working on has turned into a full fledged legal battle and I'm spending most of my days in corespondence with a law firm consisting of lawyers who have absolutely no idea what they're talking about. It's great fun but very taxing, so I find I have little energy to spend on mafia in the evnings.

It's a shame in some ways, because I've been wanting to play this game for some time, but alas. Still, I wouldn't marginalize my input as much as you guys have. I've given my opinion in as much as I've had the chance to form one of value, and I still stand by what I've been saying now for the last three days. bwgan is the killer and that's that.

[Obdigore]

ooo maybe morgy signed in anon!

[drinksinbars]

Obdigore, on Aug 6 2009, 05:45 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 11:43 AM, said:

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 05:38 PM, said:

@ DiBs - Well my opinion on Morgy is that the post I quoted is rubbish...and if that one is rubbish how many more are? So what reason would he have to lie? Ummmm,...

@ Bent - You are my favourite too you know that...believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

thats the thing, usually he has a case or two every game and he usually doesnt last this long, if bent hadnt of cleared him i would have been very suspicious.

That is assuming bent is a finder, as well as assuming morgy isn't a symp.

I mean... what if his masters are DIBS and Bent and they didn't know Morgy was their symp?

If you guys want to throw possibilities out there, put them all out there.

well my problem with that is day 1 i was trying tp push bents lynch quite hard, while toward the end bent was pushing morgos lynch so i while i could be on morgos team, i couldnt be on bents and he couldnt be on morgos. regardless of which way we look at it bent guilty or inno clears morgo. so if we are going to lynch it needs to be someone else.

At this point i am almost desperate enough to look at who wasnt on at the time of the reveal as its less likely that any killers or the evil guard was on (assuming bent is telling the truth).

[bwgan]

Morgoth, on Aug 6 2009, 05:46 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 06:31 PM, said:

dont let me having a sore head affect you, i am interested in your opinion on morgy, cause he has been largely absent sonce the find result.

I've just had much more than I expected to do at work. One of the cases I've been working on has turned into a full fledged legal battle and I'm spending most of my days in corespondence with a law firm consisting of lawyers who have absolutely no idea what they're talking about. It's great fun but very taxing, so I find I have little energy to spend on mafia in the evnings.

It's a shame in some ways, because I've been wanting to play this game for some time, but alas. Still, I wouldn't marginalize my input as much as you guys have. I've given my opinion in as much as I've had the chance to form one of value, and I still stand by what I've been saying now for the last three days. bwgan is the killer and that's that.

I haven't marinalised your input...I called BS on one of your posts...ie I didn't believe you when you said, oooo really, didn't think of that possiblity...when we all know that you think of every possibility.

[drinksinbars]

Morgoth, on Aug 6 2009, 05:46 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 06:31 PM, said:

dont let me having a sore head affect you, i am interested in your opinion on morgy, cause he has been largely absent sonce the find result.

I've just had much more than I expected to do at work. One of the cases I've been working on has turned into a full fledged legal battle and I'm spending most of my days in corespondence with a law firm consisting of lawyers who have absolutely no idea what they're talking about. It's great fun but very taxing, so I find I have little energy to spend on mafia in the evnings.

It's a shame in some ways, because I've been wanting to play this game for some time, but alas. Still, I wouldn't marginalize my input as much as you guys have. I've given my opinion in as much as I've had the chance to form one of value, and I still stand by what I've been saying now for the last three days. bwgan is the killer and that's that.

then vote by your conviction mate. as above i dont see how you could be a killer with bents reveal. you could of course be a symp, but you havent defended anyone so chances of that are low.

[drinksinbars]

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 05:50 PM, said:

Morgoth, on Aug 6 2009, 05:46 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 06:31 PM, said:

dont let me having a sore head affect you, i am interested in your opinion on morgy, cause he has been largely absent sonce the find result.

I've just had much more than I expected to do at work. One of the cases I've been working on has turned into a full fledged legal battle and I'm spending most of my days in corespondence with a law firm consisting of lawyers who have absolutely no idea what they're talking about. It's great fun but very taxing, so I find I have little energy to spend on mafia in the evnings.

It's a shame in some ways, because I've been wanting to play this game for some time, but alas. Still, I wouldn't marginalize my input as much as you guys have. I've given my opinion in as much as I've had the chance to form one of value, and I still stand by what I've been saying now for the last three days. bwgan is the killer and that's that.

I haven't marinalised your input...I called BS on one of your posts...ie I didn't believe you when you said, oooo really, didn't think of that possiblity...when we all know that you think of every possibility.

oh dear, dont encourage him, his ego is big enough.

[bwgan]

@ DiBs - that's my point though.

[bwgan]

But I do see why you say he probably isn't guilty...

[Bent]

Dibs, we have just enough to get a lynch...me,you,obi,bwgan,and morgy....however, none of us will self vote, so the only ones we could lynch are DK,shin or slick.....

[Obdigore]

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 11:48 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Aug 6 2009, 05:45 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Aug 6 2009, 11:43 AM, said:

bwgan, on Aug 6 2009, 05:38 PM, said:

@ DiBs - Well my opinion on Morgy is that the post I quoted is rubbish...and if that one is rubbish how many more are? So what reason would he have to lie? Ummmm,...

@ Bent - You are my favourite too you know that...believing you are probably scum (in the nicest possible way) has nothing to do with it.

thats the thing, usually he has a case or two every game and he usually doesnt last this long, if bent hadnt of cleared him i would have been very suspicious.

That is assuming bent is a finder, as well as assuming morgy isn't a symp.

I mean... what if his masters are DIBS and Bent and they didn't know Morgy was their symp?

If you guys want to throw possibilities out there, put them all out there.

well my problem with that is day 1 i was trying tp push bents lynch quite hard, while toward the end bent was pushing morgos lynch so i while i could be on morgos team, i couldnt be on bents and he couldnt be on morgos. regardless of which way we look at it bent guilty or inno clears morgo. so if we are going to lynch it needs to be someone else.

At this point i am almost desperate enough to look at who wasnt on at the time of the reveal as its less likely that any killers or the evil guard was on (assuming bent is telling the truth).

Unless bent is your symp or morgy is bents symp.

It could be

Bent + Shin? Bwgan? with Morgy as Symp?

Or DIBS + Morgy, with Bent only knowing DIBS as master?

With 11 people, I'm not sure we can count on Killer+Killer+Symp as the role distribution.

I also think Tapper was rolled, and he could have very well been the Guard who Guarded Bent, assuming that wasn't a lie.

It could also be Bwgan + Shin with SM or D'rek as symp - I still think its very odd that SM said after I left for sleep during day one that he wanted to continue the pissing match with me when I got back, and he attempted to force it. His play has been very bad all game long if he is an inno.

It could be DIBS + SM with Morgy as a symp. Right now with the lack of participation from a lot of people, I can't tell who is what.

[drinksinbars]

out of those three i would say shin is most likely the killer. i still think if slick was evil he would not be voting for night or suggesting it two nights in a row to give us the best chance of voting scum off. dk hasnt struck me as scum at any point and i can usually tell when he is scum.