[Hood's Path]

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 02:18 PM, said:

 Hood's Path, on Jul 29 2009, 02:24 AM, said:

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 04:10 AM, said:

Hrm thats interesting.

So, HP, what did you do?

well thyrllan i gave you a healing ability. which you should have gotten and obviously didnt.

vote thyrllan

i thought you were least likely to be killed and actually out of driss and yourself i expected you to be han.

Thats funny, I received Catapults from the Imperial Armory last night, and they certainly don't let me heal anything.

That would be why I asked you, because you said you give out guards and heals...

Have not yet read past this post.

i definitely supplied a healing ability to you. i am in charge of logistics and supplies offensive and defensive. i dont see how catapults could eb construed as healing ability. so i assume you recieved a vig f you are telling the truth.

[Emurlahn]

 D'riss, on Jul 29 2009, 02:12 PM, said:

 Emurlahn, on Jul 29 2009, 02:10 PM, said:

Yes and ive said i dont like him either i could go for either of you just right now i find your actions over the night more scummy than HP's bullshitting

Meh, all I said was who I wanted to lynch/found scummy.

Yes, this could be used for WIFOM.

On the other hand, so could the same things said in the day.

Kills will be WIFOM anyway.

It doesn't matter when you say it, if you say stuff like that, it can be used for WIFOM.

So unless we never say who we suspect at all, then it doesn't really matter when.

ok theres voicing your suspicions and then theres doing it like this

Quote

If HP survives the night-which he almost certainly will, he should be lynched.

that is not at all helpful to innos, that would have been better said after night ended after youd seen if he had survived, and definitely looks to me like a possible signal to a master or such not to kill him

[Hood's Path]

sadly i dont see how if i am scum thyrllan is scum, but as i am inno that doesnt matter.

[Thyrllan]

Oh my... the intrigue!

As I said, I received Catapults from the Imperial Armory last night. I recieved no heal power whatsoever.

So, you were either guarded, or lying about your role.

I still think your reveal is bullshit, so I will
vote Hoods Path

[D'riss]

Of course now we have a problem.

If Thyr is telling the truth it makes HPs role of giving out roles more plausible, if there's another similar role in the game.

And adds the possibility both are telling the truth. For example, assuming role giving roles exist, we don't know what happens if two roles are given to one person.

[Hood's Path]

alright pathshaper confirmed, offensive supplies are catapults and are a heal, defensive supplies are fireworks and a re a guard.

beats me.

sorry thyr

remove vote

[Hood's Path]

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 02:23 PM, said:

Oh my... the intrigue!

As I said, I received Catapults from the Imperial Armory last night. I recieved no heal power whatsoever.

So, you were either guarded, or lying about your role.

I still think your reveal is bullshit, so I will
vote Hoods Path

just ask pathshaper what role that equates to, he confirmed with me that catapults are healing.

[Hood's Path]

so i did guess right and thyr is han army.

[Hood's Path]

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 02:23 PM, said:

Oh my... the intrigue!

As I said, I received Catapults from the Imperial Armory last night. I recieved no heal power whatsoever.

So, you were either guarded, or lying about your role.

I still think your reveal is bullshit, so I will
vote Hoods Path

i do find this seriously bizarre though, i know your inno, i told you i targetted you, you admitted you recieved supplies so you know my role is genuine. Seriously, wtf?

[Thyrllan]

He told me I received a Vig via the Catapults.

You just keep making shit up.

How in any way are 'catapults' a 'heal'? They blow stuff up!

[D'riss]

 Emurlahn, on Jul 29 2009, 02:22 PM, said:

 D'riss, on Jul 29 2009, 02:12 PM, said:

 Emurlahn, on Jul 29 2009, 02:10 PM, said:

Yes and ive said i dont like him either i could go for either of you just right now i find your actions over the night more scummy than HP's bullshitting

Meh, all I said was who I wanted to lynch/found scummy.

Yes, this could be used for WIFOM.

On the other hand, so could the same things said in the day.

Kills will be WIFOM anyway.

It doesn't matter when you say it, if you say stuff like that, it can be used for WIFOM.

So unless we never say who we suspect at all, then it doesn't really matter when.

ok theres voicing your suspicions and then theres doing it like this

Quote

If HP survives the night-which he almost certainly will, he should be lynched.

that is not at all helpful to innos, that would have been better said after night ended after youd seen if he had survived, and definitely looks to me like a possible signal to a master or such not to kill him

Considering that i'd been saying that all the previous day I fail to see how it matters.
I wasn't sure I would survive.
HP was, and still is, to my mind the most likely scum.
Lynching him today yields the most information.
Considering lynching him the next day had been discussed during the day it hardly hurts.
Considering that he was such a likely lynch, and the fact that I thought he was scum, I saw the chances of him dying as negligible.

[Thyrllan]

 Hood's Path, on Jul 29 2009, 08:26 AM, said:

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 02:23 PM, said:

Oh my... the intrigue!

As I said, I received Catapults from the Imperial Armory last night. I recieved no heal power whatsoever.

So, you were either guarded, or lying about your role.

I still think your reveal is bullshit, so I will
vote Hoods Path

i do find this seriously bizarre though, i know your inno, i told you i targetted you, you admitted you recieved supplies so you know my role is genuine. Seriously, wtf?

You said you targetted me. You said you gave me a heal. I received no heal. I received a Vig.

Therefore, you were guarded or lying.

You then said that Catapults are a heal... how in any stretch of the imagination would one describte catapults as a 'heal'? A guard, maybe, because you couldn't move your army. A vig for sure.

I GOT NO HEAL, YOUR REVEAL IS BULLSHIT, AND YOU TOOK WHAT I SAID REGARDING CATAPULTS AND TRIED TO INCORPORATE IT INTO YOUR BULLSHIT REVEAL.

[D'riss]

Vote Hoods Path

He's bullshitting with his role and I still think he's scum.

[Hood's Path]

well he told me if you have 3 armies a, b and c

a is going to kill b, so c uses catapults on b to surpress an attack.

[Hood's Path]

seriously i am going to quote the role pm and expanation pm of the powers i can supply if this isnt resolved.

[Thyrllan]

And that is a guard, not a heal.

You said you gave me a heal, I received no heal. You were either guarded, which would only happen in your scenario if PS had contacted you before the game for an action for a person for night one, which you said didn't happen, or the evils have a guard.

TMDI 1 or 2 does not lend itself to having two teaching roles, and an evil guard, which is what would need to happen in your scenario.

[Thyrllan]

Then you will be modkilled, or the shit you quote will have to be changed.

If you truly are innocent, getting modkilled during the day is a foolish ploy.

[Hood's Path]

mate i gave you a heal and your right i explained it wrong but then the explanation i reciecved makes little sense either. just check with ps what a catapult means ffs.

[Thyrllan]

I did, he has yet to respond.

[Hood's Path]

 Thyrllan, on Jul 29 2009, 02:34 PM, said:

Then you will be modkilled, or the shit you quote will have to be changed.

If you truly are innocent, getting modkilled during the day is a foolish ploy.

i am seriously beyond caring, i was given no info about what i supplied until you came on thread and said catapult then i got told that some info might be useful. i asked how they could be construed as such and then the mod came back with the abc thing for explanation.

supposedly fireworks guard by scaring people shitless. catapults aid in defence. if pathshaper says you got a catapult but it means a vig to you, while i get told it means a heal, well the common factor is there is a fuck up somewhere. i know you arent lying cause otherwise why would i get told what catapult means after you said it, so you must have recieved a pm.