[Hood's Path]

lol it just my view if he went to the point of saying that their could be these variations of the vigs and finders, considering the potential mechanics that the lovers can have behind them, I would have assumed they would be mentioned.

[Liosan]

Okay, that was severely disappointing. I have a lot to say, but first off,

"Mm," Moriva grunted, shouldering past both D'Varae and Lissa to get to his office, slamming the door shut behind him before grabbing for a small looking glass. He'd managed to wipe most of the rouge from her lips off, but he could have sworn his mouth was still stained with a vague red. In the hall he heard D'Varae and Lissa acknowledge someone, just moments before his door opened and slammed shut again, this time with Chayka pressing her back to the wood, staring at him with smoldering eyes as her hand fumbled for the lock.

He had already set the glass back down, barely bracing himself as she scrambled over the desk and into his arms, both clawing at each other desperately. He grabbed her hips and with a twist, forced her up against the wall next to the bookshelf behind them, fingers clawing at the laces of her dress. "What the hell sort of performance was that?" he muttered through her lips. "We had lines, plans, and..." He groaned, barely able to gasp out, "what the hell happened?"

Now I've gotta collect my thoughts.

[Emurlahn]

ooh i'm all hot and bothered now. what was that, mills and boon?

[Hood's Path]

At the moment though Meanas seems the most suspicious.

[Galayn Lord]

Barghast, on Jun 29 2009, 09:27 AM, said:

Well, despite PB's bold predictions, we're not finished. Losing another town blows though.

And thank 1500 pound squid someone is finally paying attention to me, even if it is omgus over my case. GL, why is it hard to believe Gam? Holding a counterreveal up to now would make no sense, so I see no reason not to believe him. Even if you didn't believe it (at first, or still?), saying so over and over again in several posts is what struck me as a little insidious. One clear "we should be careful in accepting this blindly" post would have sufficed. I'll admit, there may not be anything beyond that for the case on you, but that in and of itself is not "dust". You made a case on HP based on "he asks a lot of questions" ffs.

No, I didn't. There was more to that case and you know it.

Just like you know that I went over Gam's reveal, and actually countered Liosan when he said its probably a fake. But good job re-stating your lies in an attempt to incriminate me.

[Emurlahn]

Hood's Path, on Jun 29 2009, 03:33 PM, said:

At the moment though Meanas seems the most suspicious.

i have been saying that for days. he could easily be dg or a killer.

i dont htink you should waste your disinfect on lio or korlat as we know they cant be dg, go for meanas, or eloth or even bargie or me. One of the unknowns.

[Emurlahn]

fuck even gl, he is pretty suspicious of you and is as good a bet for dg as any.

[Hood's Path]

I think Gamelon might have considered testing someone else for the DG after Liosan and Korlat reveal.

[Gamelon]

Liosan, on Jun 29 2009, 10:30 AM, said:

Okay, that was severely disappointing. I have a lot to say, but first off,

"Mm," Moriva grunted, shouldering past both D'Varae and Lissa to get to his office, slamming the door shut behind him before grabbing for a small looking glass. He'd managed to wipe most of the rouge from her lips off, but he could have sworn his mouth was still stained with a vague red. In the hall he heard D'Varae and Lissa acknowledge someone, just moments before his door opened and slammed shut again, this time with Chayka pressing her back to the wood, staring at him with smoldering eyes as her hand fumbled for the lock.

He had already set the glass back down, barely bracing himself as she scrambled over the desk and into his arms, both clawing at each other desperately. He grabbed her hips and with a twist, forced her up against the wall next to the bookshelf behind them, fingers clawing at the laces of her dress. "What the hell sort of performance was that?" he muttered through her lips. "We had lines, plans, and..." He groaned, barely able to gasp out, "what the hell happened?"

Now I've gotta collect my thoughts.

no lionk to were thats from?....how can we authenticate this?

[Galayn Lord]

Emurlahn, on Jun 29 2009, 09:35 AM, said:

fuck even gl, he is pretty suspicious of you and is as good a bet for dg as any.

of who, HP? Not anymore.

Terrible mistakes, but Game hasn't countered his sister reveal, so there is no reason to not believe it.

[Galayn Lord]

Barghast, on Jun 29 2009, 09:37 AM, said:

Well, I can believe I'm mistaken if you can be a little clearer what you're saying. I just called what I saw, no lies. Your counter of Liosan still managed to sound like it contained a big "if". You'll notice I actually quoted the whole post in my case, so it's not like I'm doctoring what you said.

edit:cross post - this is at GL

And yet all those posts are me trying to see if there was any advantage for the DG or Scum to reveal as him at that time. I was trying to think of an advantage, because if I could, then we couldn't trust the reveal. You know, cross off all the possabilities and then whatever is left must be what is going on?

You know as well as I do most people don't even read teh quotes in a case, but just what the case-maker says the quote says.

I don't understand how you guys play this game just believing any reveals that happen and not trying to think about how/why someone would lie to reveal that character.

[Gamelon]

i think i hear crickets chirping

[Galayn Lord]

I'm somewhat shocked - but I am hoping that Barghast is going back and re-reading his 'case'.

Game you said your actions are in... so now we wait for the Scum/DG.

[Hood's Path]

So GL who are you suspicious of then?

[Liosan]

Ampelas, on Jun 29 2009, 01:17 AM, said:

Galain, on Jun 29 2009, 06:45 AM, said:

I'm retiring early tonight, probably won't last any night lynches (assuming 'morning' for Morg is night for me). I have no more theories and no fancy reveals so if you are going to lynch me, that's fine. GL, Kaschan, or whoever the DG is has won the game. Congrats. If you don't lynch me, I will be on, probably before the timer is up, and throw my vote wherever it's needed.

Night.

Oh, FFS, keep saying that. Do you really think a 21-players game could be over on day 4?

Anyways.

The reveals leave me cold. I'm willing to believe they are not killers, but if the first DG is dead, anyone can become him, Big Ben style. I don't think that applies to Duncan, and he would know if it happened to his sister, so those two I'll keep trusting. But not Liosan + Korlat.

I find strange Liosan outed his partner so easily, specially when he mentions he's "inno power role". Then again in this game, seems people have put as much thinking in their reveals as what color socks they'll put on in the morning.

It was actually Korlat that suggested revealing first, which actually made me think he was infected. He suggested it after the Galain case and vote and I thought it would be easily defended against, as it all looked pretty stupid to me, but then some other silly bastards (scum/infected maybe?) jumped on and I really didn't have time yesterday to sit there and make sure I didn't get lynched, so I took the easy way out by revealing because Korlat was already on board with it. Also because we are powerless and because this is a cult game (i.e. paired players aren't that effective anyway when your partner could be cult), I felt it wasn't that huge of a blow to team inno to reveal. Yeah, the killers won't want us around at the end of the game, but I tend to think they should be far more concerned about the DG than random innocents at this point. Besides, even if we manage to stop the DG, one of the pair is going to have to die to get the CF before the other one is CI.

I'm not infected, by the way, but I understand you might feel it necessary to disinfect me anyway, Game, and I can't really convince you otherwise.

With the CF, I now feel silly going after Galain, but I still feel strongly he was a symp, though it's all unprovable speculation at this point. Normally, though, an inno PB will give us a list of targets to go after before he dies, and all he did was give us some half-cocked theory that I didn't understand on my first read-through. I'm gonna try to make heads or tails of it in my next post. After he did his about-face on me, I was sure he was then an infected symp trying to either curry favor with the DG or inherit his role (depending on whether I turned up inno or infected). Still, either way there probably would have been better targets to lynch yesterday, and if I had been around to think about it more, I probably would have gone after Kaschan instead of OMGUSing on Galain. Hindsight and all that.

Anyway, time to figure out PB's doomsay and see if I can solidify my suspicion of Kaschan.

[Gamelon]

Gamelon, on Jun 29 2009, 10:37 AM, said:

Liosan, on Jun 29 2009, 10:30 AM, said:

Okay, that was severely disappointing. I have a lot to say, but first off,

"Mm," Moriva grunted, shouldering past both D'Varae and Lissa to get to his office, slamming the door shut behind him before grabbing for a small looking glass. He'd managed to wipe most of the rouge from her lips off, but he could have sworn his mouth was still stained with a vague red. In the hall he heard D'Varae and Lissa acknowledge someone, just moments before his door opened and slammed shut again, this time with Chayka pressing her back to the wood, staring at him with smoldering eyes as her hand fumbled for the lock.

He had already set the glass back down, barely bracing himself as she scrambled over the desk and into his arms, both clawing at each other desperately. He grabbed her hips and with a twist, forced her up against the wall next to the bookshelf behind them, fingers clawing at the laces of her dress. "What the hell sort of performance was that?" he muttered through her lips. "We had lines, plans, and..." He groaned, barely able to gasp out, "what the hell happened?"

Now I've gotta collect my thoughts.

no lionk to were thats from?....how can we authenticate this?

Let me repeat myself

HOW ARE WE SUPPOSED TO AUTHENTICATE THIS!!!??!?!?

[Liosan]

Emurlahn, on Jun 29 2009, 10:32 AM, said:

ooh i'm all hot and bothered now. what was that, mills and boon?

Korlat just gave me the text. I think he's going to confirm where it's from.

[Liosan]

Gamelon, on Jun 29 2009, 11:01 AM, said:

Gamelon, on Jun 29 2009, 10:37 AM, said:

Liosan, on Jun 29 2009, 10:30 AM, said:

Okay, that was severely disappointing. I have a lot to say, but first off,

"Mm," Moriva grunted, shouldering past both D'Varae and Lissa to get to his office, slamming the door shut behind him before grabbing for a small looking glass. He'd managed to wipe most of the rouge from her lips off, but he could have sworn his mouth was still stained with a vague red. In the hall he heard D'Varae and Lissa acknowledge someone, just moments before his door opened and slammed shut again, this time with Chayka pressing her back to the wood, staring at him with smoldering eyes as her hand fumbled for the lock.

He had already set the glass back down, barely bracing himself as she scrambled over the desk and into his arms, both clawing at each other desperately. He grabbed her hips and with a twist, forced her up against the wall next to the bookshelf behind them, fingers clawing at the laces of her dress. "What the hell sort of performance was that?" he muttered through her lips. "We had lines, plans, and..." He groaned, barely able to gasp out, "what the hell happened?"

Now I've gotta collect my thoughts.

no lionk to were thats from?....how can we authenticate this?

Let me repeat myself

HOW ARE WE SUPPOSED TO AUTHENTICATE THIS!!!??!?!?

What, you think I filled it up with random words, Mad Libs style?

[Emurlahn]

i think it proves they can talk off thread, but does nought for their alignment.

kaschan and meanas are two total unknowns in my view, i hope neither is roled or we could be in for a long hall.