Help
Well it seems we have lurkers
Mafia 46 - Monastery Murders Game Thread
#662
Liosan 
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 92
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 01:58 AM
I ain't one of them, been busy is all.
@ Amp: dude, I couldn't have cared less about your case on me day 1 (especially since it wasn't your case, but Meanas' )
but good job trying to make me look all OMGU-y.
ATM, I don't have anything stronger than that, I'm afraid.
I'd really like to hear more from Tellan this weekend.
edit: form should be from
@ Amp: dude, I couldn't have cared less about your case on me day 1 (especially since it wasn't your case, but Meanas' )
but good job trying to make me look all OMGU-y.
ATM, I don't have anything stronger than that, I'm afraid.
I'd really like to hear more from Tellan this weekend.
edit: form should be from
This post has been edited by Liosan: 30 May 2009 - 01:58 AM
#663
Path-Shaper
- Mafia Modgod
-
- Group: Game Mod
- Posts: 1,255
- Joined: 01-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 02:03 AM
It is Day 3. 17 hours and 56 minutes remaining.
13 Players still alive: Ampelas, D'riss, Fener, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Kessobahn, Korvalain, Liosan, Meanas, Mockra, Ruse, Shadow, Tellan
7 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night
1 vote for Ampelas: ( Liosan )
Players not voted: Ampelas, D'riss, Fener, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Kessobahn, Korvalain, Meanas, Mockra, Ruse, Shadow, Tellan
Venge wasn't here to announce the weekend mod-kill freeze, and I"m too lazy to figure out the timezones. Alt explained the timing earlier.
13 Players still alive: Ampelas, D'riss, Fener, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Kessobahn, Korvalain, Liosan, Meanas, Mockra, Ruse, Shadow, Tellan
7 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night
1 vote for Ampelas: ( Liosan )
Players not voted: Ampelas, D'riss, Fener, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Kessobahn, Korvalain, Meanas, Mockra, Ruse, Shadow, Tellan
Venge wasn't here to announce the weekend mod-kill freeze, and I"m too lazy to figure out the timezones. Alt explained the timing earlier.
Only someone with this much power could make this many frittatas without breaking any eggs.
#665
Korvalain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 04:18 AM
D'riss, on May 29 2009, 04:16 PM, said:
Korvalain, on May 29 2009, 12:14 PM, said:
Okay, in my opinion there are only two reasons to kill Emurlahn:
1. He was too close to comfort on nailing the killers, so they needed to take him out. However, this is mitigated by the fact that he was also the next most probable lynch, and therefore, less of a threat to them.
2. He was completely off in naming the killers, and by killing him they try to raise suspicion on those who he was fingering as likely killers. Like, Silanah.
So, I don't think it's 1 because of the mitigated situation, therefore, I think it's probably two, and we need to look at those other than who Emurlahn was fingering.
Does that make sense at all to anyone but me? (Probably not.) I'm going to go ahead and look at who Emurlahn has been ignoring.
1. He was too close to comfort on nailing the killers, so they needed to take him out. However, this is mitigated by the fact that he was also the next most probable lynch, and therefore, less of a threat to them.
2. He was completely off in naming the killers, and by killing him they try to raise suspicion on those who he was fingering as likely killers. Like, Silanah.
So, I don't think it's 1 because of the mitigated situation, therefore, I think it's probably two, and we need to look at those other than who Emurlahn was fingering.
Does that make sense at all to anyone but me? (Probably not.) I'm going to go ahead and look at who Emurlahn has been ignoring.
I'm not sure I understand #2 Korv because Silanah was lynched before Emur was killed. I don't see how Emur's death puts any frame of reference around Silanah's potential innocence or symp-guilt.
Also, in your previous list, I'm willing to look at the two people you have (other than me, obviously), with Mockra probably being my biggest question mark.
Shadow, on May 29 2009, 05:05 PM, said:
Hi folks (or absence of folks)!
I'm not sure I understand #2 Korv because Silanah was lynched before Emur was killed. I don't see how Emur's death puts any frame of reference around Silanah's potential innocence or symp-guilt.
Also, in your previous list, I'm willing to look at the two people you have (other than me, obviously), with Mockra probably being my biggest question mark.
Gotta go with D'riss on this one, Korv what on earth are you thinking?! Emur didn't do anyything close to killer-naming except Sil and Korlat, both of whom were already dead. The only others he even mentions are that he had "gut scum feelings" from Lio and Ruse (post 324). And since he'd done so little finger-pointing your first case makes no sense either! You are way out to lunch on this Korv!
D'riss, on May 29 2009, 04:16 PM, said:
Korvalain, on May 29 2009, 12:14 PM, said:
Okay, in my opinion there are only two reasons to kill Emurlahn:
1. He was too close to comfort on nailing the killers, so they needed to take him out. However, this is mitigated by the fact that he was also the next most probable lynch, and therefore, less of a threat to them.
2. He was completely off in naming the killers, and by killing him they try to raise suspicion on those who he was fingering as likely killers. Like, Silanah.
So, I don't think it's 1 because of the mitigated situation, therefore, I think it's probably two, and we need to look at those other than who Emurlahn was fingering.
Does that make sense at all to anyone but me? (Probably not.) I'm going to go ahead and look at who Emurlahn has been ignoring.
1. He was too close to comfort on nailing the killers, so they needed to take him out. However, this is mitigated by the fact that he was also the next most probable lynch, and therefore, less of a threat to them.
2. He was completely off in naming the killers, and by killing him they try to raise suspicion on those who he was fingering as likely killers. Like, Silanah.
So, I don't think it's 1 because of the mitigated situation, therefore, I think it's probably two, and we need to look at those other than who Emurlahn was fingering.
Does that make sense at all to anyone but me? (Probably not.) I'm going to go ahead and look at who Emurlahn has been ignoring.
I'm not sure I understand #2 Korv because Silanah was lynched before Emur was killed. I don't see how Emur's death puts any frame of reference around Silanah's potential innocence or symp-guilt.
Also, in your previous list, I'm willing to look at the two people you have (other than me, obviously), with Mockra probably being my biggest question mark.
Gotta go with D'riss on this one, Korv what on earth are you thinking?! Emur didn't do anyything close to killer-naming except Sil and Korlat, both of whom were already dead. The only others he even mentions are that he had "gut scum feelings" from Lio and Ruse (post 324). And since he'd done so little finger-pointing your first case makes no sense either! You are way out to lunch on this Korv!
It was a theory. The experiment would have proven it false! I hadn't looked at Emu's posts close enough to see if he had been casting suspicions on lots of people.
So, Shadow, why kill Emurlahn then? For shits and giggles? There is always a reason, even if it is hard to spot.
#674
Korvalain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 06:16 AM
It's "essentially" self-contained in the "let's see who has been on both trains" Liosan post, right after yours on D'riss last night. Surprised you don't remember it. Anyways, after thinking about it, it's not very good. Killer's play smooth and don't cause trouble, while Lio is all over the place. I'm drunk. I blame everybody working for the weekend.
Remove Vote.
I'm just extremely frustrated by the slow pace of play.
Remove Vote.
I'm just extremely frustrated by the slow pace of play.
#675
Mockra
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 2
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 06:20 AM
Korvalain, on May 30 2009, 06:16 PM, said:
It's "essentially" self-contained in the "let's see who has been on both trains" Liosan post, right after yours on D'riss last night. Surprised you don't remember it. Anyways, after thinking about it, it's not very good. Killer's play smooth and don't cause trouble, while Lio is all over the place. I'm drunk. I blame everybody working for the weekend.
Remove Vote.
I'm just extremely frustrated by the slow pace of play.
Remove Vote.
I'm just extremely frustrated by the slow pace of play.
Likewise but people have lives and not much is happening
Well I said I would check in and not much has happened once again.. Im off..
#676
Fener
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 35
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 06:21 AM
Oh, of course!
Yeah, wasn't it Mockra, D'riss, and Liosan?
Well, yeah, it is a bit of a stretch, but even so, it's more than anything else we've got during this incredibly slow session. Which reminds me, is the weekend freeze time-inclusive? Or is it only modkill timer? If it's time, then there is no point in rushing. Elsewise, I'd like to really focus on those three people a bit, and perhaps pressure them.
Yeah, wasn't it Mockra, D'riss, and Liosan?
Well, yeah, it is a bit of a stretch, but even so, it's more than anything else we've got during this incredibly slow session. Which reminds me, is the weekend freeze time-inclusive? Or is it only modkill timer? If it's time, then there is no point in rushing. Elsewise, I'd like to really focus on those three people a bit, and perhaps pressure them.
#679
Hood's Path
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 31
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 06:24 AM
All right, nothing's going on, so let's talk about D'riss.
I got highly suspicious of him after his vote on Emur. I made a case at post #505, and I think D'riss still hasn't clarified his reasoning on that vote. He just kind of switched it like nothing was wrong.
Fener then made a good analysis of his posts in posts #564 and #566.
Okay, since then, D'riss did the annoying "talk about someone like they're still alive...oh, whoops, I guess their dead series of posts" shtick that also rubbed me the wrong way.
Still catching up but you are correct. I have been suspicious of Emur for a while, which also is in response to someone saying I have had a bit of a fixation with him. I just didn't think the tide would shift much on Emur and so I joined the chorus on Silanah.
Oh, lol. Well so much for being suspcious of Emur... still reading.
He was catching up, yes, but who doesn't read the night scene before they start posting? It's almost like he was looking for an excuse to pull out a "lol, whoops, Emur's dead" post.
In addition to this, we have Ruse, who really seems to be doing a master job of symping D'riss. On two occasions today he chimes in saying that he's going to look at D'riss' (and others') posts and then proceeds to get everyone talking about all the other suspects except D'riss:
there was another train before the silanah one that also picked up speed pretty quickly...then it quickly shifted to silanah...
Maybe need to look at that....i think it was on ehmur
D'riss was a main part of that train, but Ruse doesn't bring it up again.
interesting....
Since i have some time...ill go have a look at mockras posts....i think fener just had a gander at driss like a few posts up...maybe ill have another look at driss too.
It's like he's all, "Don't worry, guys, I got this D'riss thing. Don't worry about it." And then he goes and does something else. And it's not like there's a lot else to do around here. It just seems like he's misdirecting.
With that in mind, I shall
Vote D'riss
I got highly suspicious of him after his vote on Emur. I made a case at post #505, and I think D'riss still hasn't clarified his reasoning on that vote. He just kind of switched it like nothing was wrong.
Fener then made a good analysis of his posts in posts #564 and #566.
Okay, since then, D'riss did the annoying "talk about someone like they're still alive...oh, whoops, I guess their dead series of posts" shtick that also rubbed me the wrong way.
D'riss, on May 29 2009, 08:20 AM, said:
Tellan, on May 29 2009, 12:54 AM, said:
Silanah, D'riss and Mockra voted for Emurlahn before the train got going on Silanah instead. Obviously, Sil didn't change their vote.
D'riss voted for Emur because he felt Emur wasn't voting based on what's been happening in the game. D'riss is the first to switch over from Emur to Sil. I'm not really sure from his post why he decided to change his mind, perhaps D'riss can expand upon that?
As it is, right now I just get the feeling he felt the tide was turning that way, rather than overt suspicion of Sil.
D'riss voted for Emur because he felt Emur wasn't voting based on what's been happening in the game. D'riss is the first to switch over from Emur to Sil. I'm not really sure from his post why he decided to change his mind, perhaps D'riss can expand upon that?
As it is, right now I just get the feeling he felt the tide was turning that way, rather than overt suspicion of Sil.
Still catching up but you are correct. I have been suspicious of Emur for a while, which also is in response to someone saying I have had a bit of a fixation with him. I just didn't think the tide would shift much on Emur and so I joined the chorus on Silanah.
D'riss, on May 29 2009, 08:20 AM, said:
Path-Shaper, on May 29 2009, 12:58 AM, said:
The night was short and tense, the sound of magic crackling through the air.
The next morning the monks gather once again. All are bleary eyed from lack of sleep, be it due to fear or action none can tell of the others. Looking around it's once again apparent that a search must be made.
A single corpse is found - burnt to a crisp but whole, in a room filled with ash and embers.
Emurlahn (Kurt Montandon) is dead and was a Monk of the Path.
The next morning the monks gather once again. All are bleary eyed from lack of sleep, be it due to fear or action none can tell of the others. Looking around it's once again apparent that a search must be made.
A single corpse is found - burnt to a crisp but whole, in a room filled with ash and embers.
Emurlahn (Kurt Montandon) is dead and was a Monk of the Path.
Oh, lol. Well so much for being suspcious of Emur... still reading.
He was catching up, yes, but who doesn't read the night scene before they start posting? It's almost like he was looking for an excuse to pull out a "lol, whoops, Emur's dead" post.
In addition to this, we have Ruse, who really seems to be doing a master job of symping D'riss. On two occasions today he chimes in saying that he's going to look at D'riss' (and others') posts and then proceeds to get everyone talking about all the other suspects except D'riss:
Ruse, on May 29 2009, 12:35 AM, said:
Tellan, on May 29 2009, 03:31 AM, said:
Ah, another lynch missed, sigh. Sorry I haven't been around anywhere near enough, finding it hard to find time to access the internet at the moment.
I raised my eyebrows a bit at how quickly the train on Silanah developed. Perhaps not so much in terms of time, but in terms of people not explaining themselves fully before voting that way. I don't disagree with the lynch per se, but my spider sense is tingling for one or two scum hoppers there.
I raised my eyebrows a bit at how quickly the train on Silanah developed. Perhaps not so much in terms of time, but in terms of people not explaining themselves fully before voting that way. I don't disagree with the lynch per se, but my spider sense is tingling for one or two scum hoppers there.
there was another train before the silanah one that also picked up speed pretty quickly...then it quickly shifted to silanah...
Maybe need to look at that....i think it was on ehmur
D'riss was a main part of that train, but Ruse doesn't bring it up again.
Ruse, on May 29 2009, 01:32 AM, said:
Tellan, on May 29 2009, 03:54 AM, said:
Silanah, D'riss and Mockra voted for Emurlahn before the train got going on Silanah instead. Obviously, Sil didn't change their vote.
D'riss voted for Emur because he felt Emur wasn't voting based on what's been happening in the game. D'riss is the first to switch over from Emur to Sil. I'm not really sure from his post why he decided to change his mind, perhaps D'riss can expand upon that?
As it is, right now I just get the feeling he felt the tide was turning that way, rather than overt suspicion of Sil.
As for Mockra, he puts his vote on Emur "unless something with substance turns up", which is his only explanation. It's also an interesting one given that his next post is this:
Well I find it interesting that you don't want to cast a vote on Emur but you won't cast it on anybody else..
If you don't like the case in front of you, vote for someone else..
Interesting because I got the feeling from Mockra's post where he votes for Emure that he didn't like that case, i.e. 'till something with substance turns up.' So if these are your principles, then why put your vote on a case you didn't like. Why didn't you vote for someone else who you felt might be more deserving of it? Also, Mockra hasn't exactly been foremost in attempting to find something to go on 'till something with substance turns up' sounds like he's waiting for others to do the legwork.
Mockra changed his vote to Silanah in order to, according to them, get the chance of a lynch. No real suspicion of Sil then, and no effort made to look elsewhere - though admittedly by this point time was running short.
D'riss voted for Emur because he felt Emur wasn't voting based on what's been happening in the game. D'riss is the first to switch over from Emur to Sil. I'm not really sure from his post why he decided to change his mind, perhaps D'riss can expand upon that?
As it is, right now I just get the feeling he felt the tide was turning that way, rather than overt suspicion of Sil.
As for Mockra, he puts his vote on Emur "unless something with substance turns up", which is his only explanation. It's also an interesting one given that his next post is this:
Mockra' post='610666, on May 29 2009, 04:15 AM, said:
Kessobahn' post='610663, on May 29 2009, 02:06 PM, said:
Huh, 15 minutes and no answer. Well, I'm going to leave now, probably for the night. I may check back before heading for bed. I doubt if I'll be casting a vote this day, as there has been nothing to vote on. I still think Meanas has been symping Silanah, but I have no evidence to back up a vote. Which means, probably no lynch. I'm gonna go pray for a more productive day tomorrow. Adios muchachos.
Well I find it interesting that you don't want to cast a vote on Emur but you won't cast it on anybody else..
If you don't like the case in front of you, vote for someone else..
Interesting because I got the feeling from Mockra's post where he votes for Emure that he didn't like that case, i.e. 'till something with substance turns up.' So if these are your principles, then why put your vote on a case you didn't like. Why didn't you vote for someone else who you felt might be more deserving of it? Also, Mockra hasn't exactly been foremost in attempting to find something to go on 'till something with substance turns up' sounds like he's waiting for others to do the legwork.
Mockra changed his vote to Silanah in order to, according to them, get the chance of a lynch. No real suspicion of Sil then, and no effort made to look elsewhere - though admittedly by this point time was running short.
interesting....
Since i have some time...ill go have a look at mockras posts....i think fener just had a gander at driss like a few posts up...maybe ill have another look at driss too.
It's like he's all, "Don't worry, guys, I got this D'riss thing. Don't worry about it." And then he goes and does something else. And it's not like there's a lot else to do around here. It just seems like he's misdirecting.
With that in mind, I shall
Vote D'riss
#680
Korvalain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 30 May 2009 - 06:29 AM
I have no idea. I want to see Tellan, Gamelon, definitely and you two (Fener, Mockra) hopefully a bit more. Weekend is nice time to hide for scum because of no mod-kills. However, if a low-poster doesn't feel like coming on the weekend, I'm going to have no reservations. This game is too slow, as of right now.
Edit: Cross post. Hood's Path. Nice to see you! I'll add you to the "would like to hopefully a bit more from," list. And that is a solid start.
Edit: Cross post. Hood's Path. Nice to see you! I'll add you to the "would like to hopefully a bit more from," list. And that is a solid start.
This post has been edited by Korvalain: 30 May 2009 - 06:31 AM
