[Mentalist]

I was looking into that last night actually--I was looking at who could be linked to Morgoth, and dismissing you (for meta reason), I was thinking either Venge or Gavin.
the way he reacted to my lynch, however, was totally not what i'd have expected, so if he's scum, im gonna say "good game" right now.

[Jump Around]

Mentalist, on Mar 27 2009, 08:47 PM, said:

Jump Around, on Mar 27 2009, 02:41 PM, said:

Well, after a scan-through, I can't find a single moment where Kurt and Morgoth quoted each other's posts or even mentioned each other's names. That's pushing normal gameplay, or even the laws of probabilities.

With Yellow, on the other hand, there's been some stuff thrown, like Ment notes, plus this post by Yellow:

Yellow, on Mar 26 2009, 09:41 PM, said:

Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 07:38 PM, said:

So you suspect me cause I suspect the people who I have voted for so far in the game and JA??? Ummm ok. Well done. Your right I think that we should make sure that JA and Morgy and Mental stay around....

No, don't misrepresent me. I suspect you because you clearly stated you suspected a player (Ment), but you would prefer we lynched either JA or Morgoth.

And your first vote of the day was a completely different player (Gavin).

So you're basically just looking for a) a quick lynch, a lynch of a troublesome player, c) to lay groundwork for your next lynch.

Now, in a CF game, which is more probable, that they would ignore one another completely, or throw little stuff like this?

ok, I don't get how this implicates Yellow, tbh. explain?
Venge WAS acting kinda all over the place yesterday. he was inno, granted, and I can see the pressure vote on Gavin, and all, but the bit about holding off a lynch and teh mixed signals thing makes me think he was very confused yesterday.

I didn't mean that this was incriminating against Yellow, I meant that him and Morgoth threw suspicions at each other, something Morgoth and Kurt never did.

You quoted Morgoth' post, I quoted this Yellow post I found.

[Mentalist]

Jump Around, on Mar 27 2009, 03:01 PM, said:

Well, between Yellow/Kurt I think my choice would be Kurt. For his own game style or just cruising around, and his complete lack of interaction with Morgoth. I know it's CF, and the scum knows it, but the probabilities of those two just completely acting like they're not even aware the other is playing is too far out to consider they didn't do it subconciously.


If we were dealing with a pair of killers, I would not dismiss Gavin and Ment so easily. But without them being able to communicate, I can't see it. If Ment was Morgoth's symp, Ment's CF would have come up inno so Morgoth would not have gained anything by having him lynched, quite the contrary. As for Gavin, if he did this to his own master without being able to talk to him off-thread is too... cold-hearted to consider. It's good strategy in the long term, but to take that decision himself instead of following the easier Ment lynch? I don't see it. If so, though, that Gavin should be hunted for many games to come, he's worst than me, dibs and Morgoth put together.

more importanly, re: me and morgy, it'd have taken some massive egos on both of our parts to be at each other's throats for most of the game, expecting to lynch off one and have the other cast through to victory.

[Mentalist]

yeah, as far as i'm concerned, all signs point to Kurt for today.
I'm afraid we're gonna have to wait for Gavin to get there, however, if Yellow's gonna be sticking to you.

[Jump Around]

Yellow, on Mar 27 2009, 09:03 PM, said:

I still think it's you

Right, I'm off to go do something more productive. It will probably involve white wine (calm down, Tapper love)... I will be back shortly!

If my point was to convince you all not to lynch me today, I wouldn't be wasting my time trying to decide between you and Kurt

I'm just putting what I find in case I get lynched, maybe it can help for tomorrow.

[Mentalist]

the way I envision this: kurt will come on, give little to no defence, vote you.

we will both vote Kurt.

and Gavin wil have to decide who to hammer and he'll vote Yellow,

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 5
19.25 hours left
5 Players alive
( Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist, Yellow)
3 votes to lynch

1 Vote Jump Around (Yellow)


Not voted: Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist

[Mentalist]

yawn
dead thread is dead.
I suppose we're all waiting for Kurt to come by to shed some light by giving us his insight.

[Yellow]

Mentalist, on Mar 27 2009, 08:55 PM, said:

yawn
dead thread is dead.
I suppose we're all waiting for Kurt to come by to shed some light by giving us his insight.

Lol aye. He'll close the case for us in one fell post.

Just been watching some Flight of the Conchords. Fucking funny.

Too many dicks on the dancefloor.

[Mentalist]

lol
not a big fan of techno rap, though

unless it's much, much faster.

a la this

ah, the 90s... how I miss you..

[Yellow]

That's some scary, bizarre shit. Flight of the Conchords are a parody band... that thing you linked to is just weird.

Right, I'm off!

This post has been edited by Yellow: 27 March 2009 - 10:20 PM

[Mentalist]

lol, turbo-techno of the 90s.

not to mention it wasn't in English,

back in 6th grade, that's the kind of stuff theyplayed at school dances

anyhow, still waiting for Kurt to show up before I vote him...

*twiddles thumbs*

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 5
15 hours left
5 Players alive
( Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist, Yellow)
3 votes to lynch

1 Vote Jump Around (Yellow)


Not voted: Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist

Sixty noticed that my math sucks...so I corrected it, lynch happened at 10:30 a.m. my time....its now 7:30 pm my time...thats 9 hours. not 11, Wait until I get really drunk later, lol.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 27 March 2009 - 11:34 PM

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 5
13.75 hours left
5 Players alive
( Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist, Yellow)
3 votes to lynch

1 Vote Jump Around (Yellow)


Not voted: Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist

[Mentalist]

hey, kurt's here!

anyhting to say for yourself?

[Kurt Montandon]

I really thought I was going to be able to play this morning, but only had about twenty minutes after waking up before I had to be out the door, and I just got back after twelve hours away from the house.


Vote Yellow

From the train on Morgoth, I guess the other scum can't be Gavin or Mentalist, my two primary suspects. And I know it's not me, so ...

[Kurt Montandon]

Mentalist, on Mar 27 2009, 05:45 PM, said:

hey, kurt's here!

anyhting to say for yourself?

Yeah, I got two hours of really poor sleep last night, then spent twelve hours travelling and taking a class on wildfire fighting safety, then just got back and have a growing headache for some damned reason. I'm also very hungry.

Oh, and I've missed the last three lynches and Nights. Hell, I'm surprised I'm still even alive.

[Mentalist]

wow
well, that's a first.

tbh, I expected you to jump on JA.

i'm really not sure between you and Yellow, i'm not gonna lie.

[Kurt Montandon]

Mentalist, on Mar 27 2009, 06:41 PM, said:

wow
well, that's a first.

tbh, I expected you to jump on JA.

i'm really not sure between you and Yellow, i'm not gonna lie.

Actually, before I finished reading up, I was going to go after you again.

But you led the charge against Morgoth, and that's going a bit far in the "distancing" category, if you were really scum. As, I would point out, is the fact that I and Morgoth didn't interact. Distancing is one thing, but that's just too obvious - If I was Morgoth's partner, I'm sure I would have voiced suspicions about him by now, maybe even cast a token vote that I didn't expect to go through. He just didn't get my attention.

Mod Edit: I took out the amateur comment, no need in making anyone feel like they don't know what they are doing...It in no way affects the reading of the post and was not necessary, IMO...which is the only opinion that matters really.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 28 March 2009 - 01:51 AM

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 5
12.75 hours left
5 Players alive
( Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist, Yellow)
3 votes to lynch

1 Vote Jump Around (Yellow)
1 Vote Yellow (Kurt M)


Not voted: Gavin, Jump Around, Kurt M., Mentalist