[Sixty]

Morgoth, on Mar 24 2009, 11:32 AM, said:

Sixty never responded to my request as to why he thought Obdi could be a symp, did he?

I just got home, track season started and I'm completely out of shape.

I honestly didn't get real symp vibes from either (although I'm not one of the better players so my reads aren't as accurate), but I was mostly thinking aloud at that point.

[Sixty]

@Yellow: Must have gotten something mixed up, so that's my mistake.

Tbh out of all the cases out so far, the one on dkt seems the most viable imo. Repeated ignorance about various mechanics tells me it's not someone who isn't paying attention (because that doesn't excuse artificial-sounding ignorance of the basic killer/symp setup...it's not as if this is a mindfuck game).

I am keeping my eye on a couple others, though.

Vote Dkt

[Kurt Montandon]

Sixty, on Mar 24 2009, 03:09 PM, said:

@Yellow: Must have gotten something mixed up, so that's my mistake.

Tbh out of all the cases out so far, the one on dkt seems the most viable imo. Repeated ignorance about various mechanics tells me it's not someone who isn't paying attention

Uh, in his defense, I was completely wrong about my case on him.

[Sixty]

I was referring to the thing about not knowing the night mechanics followed by the other stuff. (Brain's slow right now so bear with me here)

[Yellow]

Kurt Montandon, on Mar 24 2009, 10:12 PM, said:

Sixty, on Mar 24 2009, 03:09 PM, said:

@Yellow: Must have gotten something mixed up, so that's my mistake.

Tbh out of all the cases out so far, the one on dkt seems the most viable imo. Repeated ignorance about various mechanics tells me it's not someone who isn't paying attention

Uh, in his defense, I was completely wrong about my case on him.

What case was this? Are you talking about a case on Dkt, or am I missing something?

I seem to remember that you backed up Dkt's "misinterpreting" of the mechanic, which is why people are picking up a symp vibe. Your post above (if I'm reading it properly, apologies if I'm not) seems to just back this up, because you're defending him.

Anyway, I'm off to bed, back in the morning.

vote dktorode

I'd like to see a response to the Kurt/dk pair possibility.

[Kurt Montandon]

Yellow, on Mar 24 2009, 03:42 PM, said:

Kurt Montandon, on Mar 24 2009, 10:12 PM, said:

Uh, in his defense, I was completely wrong about my case on him.

What case was this? Are you talking about a case on Dkt, or am I missing something?

I seem to remember that you backed up Dkt's "misinterpreting" of the mechanic, which is why people are picking up a symp vibe. Your post above (if I'm reading it properly, apologies if I'm not) seems to just back this up, because you're defending him.

I found it suspicious that he knew that the Symp would take over for a dead Killer. I didn't read P-S's opening posts closely enough, and missed the line that pointed out this mechanic for everyone to know.


EDIT: I should say that I can't criticize him for not knowing that the Symp-Killer pair knew each other - I missed that line, too. I scanned that second P-S opening post waaaay too quickly.

This post has been edited by Kurt Montandon: 24 March 2009 - 11:06 PM

[Morgoth]

I can't say I buy the whole dk thing at this point. Also, why would there be a symp vibe in this game? I think people are forgetting that the symp here is not a regular sort of symp. In this game the symp becomes the killer once the killer is dead, so technically the killer should be more willing to throw himself into the fray than the symp, or at least neither has a strong incentive to sacrifice himself for the other.

The symp here is not misdirection, he's a backup.

So, I find Ment to be on the more suspicious part of the scale. DiBs is there too, but I can't as of yet put my finger on why so I'm waiting until I am more convinced it's a proper gut feeling and not all the garlic I put in my dinner.

[Morgoth]

Sixty, on Mar 24 2009, 10:58 PM, said:

Morgoth, on Mar 24 2009, 11:32 AM, said:

Sixty never responded to my request as to why he thought Obdi could be a symp, did he?

I just got home, track season started and I'm completely out of shape.

I honestly didn't get real symp vibes from either (although I'm not one of the better players so my reads aren't as accurate), but I was mostly thinking aloud at that point.

why would you say that though? If you had no basis for your statement then all it could do was to create wrong assumptions which might backfire later on.

anyways, I'm off to bed

[bubba]

You just became PI in my book morgy....I was waiting for someone to post that. Yesterday I picked up on that and have been holding back today to see where it all went.

@post 447

[Morgoth]

Bubba, on Mar 25 2009, 12:26 AM, said:

You just became PI in my book morgy....I was waiting for someone to post that. Yesterday I picked up on that and have been holding back today to see where it all went.

@post 447

fucking hell bubba, please change your avatar! I was utterly confused for the better part of 10 seconds

[Morgoth]

Bubba, on Mar 25 2009, 12:26 AM, said:

You just became PI in my book morgy....I was waiting for someone to post that. Yesterday I picked up on that and have been holding back today to see where it all went.

@post 447

On another note, I can't say I feel the same about you. I haven't seen enough of you I feel to make any opinions as to your allignment, which is never a good thing.

But never mind, I need to go to bed

[bubba]

Morgoth, on Mar 24 2009, 07:30 PM, said:

Bubba, on Mar 25 2009, 12:26 AM, said:

You just became PI in my book morgy....I was waiting for someone to post that. Yesterday I picked up on that and have been holding back today to see where it all went.

@post 447

fucking hell bubba, please change your avatar! I was utterly confused for the better part of 10 seconds

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 2
14.25 hours left.
11 Players alive
(Bubba, DKTorode, Drinksinbars, Gavin, Jump Around, , Kurt M., Mentalist, Morgoth, Sixty, Vengeance, Yellow)

3 votes Dktorode (Dibs, Sixty, Yellow)
1 Vote Yellow (Dktorode)
1 Vote Kurt M. (Vengeance)
2 Votes Mentalist (Jump Around, Morgoth)

Players not voted : Bubba, Gavin, Kurt M., Mentalist

[bubba]

Bent your an ASSS....you about blew my eardrum out.....ASSSS

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 2
9.25 hours left.
11 Players alive
(Bubba, DKTorode, Drinksinbars, Gavin, Jump Around, , Kurt M., Mentalist, Morgoth, Sixty, Vengeance, Yellow)

3 votes Dktorode (Dibs, Sixty, Yellow)
1 Vote Yellow (Dktorode)
1 Vote Kurt M. (Vengeance)
2 Votes Mentalist (Jump Around, Morgoth)

Players not voted : Bubba, Gavin, Kurt M., Mentalist

For those interested, I had a fucking BLAST! Papa Roach actually put on a better show than Avenged Sevenfold, the lead singer of PR actuall came down into the middle of the audience and sang part of a song, crazy bastard. But AS, they win for sheer loud-head-banging-bass-drumming-guitar-playing-one fucking handed-not even-struming-the-strings-and-playing-a-whole-fucking-sorrowful-song-by-himself-kick-ass-screaming-rock star capabilities.

And Bubba, not sorry about your ear. You needed to hear that shit! My ears almost bled. Anyway, off to bed, hopefully I'll have sobered up a bit and be on before the deadline. If no, talk amongst yourselves, until someone gets on to tell you who is ded. Love you nighty night

~Now if I can just talk the wife into a little BJ action....Oh and Tapper, I hope you and your husband have a long happy life together...I didn't realize it was legal for 2 men to e married in other countries....learn something new everyday on the boards,lol. Congrats for real though, best thing I ever did was suckering mrs. Bent into saying I DO...HAHAHAAHA

[Mentalist]

hmm
well this is certainly eventful.

[Kurt Montandon]

Mentalist, on Mar 24 2009, 09:54 PM, said:

hmm
well this is certainly eventful.

Time zones suck. It'll pick up right around time for me to head to bed.

[Mentalist]

meh, i'm partially to blame, I guess--but i've been rather preoccuppied trying to salvage stuff from my corrupted hard drive. Still am, in fact.

I should go to bed.
But I got a presentation to do for tomorrow...
fuck, i'll probably end up starting it at 4 AM again...

[Gavin]

Sorry haven't been around much, been a little busy today, I get started on a post then get called away for work.

So read up on what i've missed.

DKT - making a reading mistake, I can relate to that. Also I'm trying to think of why anyone would deliberately make a mistake like that in the rules and try to misrepresent it? Doesn't make sense to me, so I'm rather hesistant to vote him.

Ment, do you want to comment on your case on you?

If I had to point at scum at moment I would say Sixty is my leading scum candidate more gut than anything else at the moment, will go back and do a reread and see if I can't figure out why.

[Mentalist]

um, what's there to say?

I got up late, caught up on thread, misread what Kurt was saying, made a not-the-best-ly worded comment about it, and it landed me 2 paranoia votes.

can't really defend against that all that much...