[Rashan]

I'm thinking the same, I mean until now I could buy his "no time" excuses, but in the last posts he looks borderline bored. He could have at least have voted or something.

[Kaschan]

well there hasnt been that much, is everyone playing cagey fro a reason? korlats post about ruse struck me as particulkary odd, we arent getting anywhere, its like me saying...

"god, whats up with him?"

and tennes comes back and odes nothing AGAIn. i am voting tennes at the moment, and even silanahs strange reveal wont change that. Ov er on modcraft the one good choice they have made is moidkills go by content not just activity, so people saying one or two things just within the limit ae odkilled, thats something i think we should implement to discourage this type of gameplay

fingers not working today.

[Rashan]

I'm back, sorry for last few posts, grumpy sunday morning before coffee

I still own up to the content if not the tone, though.

[Rashan]

Kaschan, on Mar 1 2009, 12:32 PM, said:

Ov er on modcraft the one good choice they have made is moidkills go by content not just activity, so people saying one or two things just within the limit ae odkilled, thats something i think we should implement to discourage this type of gameplay

Unlike Modcraft, we have no problem getting the numbers for a game, so I fail to see where the pressure is to register for those who know they won't have the time to read the thread and play properly. It baffles me that we still have this problem coming from players who are not on their first game and knew exactly what to expect.

This rule is tricky for the mods, how to you rate his "I'm surprised by Silanah's reveal" post. It is content, after all. That rule is as easy to avoid as the current one for those who feel cool registering but don't care for the game.

[Kaschan]

but if there is something behind it, and they knows so then they can decide if its content or not. if tennes for example is just coming on to say hello then leave and not even bothering to explain himelf to us or the mods then that would be modkill worthy. if instead he was say pred or company, then going to mods and saying, i am going to lie low, lets them decide whats happening ios a tactic and not just inactivity.

[Path-Shaper]

I'm out for the next three hours - will be back to babysit your weekend break after that.

Cheers,

Tapper

[Kaschan]

holy fuck dead thread is dead

[Gamelon]

Just checking in. Tennes reappeared! Just off to a football match. Be back in a few hours.

[Kaschan]

what match?

[Anomandaris]

Hey guys, sorry for not being around, but I am having some RL issues and as such I can't really do much at the moment.
I do have a moment to talk now though.

First off, the night scene, I found it rather sketchy in details (bad mods! ).
So I find GL's immediate reaction, that it had to be a Pred, a little odd, so I went back and took a look.

Night 1: We had a pred kill. Victim skinned and decapitated.
Day 2: We had another pred kill. This time Lish (HP, Alien)

And then night 2 we get a vague death scene.

So my thoughts at the moment are these. Just before HP showed up there was an Alien day kill. I think that may have been Lish, probably assuming we would overlook the kill and his appearance at the same time as WIFOM.

Later on Lish makes a post and immediately after it, he gets vigged by a pred.

Now going on what I recall from the last game, I believe Venge has probably built the pred very similarly.
IIRC he had a find ability at night and D/NK power.

And now the crux, GL was so quick to jump to the conclusion that it was a predator, I reckon he is either not thinking straight, or more likely I have alt guessed him correctly, in which case my entire reason for suspecting him goes straight out the window.

@Galayn Lord: IGMEOY

This post has been edited by Anomandaris: 01 March 2009 - 02:21 PM

[Anomandaris]

Ok maybe I am stretching a little here, but I did a re-read on a few people and found this:

Silanah, on Feb 27 2009, 05:06 AM, said:

Shit, this ain't good at all. It would seem to me that there was a Pred kill on Gavin, but Dkt seems to have been nailed by a particularly malicious human. Maybe an infected? But again, PS says no reading things in, so I guess I'll find out in spoilers. Still, I didn't think even Preds had multiple kills per night... I've gotta go to bed, I'll be taking a look at the lynch train in the morning and seeing what there is to see.

EDIT: for errors in the train of thought (read really needs to go to bed)

Now I went back to the scene and looked again and I was also a little curious as to how Silanah managed to work out which kill was which and I would like to know how he got to those conclusions.

Then I looked at his reveal.

"2 shot night guard and 1 shot day guard = A jack shit role"

And on top of this knowing, they were limited he decided to use them straight off the bat?
Sorry, but that makes no sense to me. As a limited guard, I know I would have waited to use them, instead of just throwing them away.

So Silanah, I am calling BS on your reveal!

Vote: Silanah

[Kessobahn]

Ok I'm here, sorry I haven't been around as much as I would have liked.

Honestly I think that Silanah may be one of our best choices. The recent posts from Sil (4-5 pages) included the 2 minutes to review a case and revealing as a useless role. You know what role is useless??- RI, a guard is not useless and is a good role if the person knows how to do it and that doesn't involve wasting both guards on the first two nights. I think there is some weird stuff going on in Sil's part of the playing field.

I think the stuff on Ano may have merit as well, but isn't as strong imo.

[Kessobahn]

Nobody? Well ok.

vote Silanah will be back later.

[Kaschan]

what if sil is telling the truth though? would we really want to risk lynching our guard? granted guard isnt a jack shit role, but then maybe he expected everyone to be roled? i still think tennes is the pred, there is something undeniably scummy about such play.

[Gamelon]

Kaschan, on Mar 1 2009, 01:50 PM, said:

what match?

My college 4th team. We lost 10-3

[Gamelon]

Kaschan, on Mar 1 2009, 04:48 PM, said:

what if sil is telling the truth though? would we really want to risk lynching our guard? granted guard isnt a jack shit role, but then maybe he expected everyone to be roled? i still think tennes is the pred, there is something undeniably scummy about such play.

He's claiming RI because he says he has used all his guards.

[Kaschan]

thought he said he had a day guard left?

[Path-Shaper]

It is day 3 you have 12 hours and 50 minutes.

Players still alive (Silanah, Gamelon, Kessobahn, Korlat, Mockra, Ruse, Galayn Lord, Kaschan, Tennes, Rashan, Anomandaris)


Which means that you need 6 to lynch and 6 to go to night.

2 vote for Tennes (kaschan, ruse)
1 vote for Galayn Lord (rashan)
1 vote for Anomandaris (silanah)
3 vote for Silanah (galayn lord, Anomandaris, Kessobahn)

Seems slow I will be on and off for most of the day...

-Vengeance

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 01 March 2009 - 05:07 PM

[Kaschan]

thats 3 for sil, i amy change, but i think tenes is the more likely, but i will change before bed later if sil hasnt come back with anything.

[Anomandaris]

Sorry, I seem to have missed it, but is there a case against Tennes or is it based on the fact he appears and disappears without saying or doing anything?