[Galayn Lord]

Ano or Tennes imo.

[Korlat]

Tennes definitely need to step it up. Why Ano? I know you and him have had some fighting going on.



Edit: I'll need to reread to have an opinion about that.

This post has been edited by Korlat: 01 March 2009 - 10:12 PM

[Path-Shaper]

It is day 3 you have 7 hours and 14 minutes.

Players still alive (Silanah, Gamelon, Kessobahn, Korlat, Mockra, Ruse, Galayn Lord, Kaschan, Tennes, Rashan, Anomandaris)

Currently, 6 to lynch and 6 to go to night.


1 vote for Galayn Lord (rashan)
1 vote for Anomandaris (silanah)
5 votes for Silanah (Anomandaris, Kessobahn, Ruse, Kaschan, Korlat)

Seems slow I will be on and off for most of the day...

-Vengeance

Tapper, soon out for night.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 01 March 2009 - 10:37 PM

[Gamelon]

Right, having finally finished my read through, here's what I think on all the people alive.

Tennes - Like people have said, virtually all his posts have been apologizing for lack of activity. In his little content he hammered Galain and also suggested that he understood why Silanah revealed. I would like to know what reason he feels justifies Silanah's reveal, given if Silanah now died he would have wasted a day guard. Don't know whether to read the lack of activity as scum hiding or just someone who does actually have little time.

Mockra - Actually very little content as well I feel, apart from maybe a slip on saying alien rather than aliens and predator. He was one of the several people who I felt got over frustrated at the lynch of Shadow and while it could be righteous anger, it just felt a bit excessive. He could be scum trying to lie low I feel, and maybe used the Shadow lynch to try and display his innocence.

Kessobahn - The main activity by Kess was pushing the Shadow lynch but then strangely he refuses to hammer. This feels a bit strange because he was saying that it was obvious that Shadow needed to be lynched but when it came to it, he didn't hammer, maybe because he didn't want the attention that could possibly garner? Anyway, apart from that, most of what he's done since has been Odyssey spam.

Korlat - Don't feel there's much to say about to say about him apart from the rather odd jumping on and off Shadow train. It feels kind of weird as speaking for myself, I would not have gone from "sure this is the right lynch" to stepping back quite so quickly just because Serc said so.

Ruse - Another one that got rather over annoyed at the lynch of Shadow. To me that just felt like scum trying to lie low. He actually seems to have very little content, although I noticed that he did try to claim Newt was a marine to try to prove a point as well as noting that HP appeared just as alien vig happened. This may be a slip pointing to him as the Predator since it wasn't picked up on and as we know HP then got himself killed, probably by a predator, and was indeed an alien.

Edit: about Ruse, I meant "it felt like scum trying to hide as inno" don't know where lie low came from...

This post has been edited by Gamelon: 01 March 2009 - 11:22 PM

[Gamelon]

more is coming, I got tired of writing....

[Silanah]

Holy shit!

Okay, since I don't know what the case is against me yet, other than suspicion on my reveal, let me reveal my other little secret. I had one final one-shot ability, which I used just a while ago. It was a find on Ano. He's an Alien. Do with that what you will, I gotta read up on this thread.

[Tapper]

I'm logging off for the night. See you all tomorrow - I won't be at work in time to process the lynch, so it might be night is already in effect befoe I do the lynch scene... depending of course on whether or not it happens before Venge goes to bed/work/school.

Cheers,

Tapper

[Gamelon]

Silanah - He has little content and most of his posts were in day 1. In fact he hadn't contributed much since apart from his (fake?) reveal. I don't buy that you would reveal if you still have a day guard left, and if he thought he didn't, then trying to reveal as roleless inno strikes me as scummy. In addition, it's a little convenient that the people he supposedly guarded are dead so there's no-one to contradict him. However, I don't feel he's the predator, and since I feel that we really need to lynch the predator soon, I would wish to look for the predator today but if we don't come up with a better lynch candidate I would be more than happy to vote him.

Ano - Ano has come under some suspicion because he claims marine quite obviously by declaring his winning condition to be that of a marine. I understand where GL is coming from about people who try and claim inno are most likely not inno but I don't feel Ano did really overstretch his claim to make it look too suspicious. His other major contribution was starting the lynch train on Shadow which was fair enough I felt.

Kaschan - He pushed the day 1 lynch of Shadow quite happily and was also suspicious of HP, though as company not as Alien but close enough... Apart from that there's been little content apart from some quick symping and distancing by Rashan on him over trying to get Tennes's attention. Don't feel he has done much suspicious stuff, but then again, he is acting like I feel a predator would as all the predator has to do is keep his head down, be a middling poster, survive 5 days while killing off the aliens.

Galayn Lord - Not much to say apart from his assertion about the night 2 kill being a predator and then ensuing pissing contest with Rashan. Oh and his suspicions on Ano. I can kind of see his reasoning about the night kill, I myself had it down as being the most probable but to assert it and sound so convinced is a bit suspicious. I mean, the predator could have had a day/night vig per day, and used it on HP, and the night kill could be nothing to do with the predator. Overall though, I don't feel he's been too suspicious.

Rashan - Out of everyone, his content, even proportionately, has been the most. He has made several cases, including ones on Omtose and Mockra. This seems really helpful, but since I am suspicious of anyone wanting to be too helpful, I am a little suspicious of him. Could be scum trying to hide in plain sight in my opinion. Apart from the cases he has pushed, he has had a pissing contest with GL and either symped me or tried to distance from Kaschan, around the time when both voted Tennes to try and draw him out.

[Gamelon]

Silanah, on Mar 1 2009, 11:01 PM, said:

Holy shit!

Okay, since I don't know what the case is against me yet, other than suspicion on my reveal, let me reveal my other little secret. I had one final one-shot ability, which I used just a while ago. It was a find on Ano. He's an Alien. Do with that what you will, I gotta read up on this thread.

Hey Sil, can you tell me who you tried to day guard please?

[Galayn Lord]

Gamelon, the pissing contest itself resulted from an offhand comment made on another offhand comment...it was pretty retarded tbh.

Shit, Ano's an alien? If that's true, then it explains some of my suspicions...
Although do we want to trust him? Or even if he's right, do we want to kill an alien when we need to take out the predator?

[Silanah]

Anomandaris, on Mar 1 2009, 08:12 AM, said:

Ok maybe I am stretching a little here, but I did a re-read on a few people and found this:

Silanah, on Feb 27 2009, 05:06 AM, said:

Shit, this ain't good at all. It would seem to me that there was a Pred kill on Gavin, but Dkt seems to have been nailed by a particularly malicious human. Maybe an infected? But again, PS says no reading things in, so I guess I'll find out in spoilers. Still, I didn't think even Preds had multiple kills per night... I've gotta go to bed, I'll be taking a look at the lynch train in the morning and seeing what there is to see.

EDIT: for errors in the train of thought (read really needs to go to bed)

Now I went back to the scene and looked again and I was also a little curious as to how Silanah managed to work out which kill was which and I would like to know how he got to those conclusions.

Then I looked at his reveal.

"2 shot night guard and 1 shot day guard = A jack shit role"

And on top of this knowing, they were limited he decided to use them straight off the bat?
Sorry, but that makes no sense to me. As a limited guard, I know I would have waited to use them, instead of just throwing them away.

So Silanah, I am calling BS on your reveal!

Vote: Silanah

Anything to get a kill eh? It almost worked too.

Gamelon, on Mar 1 2009, 10:13 AM, said:

Yeah sorry, he tried to use it apparently but Path-Shaper didn't see it or something.

So who did you try to use it on Sil?

I tried to use it on Kess, just picked somone random really. Honestly, I DON'T know how to play a guard, and with the number of kills this game enables, it seemed extremely likely that I'd die quickly. However, ModCraft game is basically over, and I can concentrate now.

At everyone who wondered how the fuck I can draw conclusions from a scene? Well, 2 reasons. As a singer, I have to understand the lyrics of the song, and that involves a serious analysis. On ModCraft, in the LOTR game, the mods decided to code the characters into the description of their deaths, as well as giving a clue as to what characters killed them. As a character who ordered a lot of kills, Sauron, namely, I was in a position to recognize those clues, and I suppose I'm simply reading those clues from Venge's scenes as well. Sorry if I'm confusing people, and I may be completely off the truth, but I was simply stating my ideas the way anybody should if they truly believe those ideas, namely, as statements of fact.

[Silanah]

Gamelon, on Mar 1 2009, 04:15 PM, said:

Silanah, on Mar 1 2009, 11:01 PM, said:

Holy shit!

Okay, since I don't know what the case is against me yet, other than suspicion on my reveal, let me reveal my other little secret. I had one final one-shot ability, which I used just a while ago. It was a find on Ano. He's an Alien. Do with that what you will, I gotta read up on this thread.

Hey Sil, can you tell me who you tried to day guard please?

Just did. Look, I have to go eat dinner. I'll defo be back soon. Sorry.

[Gamelon]

So with that epic summary, I would just like to conclude that I feel Mockra and Ruse would be the people I want to look at because I really didn't like their "righteous" anger on the day 1 lynch. In addition, both had maybe a slip I feel, Mockra with his "semantics" on using Alien for Aliens and Predators and Ruse with his note that HP could well be a day-vigging alien and then HP gets vigged within a few hours.

[Gamelon]

Galayn Lord, on Mar 1 2009, 11:16 PM, said:

Gamelon, the pissing contest itself resulted from an offhand comment made on another offhand comment...it was pretty retarded tbh.

Shit, Ano's an alien? If that's true, then it explains some of my suspicions...
Although do we want to trust him? Or even if he's right, do we want to kill an alien when we need to take out the predator?

Yeah but pissing contests which retarded or not are a great way to draw off suspicion I feel, as people would think, scum wouldn't do that because it attracts far too much attention.

I feel we need to go after the predator too but I really don't like the idea of leaving both Sil and Ano alive tonight either, since if Sil is lying, he would be scum and may be able to infect or kill and if Ano is alive and Sil is telling the truth, then Ano can probably infect someone.

[Korlat]

Yeah, this is a tricky situation. We should give Ano time to counter reveal.

[Galayn Lord]

If he _was_ the alien, though, then he'd just make up some bs about his role...

[Korlat]

Well sure but then we got something more to go on.



Edit: forgot 'got'.

This post has been edited by Korlat: 01 March 2009 - 11:42 PM

[Galayn Lord]

When does day end?

<--retarded

This post has been edited by Galayn Lord: 02 March 2009 - 12:06 AM

[Mentalist]

in about 5 hours.
which will be Venge's midninght.
I'm not sure he'll actually stay up that late since he's a working man and all that.

[Kessobahn]

Gamelon, on Mar 1 2009, 05:42 PM, said:

Right, having finally finished my read through, here's what I think on all the people alive.



Kessobahn - The main activity by Kess was pushing the Shadow lynch but then strangely he refuses to hammer. This feels a bit strange because he was saying that it was obvious that Shadow needed to be lynched but when it came to it, he didn't hammer, maybe because he didn't want the attention that could possibly garner? Anyway, apart from that, most of what he's done since has been Odyssey spam.

I think if you look back I was saying that a Shadow lynch was a good idea but patience is a good thing. There were 16 hours left at that point and I didn't want a speed-lynch day 1 which is a good move, though it happened anyway. Besides my one post about not wanting to hammer occured at L-3, I got my maths wrong and when it came time to truly hammer I was in class.