[Thyrllan]

"Suspected by shadow" seems a common excuse for jumping on now.
Do a post search on shadow.
Within the first page he mentions Galain maybe twice.
Now, while im not particularly against lynching him, I would prefer if people gave more reason than "shadow suspected him".

[Rashan]

Thyrllan, on Jan 30 2009, 01:27 PM, said:

"Suspected by shadow" seems a common excuse for jumping on now.
Do a post search on shadow.
Within the first page he mentions Galain maybe twice.
Now, while im not particularly against lynching him, I would prefer if people gave more reason than "shadow suspected him".

Ummm. I made a full case on him, which you already looked over......

[Galain]

If you think that I would kill someone because they suspected me, Shadow has hardly been the one pushing for a lynch on me. Shadow was a lot more suspicious of other people than of me.

I think that D'riss is far from PI. I still have him down as PS probable symp.

[Thyrllan]

Rashan, on Jan 30 2009, 06:32 PM, said:

Thyrllan, on Jan 30 2009, 01:27 PM, said:

"Suspected by shadow" seems a common excuse for jumping on now.
Do a post search on shadow.
Within the first page he mentions Galain maybe twice.
Now, while im not particularly against lynching him, I would prefer if people gave more reason than "shadow suspected him".

Ummm. I made a full case on him, which you already looked over......

Yes, my complaint isnt that I dont think galain is a bad lynch.
Its that the reasons people are giving are bad.

[Liosan]

Thyrllan, on Jan 30 2009, 06:27 PM, said:

"Suspected by shadow" seems a common excuse for jumping on now.
Do a post search on shadow.
Within the first page he mentions Galain maybe twice.
Now, while im not particularly against lynching him, I would prefer if people gave more reason than "shadow suspected him".

I was referencing just one of the cases already made. As omtose pointed out in that last quote, galain and omtose are; from day 1, scum suspects and it is highly likely they are using the day 1 skin of your teeth method which always seems to work on this board. Essentially you make yourself a target on day 1 and then hide until the end. That galain has four votes just means i am going to try and lynch him today instead of tomorrow or the day after when it would have become a big issue for me if they were still around. Personally i would prefer to lynch driss, but i think he can wait until tomorrow as if he is a symp he isnt going to be on anyway to influence people.

[Liosan]

Galain, on Jan 30 2009, 06:34 PM, said:

If you think that I would kill someone because they suspected me, Shadow has hardly been the one pushing for a lynch on me. Shadow was a lot more suspicious of other people than of me.

I think that D'riss is far from PI. I still have him down as PS probable symp.

more acronyms?

Sorry galain, but the day 1 business sits sour with me and as there is already a train on you it would be pretty pointless for me to jump on the driss train and fight to lynch him when you are one of the people i feel we need to remove in order to win this and i would probably just work toward yours or omtose' lynch come tomorrow. Hopefully this game is not going WCS and we have got the creature and at least one of the necros so we can afford a bad lynch.

[Liosan]

I should really check the time stamps, i thought you two were on, and now i see you last posted half an hour ago. Ok i am cooking at the moment, so will check back on after me dinner.

[Omtose]

Liosan, on Jan 30 2009, 08:07 PM, said:

Thyrllan, on Jan 30 2009, 06:27 PM, said:

"Suspected by shadow" seems a common excuse for jumping on now.
Do a post search on shadow.
Within the first page he mentions Galain maybe twice.
Now, while im not particularly against lynching him, I would prefer if people gave more reason than "shadow suspected him".

I was referencing just one of the cases already made. As omtose pointed out in that last quote, galain and omtose are; from day 1, scum suspects and it is highly likely they are using the day 1 skin of your teeth method which always seems to work on this board. Essentially you make yourself a target on day 1 and then hide until the end. That galain has four votes just means i am going to try and lynch him today instead of tomorrow or the day after when it would have become a big issue for me if they were still around. Personally i would prefer to lynch driss, but i think he can wait until tomorrow as if he is a symp he isnt going to be on anyway to influence people.

I have already said I used this method, just haven't been exactly silent about and after it

[Liosan]

Yeah, but saying it is in itself a form of deference as you put it out there so we know its something we have to do, but then things will keep coming up or you will make a good case on someone. It is too risky and everyone should know it.

[Meanas]

Thanks for getting up and making a case Rashan, and it is a good one, not the best that we have seen so far (the case on GL being the best) but you do make some decent points. What helped make up my mind is the lack of a defense that Galain gave. I personally would like to lynch D'riss. For the same reasons that I gave yesterday. But I also don't want to see this day drag out. I find it passingly strange that Rashan would first vote for his case then remove his vote (when there were only 3 votes saying that he was afraid of double voters) then put his vote back on. I think that D'riss needs to be lynched sooner rather then later. I do not see Galain as a killer. However I feel that we must lynch. I will be around for another couple of hours. I would like for Galain to at least make an attempt to defend himself. If he doesn't I will vote for him before I leave.

[Meanas]

Looks like it is just me and you Omtose. What would you like to talk about.

[Thyrllan]

I am here.
I would like to talk about the odyssey.

I like the case on galain tbh, but not some of the reasons people have given. Even just saying they agree with the case, though I believe lisoan has gone on to say he has done.

Sorry if im not making much sense, i'm really tired. And its still early .

I blame silencer.

[Meanas]

Yeah someone to talk to. Sorry I had gone back to reread the last several pages. You still here?

[Hood's Path]

I like Rashan's case on Galain, and I do feel it's stronger than my case on Silanah. Galain's defense seemed like it was really lacking to me. I'm not sure if it's because he's busy with RL as he says, or if it's an attempt to make people disregard his behaviour. Either way it didn't do much to make him look less guilty. I'm not going to be on very much this weekend, but I will make an effort to get on at least a few times. I feel we need to get a lynch, and not just leave the weekend to be completely dead like it was last week. If Galain comes up with a better defence or someone else puts together something stronger I can always change my vote. So far though this is the strongest and most viable case, and therefore warrants my vote.

Remove Vote
Vote Galain

[Path-Shaper]

it is Day 7, Week-end freeze in effect

10 people are still alive (Hood's Path, Silanah, Thyrllan, Galain, Rashan, Liosan, Meanas, Omtose, D'riss, Ruse)

takes 6 votes to lynch or 5 to go to night

5 votes Galain (Silanah, Omtose, Rashan, Liosan, Hood's Path)
1 vote Silanah (Thyrllan)
1 vote D'riss (Galain)
1 vote Rashan (Ruse)

2 people have not voted (Meanas, D'riss)


---


There's very few of you left. Only one night-kill. Can one of the killing faction be dead? Are the Necros recruiting?

As the tension mounts, you start looking at Galain, who has been suspiciously silent since the beginning of the events.

"Don't kill that's a waste! Let me find a gas oven and I'll take care of myself!"

But before he has time to even reach the kitchen, he is grabbed and dragged to the rope.

"No, really, I meant it, I can sdfafarrrrrrrrrrrrrgllllllllglglgglglglgl!!"


Galain (The Man Who) is dead

It is now night.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 30 January 2009 - 08:07 PM

[Rashan]

Meanas, on Jan 30 2009, 02:40 PM, said:

Thanks for getting up and making a case Rashan, and it is a good one, not the best that we have seen so far (the case on GL being the best) but you do make some decent points. What helped make up my mind is the lack of a defense that Galain gave. I personally would like to lynch D'riss. For the same reasons that I gave yesterday. But I also don't want to see this day drag out. I find it passingly strange that Rashan would first vote for his case then remove his vote (when there were only 3 votes saying that he was afraid of double voters) then put his vote back on. I think that D'riss needs to be lynched sooner rather then later. I do not see Galain as a killer. However I feel that we must lynch. I will be around for another couple of hours. I would like for Galain to at least make an attempt to defend himself. If he doesn't I will vote for him before I leave.

FYI, I removed the vote due to the sheer amount of time left and the speed in which the train was growing. And I put the vote back on because we are in weekend break and I saw Ruse trying to derail the lynch, which appeared to me to be symp like. However it could be fake symping, but thats Wifom.

[Meanas]

After reading the last several pages I think that I am starting to see a connection. I am going to try to get it together and up here soon. As we come down to the wire. It has been my experience that symps and killers have to step forward and drive cases and lynches. Any way I will have more on that in as soon as I finish getting the connections together.


Edit: cross post with Pathshaper Fuck.

This post has been edited by Meanas: 30 January 2009 - 08:09 PM

[Silanah]

I come online just as day ends O.o
Weekend break is going to be annoying -.-

[Thyrllan]

Hmm, not sure if I like the speed of this lynch. He really didn't defend himself, and seemed almost unwilling to, but I wouldn't have been against giving him more time to do so.
I mean, we have whole weekend, so lynch didnt need to be fast or anything.

[Liosan]

well we all seem to be online so i do not see why the weekend break has to be really quiet, unless driss is roled and hasnt put in a night action i think everyone else is about, so night should not be long.