Just finished this a few weeks back but waited for the Forum migration before posting.
Loved it. loved loved loved it. I'm going
SPOILERS in here so you are warned..... i'm not reviewing, i'm discussing....
SPOILERS SPOILERS
THE SPOILERS REMAIN
SPOILERS FUCKING
SPOILERS
WILL SPOIL YOU
SPOILERS
SPOILERS
I've always liked RM's work, the Kovacs books are great, i think Black Man was brilliant, even Market Forces was mildly entertaining. This, this was a whole new level for him.
He throws you into the world and makes it clear you are coming in at a pause, so to speak. A big war against genocidal lizard men just ended, and three of the heroes from that war are getting on with their lives.
Ringil, Egar, Archeth... great characters. let's get the obvious out of the way, Ringil is gay. He fucks men. He's up front about it. His pov included comments about anal and oral sex that would give the average Jordan fan heart palps. He's also flawed and nasty and noble all at once and possibly one of the coolest fantasy characters in ages. The description from Egar of how Ringil rallied the soldiers at Gallows Gap to charge was one of the best bits of text i have ever read in a fantasy book... 'men laughing as they died'... holy. fuck.
Egar was great fun - barbarian who misses civilization and just plain badass. We never get the description of how he became Dragonbane but we believe it just based on how he fights. "I'm with the faggot." LOL.
Archeth was a stand-out too. Her mixed race origins, her fight to stay decent, and the way she names her blades and fights with them all were great to read. I liked how RM didn't feel the need to explain everything with her... the text just says something like 'Archeth pulled Bandgleam out and threw, pulling out Laughing Girl before the blade hit home..." and it just works. She has four blades and has names for all of them... She has a history with another race that left the world, she has a detached bio-computer ship pilot living in her library and it just all falls together so well.
The
elves dwenda/dwellers were good bad guys. RM skipped a lot of the pretentious nonsense instead having them be powerful but vulnerable, contemptuous of humans but afraid of them and attracted to them... given the author's creativity with the other races that appear briefly (notably the lamprey women), i sort of wish he had done something more interesting than other-dimensional lightning elves, but then Ringil's relationship with the leader wouldn't have made much sense if they were truly alien. As it was the transition from Ringil trying to kill him to them sheboinging in interdimensional spaces to turning on him at the end was the only part of the plot i found weak. It just didn't read true the way their relationship evolved and devolved.
I am totally curious whether it's Ringil the 'Dark Lord' prophecy is referring to. The ending is ambiguous.
I totally enjoyed this book. RM stays firmly in my pre-order list and i hope he does more in the fantasy genre.
- Abyss, ...found the headtrees just creepy...
This post has been edited by Abyss: 24 September 2008 - 04:43 PM