[Andorion]

You do no Town actually lost right?

[Khellendros]

Haven't looked at SH yet, but I never would have guessed Tulas was Andorion. Some very smooth play there, up until the Rikkter defence, that was really the only thing which damned you. Good game.


I agree that town in a way got lucky, in that they did so well despite some low participation which could have really hurt us in other circumstances. But don't worry, Venesara and I (Omtose) were on the case

[Blend]

Tennes, on 18 February 2015 - 02:04 PM, said:

Jesus that may have just been the single greatest game for town ever.

I wouldn't say that necessarily - Grief made a very good point in SH after he was killed.

When you guys basically VPI'd yourselves using the word "generic" from your role PMs, I technically should have modkilled you all, as that's quoting exact wording from your PMs. I didn't really realize what was happening until Grief pointed it out, so I just let the game play out by that point, but had I caught on, I would have modkilled the three people who VPI'd themselves using that word.

If "generic" hadn't been used to VPI whoever it was that was up before you all switched over to Rikkter, that would have been another town down, and could have changed the game.

[Khellendros]

Blend, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Tennes, on 18 February 2015 - 02:04 PM, said:

Jesus that may have just been the single greatest game for town ever.

I wouldn't say that necessarily - Grief made a very good point in SH after he was killed.

When you guys basically VPI'd yourselves using the word "generic" from your role PMs, I technically should have modkilled you all, as that's quoting exact wording from your PMs. I didn't really realize what was happening until Grief pointed it out, so I just let the game play out by that point, but had I caught on, I would have modkilled the three people who VPI'd themselves using that word.

If "generic" hadn't been used to VPI whoever it was that was up before you all switched over to Rikkter, that would have been another town down, and could have changed the game.

Just been reading all that - and realising Andorion was Grief at the beginning lol. I'll have more to say later, but in a departmental meeting at the moment.

[Andorion]

Khellendros, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Haven't looked at SH yet, but I never would have guessed Tulas was Andorion. Some very smooth play there, up until the Rikkter defence, that was really the only thing which damned you. Good game.


I agree that town in a way got lucky, in that they did so well despite some low participation which could have really hurt us in other circumstances. But don't worry, Venesara and I (Omtose) were on the case

Frankly you spooked me out. You were so exact all the time, that first NK should have been you. I guessed you were a finder during day 2, I think. BTW I was not Tulas. Look at the Spoilers.

I wish I could play as well as Grief or you.

Anyway practice makes pefect, so I am already up for the next game. Lets have another faction game. And this time I want kill abilities. Loooots of kill abilities

[Blend]

Andorion, on 18 February 2015 - 02:50 PM, said:

want kill abilities. Loooots of kill abilities

Heh, looks like someone's starting their list.

[Gust Hubb]

Blend, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Tennes, on 18 February 2015 - 02:04 PM, said:

Jesus that may have just been the single greatest game for town ever.

I wouldn't say that necessarily - Grief made a very good point in SH after he was killed.

When you guys basically VPI'd yourselves using the word "generic" from your role PMs, I technically should have modkilled you all, as that's quoting exact wording from your PMs. I didn't really realize what was happening until Grief pointed it out, so I just let the game play out by that point, but had I caught on, I would have modkilled the three people who VPI'd themselves using that word.

If "generic" hadn't been used to VPI whoever it was that was up before you all switched over to Rikkter, that would have been another town down, and could have changed the game.

Yeah, very true. I wrote my apology in SH. It was cheating and I knew it, so no kuddos or rep to me. sorry.

[Khellendros]

Andorion, on 18 February 2015 - 02:50 PM, said:

Khellendros, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Haven't looked at SH yet, but I never would have guessed Tulas was Andorion. Some very smooth play there, up until the Rikkter defence, that was really the only thing which damned you. Good game.


I agree that town in a way got lucky, in that they did so well despite some low participation which could have really hurt us in other circumstances. But don't worry, Venesara and I (Omtose) were on the case

Frankly you spooked me out. You were so exact all the time, that first NK should have been you. I guessed you were a finder during day 2, I think. BTW I was not Tulas. Look at the Spoilers.

I wish I could play as well as Grief or you.

Anyway practice makes pefect, so I am already up for the next game. Lets have another faction game. And this time I want kill abilities. Loooots of kill abilities

Haha, it's great to hear you're enjoying it!


Re Grief's point, I'm going to post in the spoiler thread about it.

[Tiamatha]

Getting steamrollered here, I'll be back tomorrow.

Edit: By which I mean I'll actually post something coherent.

Having caught up very very fast, sorry folks. I'll sit out the next few games.

This post has been edited by Tiamatha: 18 February 2015 - 05:02 PM

[Inane Babble]

Blend, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Tennes, on 18 February 2015 - 02:04 PM, said:

Jesus that may have just been the single greatest game for town ever.

I wouldn't say that necessarily - Grief made a very good point in SH after he was killed.

When you guys basically VPI'd yourselves using the word "generic" from your role PMs, I technically should have modkilled you all, as that's quoting exact wording from your PMs. I didn't really realize what was happening until Grief pointed it out, so I just let the game play out by that point, but had I caught on, I would have modkilled the three people who VPI'd themselves using that word.

If "generic" hadn't been used to VPI whoever it was that was up before you all switched over to Rikkter, that would have been another town down, and could have changed the game.

"You guys" doesn't include me, so don't modkill me

I agree that there needs to be some mechanism that prevents that kind of play, but I dislike the idea of putting the RI PM into the setup, as there may sometimes be information in there that scum would benefit from knowing, and if it becomes normal to put the PM in, then in the games where it is ABSENT then scum will know something is up. Modkills for stuff like this seems like the best disincentive IMO.

[Vengeance]

Inane Babble, on 18 February 2015 - 05:10 PM, said:

Blend, on 18 February 2015 - 02:42 PM, said:

Tennes, on 18 February 2015 - 02:04 PM, said:

Jesus that may have just been the single greatest game for town ever.

I wouldn't say that necessarily - Grief made a very good point in SH after he was killed.

When you guys basically VPI'd yourselves using the word "generic" from your role PMs, I technically should have modkilled you all, as that's quoting exact wording from your PMs. I didn't really realize what was happening until Grief pointed it out, so I just let the game play out by that point, but had I caught on, I would have modkilled the three people who VPI'd themselves using that word.

If "generic" hadn't been used to VPI whoever it was that was up before you all switched over to Rikkter, that would have been another town down, and could have changed the game.

"You guys" doesn't include me, so don't modkill me

I agree that there needs to be some mechanism that prevents that kind of play, but I dislike the idea of putting the RI PM into the setup, as there may sometimes be information in there that scum would benefit from knowing, and if it becomes normal to put the PM in, then in the games where it is ABSENT then scum will know something is up. Modkills for stuff like this seems like the best disincentive IMO.

We usually do put the generic town role pm into the set up. Just to prevent what happened from happening. In games where it is absent it is usually a result of there being no generic role pm.

[Alkend]

I was a huge help I know.

Japan still has resorts with no internet access provided. I had forgotten that when I signed up - I went on a mini-vacation with my family and found myself only able to use my phone.

I agree with Venge - generic RI pms in the setup help, and yes, some people should have been modkilled.

[Gnaw]

Bubba, on 11 February 2015 - 02:19 AM, said:

By the way.....
3f9y5RT.gif


I really wanted to play...

That was great Bubba. I chuckled at that one for days.