[Path-Shaper]

It is now Day 5. 4 hours 37 minutes remaining.

6 players are alive: Barghast, Denul, Eloth, Galayn Lord, Kaschan, Pallid

4 votes to lynch, 3 votes to go to night.

2 votes Kaschan: Pallid, Eloth
2 votes Barghast: Galayn Lord, Kaschan
1 votes Eloth: Barghast


Players not voted: Denul

[Barghast]

I'm off work. Drive home is about 30 mins.

Denul, on 03 June 2014 - 08:31 PM, said:

On the other hand Kaschan. I could vote him on his play the whole game. I thought he'd step it up come end game but his vote has been more self preservation than looking for scum.

Well, we're running out of time. If he's at l-1 by the time I get home, I don't see any reason not to roll ourr dice on him. Eloth swapping votes worries me. Not because its Kaschan, because no matter who he swaps to its still shifty. I see Eloth paired with you or GL over Kaschan. I see GL paired with Kaschan.

[Kaschan]

Denul, on 03 June 2014 - 08:16 PM, said:

Kaschan why didn't you add to me then?

Fuck sake. You're coming across quite righteous. You say I am best chance at scum but then vote Barghast without questioning the votes on yourself

Now at this point with the amount that we all have gone through the thread can I question the votes on myself. I know that I am town but that means nothing to anyone else because everyone says that including scum. But your right my vote for Barghast is based on a little bit of self preservation and not on total outright belief that he is the soul remaining scum. Like GL's vote for him.

Remove Vote

[Path-Shaper]

It is now Day 5. 4 hours 32 minutes remaining.

6 players are alive: Barghast, Denul, Eloth, Galayn Lord, Kaschan, Pallid

4 votes to lynch, 3 votes to go to night.

2 votes Kaschan: Pallid, Eloth
1 vote Barghast: Galayn Lord
1 votes Eloth: Barghast


Players not voted: Denul, Kaschan

[Pallid]

I could easy be convinced to change my vote to any of the trifecta of bargh, kasch and eloth.

I feel there's definitely at.least one scum in there, and I really cant decide which, if its a dice needs rolling I'm game, but will hold of until I get and shower and i to bed

[Eloth]

Oh do whatever the fuck you like, I documented yesterday that, RIGHT AFTER TWO PEOPLE I KNOW TO BE TOWN, YOU ARE THE LEAST LIKELY TO BE SCUM, earlier today I mentioned THAT I WOULD GLADLY VOTE FOR KASCHAN IF DENUL LYNCH IS NOT POSSIBLE, and decided to change my vote TO GET A SATISFACTORY FUCKING LYNCH ON D-DAY after Denul once more weaseled his way out of one.

How is this for Buddying up to you; You are a total idiot, who just handed scum ANOTHER easy fucking win. GG.

I will now be SURPRISED if you don't turn up scum.

"He's trying to get a lynch, he previously stated he found desirable, that isn't me he must be Scum!"

CHRIST.

[Galayn Lord]

Kaschan said:

1401828255[/url]' post='1128386']

Denul said:

1401826615[/url]' post='1128371']
Kaschan why didn't you add to me then?

Fuck sake. You're coming across quite righteous. You say I am best chance at scum but then vote Barghast without questioning the votes on yourself

Now at this point with the amount that we all have gone through the thread can I question the votes on myself. I know that I am town but that means nothing to anyone else because everyone says that including scum. But your right my vote for Barghast is based on a little bit of self preservation and not on total outright belief that he is the soul remaining scum. Like GL's vote for him.

Remove Vote

Huh? How is my vote based on self-preservation?

[Kaschan]

I think that this is starting to be do you think that there are two scum remaining or one. If there is 1 then is it Barghast? If there are two then it could be any one of you. Looking at this from a strictly WCS point of view I have to assume that there are 2 scum left. Then the question becomes is one killer and a symp or two killers. Well if it is a killer and a symp and we lynch the killer then town wins. If we lynch a symp then we get to find the killer tomorrow. If there are two killers and we lynch a killer today then we get to find the other one tomorrow. In any scenario if we lynch town then scum wins. Then off of that do I think that there are two killers or a killer and symp. I don't know. There are to many connections between people and trains. Denul has been screaming scum for half of the game. Nobody is CIed or even VPI. I feel that if there are two scum remaining then Denul is most likely one of them. But I don't see him as a killer I see him as most likely a symp.

I don't know who the killer could be. Eloth who revealed a healer in order to prevent himself from being lynched. Barghast who was almost lynched. GL who revealed that he had a BP and that scum had targeted him the first night there wasn't a kill. That reveal seems more real to me then Eloth's healer reveal. For the simple fact that GL did it with out any pressure and did it to make sure that town knew that Eloth had not prevented a kill. Eloth voted for the person who he most felt was town in Amp. The very same person who he had "healed all game". The problem is I mostly trust GL at least more then everyone else right now. But I don't agree that there is only one scum. I can't because that isn't the WCS. I am going to hold off my vote for a little bit while I think it through. If Denul is scum then he has been driving the town for most of the game. He was accused of that right out of the gate. That is a ballsy play but not totally unhead of. Buggers why couldn't we have lynched either Barghast or Eloth before today.

[Kaschan]

Galayn Lord, on 03 June 2014 - 08:53 PM, said:

Kaschan, on 03 June 2014 - 08:44 PM, said:

Denul, on 03 June 2014 - 08:16 PM, said:

Kaschan why didn't you add to me then?

Fuck sake. You're coming across quite righteous. You say I am best chance at scum but then vote Barghast without questioning the votes on yourself

Now at this point with the amount that we all have gone through the thread can I question the votes on myself. I know that I am town but that means nothing to anyone else because everyone says that including scum. But your right my vote for Barghast is based on a little bit of self preservation and not on total outright belief that he is the soul remaining scum. Like GL's vote for him.

Remove Vote

Huh? How is my vote based on self-preservation?

What not your vote! My vote. Your vote for him is based on the idea that he is the only scum left remaining. Perhaps a comma instead of a period would have helped that sentence read better. My vote was a little self preservation vote and and off of the fact that I mostly trust your reveal. But I removed because voting for Barghast based on a single scum idea isn't something that I believe.

[Galayn Lord]

Kaschan, on 03 June 2014 - 09:02 PM, said:

Buggers why couldn't we have lynched either Barghast or Eloth before today.

A deppressingly familiar mantra.

[Kaschan]

Galayn Lord, on 03 June 2014 - 09:08 PM, said:

Kaschan, on 03 June 2014 - 09:02 PM, said:

Buggers why couldn't we have lynched either Barghast or Eloth before today.

A deppressingly familiar mantra.

Yeah so we are stuck right dab in the middle of a cluster. I mostly think that your town (just a hint of doubt in the back of my head) but don't agree that there is only one scum. Eloth thinks that Pallid is town but Pallid has Eloth in his top three. Eloth also thinks that Denul is the most scummy player left but is voting for me. Barghast thinks that Eloth is lying and is scum. Denul has been to l-1 today. True it was only for a minute or so but still. The fact that scum didn't jump on and hammer is a little suspicious.

[Pallid]

or the scum were already on the train

or the scum weren't online.

I dislike pushing the idea of 1 killer left, its giving us an idea of a tomorrow if we hit wrong. This one has to stick people, frankly I'm becoming suspicious of GL for pedalling the solo idea, only works if you KNOW there's one killer left and want to paint a corpse as a symp.

[Pallid]

I'm in bed.

My vote stays, new order kasch, barg, eloth/gl, denul.

wont be here for end of day.



good night

[Galayn Lord]

Pallid, on 03 June 2014 - 09:19 PM, said:

or the scum were already on the train

or the scum weren't online.

I dislike pushing the idea of 1 killer left, its giving us an idea of a tomorrow if we hit wrong. This one has to stick people, frankly I'm becoming suspicious of GL for pedalling the solo idea, only works if you KNOW there's one killer left and want to paint a corpse as a symp.

I don't know anything. It's my theory based on my reading of the thread. Of course I could be wrong. But with this much division amongst ALL of us, I'm finding it hard to see where there could be a pair of killers. A killer and symp remaining is possibly more likely. You're welcome to disagree and show me a good candidate for a pairing.

[Denul]

Eloth says he won't return but then does when he gets a vote.

Kaschan makes some great points up above.

Makes me want to vote Eloth

[Galayn Lord]

If not Barghast, I think the best choice would be to vote off either myself or Eloth, in order to possibly clear up the thread a little one way or the other.

[Galayn Lord]

(if the game doesn't end anyway)

[Denul]

I'll vote in an hour. Just before bed. Probably going to be Eloth

[Barghast]

Pallid, on 03 June 2014 - 09:20 PM, said:

I'm in bed.

My vote stays, new order kasch, barg, eloth/gl, denul.

wont be here for end of day.



good night

This is pathetic. Pathetic. This keeps you from having to reveal your feelings or discussing any further, and its like having an excuse to not have to vote for Eloth, and if he comes back scum, you claim you didn't vote him because you were asleep,

Eloth, on 03 June 2014 - 08:53 PM, said:

Oh do whatever the fuck you like, I documented yesterday that, RIGHT AFTER TWO PEOPLE I KNOW TO BE TOWN, YOU ARE THE LEAST LIKELY TO BE SCUM, earlier today I mentioned THAT I WOULD GLADLY VOTE FOR KASCHAN IF DENUL LYNCH IS NOT POSSIBLE, and decided to change my vote TO GET A SATISFACTORY FUCKING LYNCH ON D-DAY after Denul once more weaseled his way out of one.

How is this for Buddying up to you; You are a total idiot, who just handed scum ANOTHER easy fucking win. GG.

I will now be SURPRISED if you don't turn up scum.

"He's trying to get a lynch, he previously stated he found desirable, that isn't me he must be Scum!"

CHRIST.

I need to backtrack a bit on the calling you scummy for switching votes - I'm a hypocrites for doing the same. But I'm seeing scum everywhere. The underlined part was the type of response I was looking for when I made that post. You were all ready to claim me town, then as soon as I said I thought you scummy, you're ready to flip flop. This is why I thought you might be just tying to buddy up to me so I won't vote you.

But honestly, this can be a scummy statement or not, and you all can lynch me for it, but I would be willing to lynch any one of you at this point. I'm starting to feel like each of you is as good a guess as the other, and its screwing with my judgement.

One of those damn reveals NEEDS to be tested or we're fools, are we not? I'm sticking with Eloth or GL. Screw you pallid. If you are scum then disregard this, but if you're town and you help lose this for us, I don't want to hear any of those excuses you like to give.

[Barghast]

Galayn Lord, on 03 June 2014 - 09:31 PM, said:

If not Barghast, I think the best choice would be to vote off either myself or Eloth, in order to possibly clear up the thread a little one way or the other.

Dude. Think about it. The night you CLAIM to have lost a BP, you didn't reveal until later. And since there was no night kill, and since you had yet to reveal this(and Eloth couldn't have known you would if its both true and you're town) , Eloth claimed he healed Ampelas. He'd revealed healer to escape a lynch. He didn't get NKed for it. If he withheld a kill to claim this, he couldn't have known you'd been targeted and lost a BP. It's not so much as your late reveal as it has been your over willingness to believe Eloth. So it looks like you're scum and he's your partner. Period.