4 triains going. Not bad, I see we're really pushing options. I think we need to address the elephant in the room though.
I'm gonna try address my thoughts on each train later but I'm laying down a vote on Korabas and will explain why.
Denul, on 18 April 2014 - 02:15 AM, said:
Okral Lom, on 18 April 2014 - 01:16 AM, said:
Bek Okhan, on 18 April 2014 - 12:53 AM, said:
Korabas, on 18 April 2014 - 12:26 AM, said:
Lock, on 18 April 2014 - 12:14 AM, said:
What Eloth said. Add to that that at one point you call it 'one' guard and others you imply you can use it indefinitely until another warlord pops their clogs.
Yeah a BP is more accurate. In fact, reading over the ability, it actually says that it is a bullet proof, not a guard. That's me being a nub. The move is called
Dextrocardia Situs Inversus; I can't make that sort of shit up. The actual role keeps me from getting NK'd so long as there are other warlords alive. I only had to use it once, hence the 'one'. I get nothing from stringing town along. If you need to lynch me to feel better, go ahead. It's not a bad call at this point. I'm just letting you all know whats going on over on my end. That's it.
Anyone still making this the centre of discussion should be considered later in game. I'm willing to bet there's a scum in here somewhere.
Also, this name doesn't really fit with the theme of the game. It's a condition where the organs are on the other side of the body to where they are usually found.
To be honest, that sounds pretty plausible to me - someone tries to hit you in the heart when they attack, but miss because it's not where they thought it was. Or something like that.
I don't like the way Korabas is trying to tar the names of those who question him, but I do find his reveal plausible. Going to have a look around and see if there's anything else to act as a counterpoint to the Tiam case. Not saying I don't think that's a good case, but there need to be multiple options on the table.
It's abstractly plausible. Korabas is basically trying to hint that he is Souther, one of the gangleaders, who has Dextrocardia. But in the manga its called Emperor's Armor and I think if Shin had included it it would be called that. Furthermore, based on how it plays out in the manga it would really just be a single BP, not some weird toggle BP that kills you if the other warlords are dead.
3 Votes Korabas:
Korabas has a very shaky looking reveal, so many odd things, I basically agree with the cross examinations above. I've been on the receiving end of an ability discussion gone wrong. It's gonna be impossible to buy but thats the catch 22, the truth can seem so outrageous its hard to see it as anything else but a lie. The whole thing is too bizzarre. Someone said something earlier to this effect, "how does any of it even help Korabas?" I'm not seeing it ATM. Maybe Korabas slipped in a few lies to aide his agenda but I don't see how it'd help anyone, It's effectively painting two targets on his back and tempting both shooters (town or scum) to wait and see what the other shooter does before acting on him.
Suppose Korabas is a Warleader with a BP. Won't know for sure till another Warleader dies and I guess we just need to debate the worth of waiting for proof.
Kesso asked earlier how does Town respond to this if its true? Well Theres nothing I think town can do in response besides Waiting or lynching. The only proof I'd believe is a failed NA, Don't see that happening, pretty sure scum are loving the likes of Denul and Korabas right now, and I mean if either of them are actually scum we are being shamelessly hoodwinked.
If we get a confirmed Warleader taken out spotlight shifts to Korabas. Should he last the night by design he starts to look scummy and muddies future decisions when in later days things should start to look clearer, I know its a huge WIFOMism but I'm driving at the simple fact either way no one can rely on Korabas one way or the other. I don't see town hurting without Korabas as he adds plenty of confusion and has not got the best handle on the game. That all said I see Korabas as a town player either not thinking clearly or playing a VERY risky game.
I mentioned earlier confusion around Korabas might be good for town but Korabas has since explained alot of specifics that "tell" scum how to go about things and "tell" town how to handle his reveal. It's all gonna come to a head and our only real gain is deciding to deny scum a VC or not. something I also realize might not even happen if Korabas isn't even who he claims to be!
On the odd chance we have a BP townie I don't think we get much of the benefit with the BP out there in the open. I just think Korabas would be the worst possible town to have endgame and with Denul still around thats saying alot.
TL;dR: we lynch to clear towns game and possibly prevent scums second VC.
Vote Korabas
More from me after breakfast. I'm on for another hour or so.