[Telas]

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:47 PM, said:

Wait. If SL was innocent, why didn't he want to vote Kalse?

Ok I'm back on the case. Spilled milk is spilled milk. Fuck. Let's figure it out.

Look, we had to verify the finder reveal, especially since it wasn't D-Day.

As far as the bit I quoted: are you suggesting SL was the symp?

[Tellan]

I'm retiring from the thread for a while, hopefully we'll be in day when I get back.

Giving myself a headache trying to follow Sorrit's flow of consciousness style post.

[Kaschan]

Kalse, on 31 July 2012 - 10:00 AM, said:

we cant afford another mistake


I really hope we have the time and players to get a lynch

I am a finder, and ive found that shelly and kaschan are both scum

you really cant trust those ducks.

we are a little closer to the end that I had hoped and im probably going to get NKed for this but Its best I tell you what I have found

vote kaschan

have to get one of them

Well, here's the BS of the day. What do you hope to gain from this? Only scum would try this kind of crap, picking someone that wasn't around, trying to get them lynched on some fake reveal. You're either a symp or a suicidal killer, either way, you suck

[Sorrit]

Telas, on 31 July 2012 - 12:40 PM, said:

Jesus, sorrit, you sure are dense.


We lynch Kalse tomorrow, knowing he is the symp (symps never CF scum, that's the definition of symp--so this was a fake reveal)

We will have 3 scum 6 town alive after night resolves. Lynch Kalse, night resolves. 2 scum 5 town. Then we go from there, seeing what forced Kalse to fake reveal so early in the game--clearly we can find it somewhere in the tellan/liosan/rashan circle.

We can only miss once after that. We miss, it goes 2 to 3. Another miss is scum game. Kalse was setting up this scenario. That's all I was worried about. One miss, the next is game. I just don't like it.

[Sorrit]

Telas, on 31 July 2012 - 12:49 PM, said:

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:47 PM, said:

Wait. If SL was innocent, why didn't he want to vote Kalse?

Ok I'm back on the case. Spilled milk is spilled milk. Fuck. Let's figure it out.

Look, we had to verify the finder reveal, especially since it wasn't D-Day.

As far as the bit I quoted: are you suggesting SL was the symp?

No. That would make Kalse a killer. That would hurt them. Cuz we lynch Kalse, then that would of left one scum.

I was just saying Kalse is the symp. I figured that out soon as he revealed. Just makes no sense for SL to not have wanted to kill a fake finder, if he was Inno, you know?. Just odd.

[Kalse]

kaschan is scum!! hes a killer, my main thoughts now are on the 2nd killer

Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:30 AM, said:

I say we lynch SL, as I believe this may be a play by Kalse to clear him. I find him the more suspicious of the pair anyway.

remove vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore

I think tellan is the other killer. and he used this post to switch from the killer to the symp
no find to back this up however as i expect to die tonight I thought i point it out while i still can

[Sorrit]

Plus Telas, atrahal, you realize I'm still going to have two scum on my cases saying things about my play. I can't assume it's talk from a reasonable town. I'd expect both killers to attack my logic. Because my logic had Kalse as symp. It just worried me when atrahal said not to kill the symp.

[Sorrit]

Kalse, on 31 July 2012 - 12:53 PM, said:

kaschan is scum!! hes a killer, my main thoughts now are on the 2nd killer

Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:30 AM, said:

I say we lynch SL, as I believe this may be a play by Kalse to clear him. I find him the more suspicious of the pair anyway.

remove vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore

I think tellan is the other killer. and he used this post to switch from the killer to the symp
no find to back this up however as i expect to die tonight I thought i point it out while i still can

You die tonight ? Tellan is clean.

[Tellan]

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:57 PM, said:

Kalse, on 31 July 2012 - 12:53 PM, said:

kaschan is scum!! hes a killer, my main thoughts now are on the 2nd killer

Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:30 AM, said:

I say we lynch SL, as I believe this may be a play by Kalse to clear him. I find him the more suspicious of the pair anyway.

remove vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore

I think tellan is the other killer. and he used this post to switch from the killer to the symp
no find to back this up however as i expect to die tonight I thought i point it out while i still can

You die tonight ? Tellan is clean.

Goddammit, stop posting this shit on thread. Put it in your PMs or notes. You're just WIFOMing the place up, and saying this before night resolves is 100% worse than saying it after, and it's bad in BOTH situations.



Fuck, must needs stop refreshing. Its hard to be at the computer and not refresh mafia.

[Tennes]

I would vote off Kaschan next then because he HAS to CF as scum. Or Tellan because I've wanted to for ages. If Kaschan is not scum then it has to be kalse next.

[Sorrit]

My bad. Could of swore i posted that in notes. Oh Well.

You know they're killing me. Hush. They want the best out of the way.

[Atrahal]

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:53 PM, said:

Telas, on 31 July 2012 - 12:49 PM, said:

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:47 PM, said:

Wait. If SL was innocent, why didn't he want to vote Kalse?

Ok I'm back on the case. Spilled milk is spilled milk. Fuck. Let's figure it out.

Look, we had to verify the finder reveal, especially since it wasn't D-Day.

As far as the bit I quoted: are you suggesting SL was the symp?

No. That would make Kalse a killer. That would hurt them. Cuz we lynch Kalse, then that would of left one scum.

I was just saying Kalse is the symp. I figured that out soon as he revealed. Just makes no sense for SL to not have wanted to kill a fake finder, if he was Inno, you know?. Just odd.

Are you fucking kidding me? If you think someone is a symp you don't attack the symp, you attack the person they are defending. THAT WAY, you have a chance at catching the killer. There is no fucking point in going after the symp. Lynching the symp won't win us the game, and a symp's CF won't even confirm if we have hit scum. If we have the opportunity to hit a killer we need to take it.

And don't give me this bullshit about knowing Kalse was the symp. That is the saddest backpedalling I've ever seen.

Now you're trying to cast suspicion on those who are questioning you. Wake up sunshine, this is Mafia, this is how it's played.

[Telas]

Well now that logic doesn't make sense. If Kalse is NKed (read: inno) how does that clear tellan in any way???

[Sorrit]

Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 01:04 PM, said:

I would vote off Kaschan next then because he HAS to CF as scum. Or Tellan because I've wanted to for ages. If Kaschan is not scum then it has to be kalse next.

You're so smart, Ta......Tennes! I'm glad you're around.

[Kaschan]

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:41 AM, said:

Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:35 AM, said:

Sorrit are you the symp?

Are you guys retarded or something?

If he CFs finder WE WIN. GAME OVER. WE LYNCH SL AND KASCHAN NEXT TWO DAYS.

If he's fucking with us, we lynched another innocent. Then we have to kill Rashan and Tellan. May have only covered for one. Still don't know the other.

How is lynching Kalse Not Our best plan? We fucking win if he's finder.

Scum POSSIBLE 3, town 6 tomorow. We can easily kill SL and then Kaschan.

If he's lying and we kill an Inno, its scum 3 possibly, and town 6, but we still have to lynch Rashan and tellan.

And if there not BOTH scum, they fucked us.

Figure it out, dips.

Lynch Kalse.

this doesn't make sense, don't expect we would see anything other than inno or scum in the CF

[Sorrit]

Atrahal, on 31 July 2012 - 01:05 PM, said:

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:53 PM, said:

Telas, on 31 July 2012 - 12:49 PM, said:

Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 12:47 PM, said:

Wait. If SL was innocent, why didn't he want to vote Kalse?

Ok I'm back on the case. Spilled milk is spilled milk. Fuck. Let's figure it out.

Look, we had to verify the finder reveal, especially since it wasn't D-Day.

As far as the bit I quoted: are you suggesting SL was the symp?

No. That would make Kalse a killer. That would hurt them. Cuz we lynch Kalse, then that would of left one scum.

I was just saying Kalse is the symp. I figured that out soon as he revealed. Just makes no sense for SL to not have wanted to kill a fake finder, if he was Inno, you know?. Just odd.

Are you fucking kidding me? If you think someone is a symp you don't attack the symp, you attack the person they are defending. THAT WAY, you have a chance at catching the killer. There is no fucking point in going after the symp. Lynching the symp won't win us the game, and a symp's CF won't even confirm if we have hit scum. If we have the opportunity to hit a killer we need to take it.

And don't give me this bullshit about knowing Kalse was the symp. That is the saddest backpedalling I've ever seen.

Now you're trying to cast suspicion on those who are questioning you. Wake up sunshine, this is Mafia, this is how it's played.

Argue with Telas. He thinks the same. I'm done arguing, which I already said. Time for cooperation.

[Telas]

1.) Why does Kaschan "HAVE" to CF as scum? Wtf people, unless the game's mechanics violate all mafia mechanics (finder gets scum ping from the symp), then Kalse had to have been lying, i.e. scum. He probably won't get NKed anyway even if he was inno since no one trusts him, and confusion == good for scum.

2.) Kalse was around at the beginning of day 3 and didn't reveal. He claimed work, disappeared, then showed up as a last-minute we-need-a-lynch train was building on Tellan. He had 3 votes when kalse made his reveal.

[Sorrit]

I thought Tellan had two votes. Tennes and another. Can you clarify the 3 if you already know. Save me a minute or three.

[Sorrit]

In case I die, kill Kalse, then Rashan. If Rashan is Inno, kill tellan. If Rashan is scum, kill tellan.

When Kalse did his obvious fake finder routine, I was voting Rashan. Tennes Was voting Rashan, but swapped to tellan.

[Kalse]

Well done to tellen for switching us from kaschan to sl, its cost town the game...