POOPOO MCBUMFACE, on 20 May 2011 - 09:59 AM, said:
I'm definitely in the minority on it, and I don't feel his writing was much weaker than usual (as I felt it was in UA). tbh, I just felt that the humanist themes were done better in some of the mainline Discworld books like Small Gods - which, to be fair, is one of my favourites, so it's hard to compare objectively - and got a bit preachy in parts. It wasn't a bad book overall, though, and would be great by most authors' standards; I just feel that it doesn't stack up against some of his previous work.
Night Watch was bloody great, though. Maybe my favourite of them all.
I <3 Night Watch so dang much, but I can't ever recommend it as the first Discworld book to newbies. The Thief of Time gets that nod, and I urge the readers to backtrack to Wyrd Sisters and then mow the rest down.
I didn't like Small Gods that much. Pyramids seemed to hit many of the same themes and with lighter humor for me. But Small Gods did have Lu-Tze popping up in it...
I survived the Permian and all I got was this t-shirt.