Obdigore, on 21 August 2018 - 05:23 PM, said:
Anyone play both Divinity: Original Sin II and either of the Pillars of Eternity games, and if so, can you compare them for me?
Also if you tried the multiplayer in Divinity: Original Sin II and can let me know if its stupid trash or not that'd be super helpful.
Thanks.
Well, first off, they're both excellent, and they're both HUGE.
I'm talking specifically about the first PoE, as I haven't bought the second one yet. The story is decent and some of the companions you can recruit are fun, although none are up to the standard of Minsc and Boo
Combat can be paused to queue actions for each member of your party (you can have up to five companions) but you have to manually pause it unlike in Baldur's Gate. I played it when it first came out and chose the Cipher class and found it was quite OP. Not sure if they've nerfed it since, and I haven't replayed as any of the other classes so can't comment on them. I did find that, when swarmed with enemies, it could get quite muddled but generally I found it really enjoyable. My playthrough ended up at about 80 hours, not including the White March expansion(s). Oh, and there's way too many spiders in it.
DOS II is fantastic. Unlike the first game it's got a good story that gives it real impetus. It looks gorgeous. You can choose from one of five or six pre-made characters or create your own from scratch. The pre-made characters each have their own quest line, and they turn up in game as companions (you can only have up to three of them in your party at one time, though), and they are all brilliant. It's got proper turn-based combat and a host of class-specific abilities that can produce spectacular results. It doesn't hold your hand and the difficulty can spike suddenly when you wander into areas where the enemies are higher level than you. The quests don't recommend what level you need to be, so I find it can be time-consuming and a bit frustrating to work out where to go next if you hit that difficulty barrier, especially as the battles can last a long time. Inventory management can be a pain in the arse, especially when bartering. HOWEVER, I believe they have done a lot to address these gripes with the console version coming out (and free 'Definitive Edition' update on pc, on August 31st I believe).
The drop in/drop out multiplayer (on pc) works like a charm and is great fun. It will take a LONG time to complete, though. My current game is standing at 70 hours and I'm nowhere near finishing it.
If I had to pick between the two I'd definitely go for DOS II. No hesitation. It's awesome.