[Hood's Path]

You won't find much unfortunately. He's been a low poster and has random voted a couple of times. His vote on day three was a switch from Sorrit to Alkend.

He was the first vote on Sorrit, and his vote change later swung the number from Sorrit 4/Alkend 3 to Alkend4/Sorrit3. That "swing" vote makes me think Alkend's cool, and puts a question mark on Sorrit. (although voting him in the first place and leaving that vote for a good number of hours would be pretty ballsy).

Edit: added "a couple of times" for clarity

This post has been edited by Hood's Path: 28 April 2010 - 05:23 PM

[Eloth]

Right wcs is three scum left if we don't lynch correctly we lose today.

2 scum left Day 8 is d day.

1 scum is left then then it day 9. That we can rule out if Tulas is symp.

Which means if it 3 scum left to survive any longer we want to lynch Tulas.

If it Two scum left removing him gives us an extra day.

Rightwhat you said is very believable.

Ok I'll go with it.

Remove Vote
Vote Tulas Shorn

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 7. 3 hours and 28 minutes remaining
8 Players still alive: Alkend, D'riss, Eloth, Galain, Hood's Path, Korbas, Sorrit, Tulas Shorn

5 votes to lynch, 4 votes to go to night.

1 Vote for Alkend ( Sorrit )
2 Votes for Tulas Shorn ( Hood's Path, Eloth )
1 Vote for Eloth ( Tulas Shorn )

Players not voted: Alkend, D'riss, Galain, Korbas

[Sorrit]

remove vote

Vote Tulas Shorn

barring a counter reveal, we are basically exchanging a symp for our remaining roled player. BUT this menas that we at least get to make the scum kill us all for a win and the majority. I'll take that tradde.

I would have liked you to hold your reveal for one more night. You were under lynch pressure, so not a likely NK... but oh well. pandora's box is opened and what can we do... that being said...

while you are still around I wonder if it wouldn't be better to look for the killer. With Tulas' vote today I would be insanely surprised if Eloth is the last scum. That makes Me, Eloth and HP VPI in my book right now. ( this is all barring a counter reveal, if that happens, I'll have to reevaluate) leaving the Killer in the Galain/Korbas/D'riss/Alkend group.

Since we now know Korbas isn't a symp, his attacks on Alkend make more sense. I am leaning towards Korbas being the remaining Killer, maybe Alkend. Imo we should save Tulas for tomorrow while we still have HP and try for the Killer today when we have more known inno's. Thoughts on that idea?

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 7. 3 hours and 28 minutes remaining
8 Players still alive: Alkend, D'riss, Eloth, Galain, Hood's Path, Korbas, Sorrit, Tulas Shorn

5 votes to lynch, 4 votes to go to night.

3 Votes for Tulas Shorn ( Hood's Path, Eloth, Sorrit )
1 Vote for Eloth ( Tulas Shorn )

Players not voted: Alkend, D'riss, Galain, Korbas

[Hood's Path]

I gotta go to bed. Good luck sorting things out. I feel I've done my duty and contributed to China's 5000 year history!


Tulas Shorne's death will ensure Yuan Shao's safety a bit longer. I wish I could have used this to find the killer, and I put off revealing 2 days in a row to try, but Tulas's RL situation and low posting has sort of forced my hand.

[Hood's Path]

Sorrit, on 28 April 2010 - 05:26 PM, said:

remove vote

Vote Tulas Shorn

barring a counter reveal, we are basically exchanging a symp for our remaining roled player. BUT this menas that we at least get to make the scum kill us all for a win and the majority. I'll take that tradde.

I would have liked you to hold your reveal for one more night. You were under lynch pressure, so not a likely NK... but oh well. pandora's box is opened and what can we do... that being said...

while you are still around I wonder if it wouldn't be better to look for the killer. With Tulas' vote today I would be insanely surprised if Eloth is the last scum. That makes Me, Eloth and HP VPI in my book right now. ( this is all barring a counter reveal, if that happens, I'll have to reevaluate) leaving the Killer in the Galain/Korbas/D'riss/Alkend group.

Since we now know Korbas isn't a symp, his attacks on Alkend make more sense. I am leaning towards Korbas being the remaining Killer, maybe Alkend. Imo we should save Tulas for tomorrow while we still have HP and try for the Killer today when we have more known inno's. Thoughts on that idea?

Huh? How do we now know Korbas isn't a symp? And Alkend looks pretty PI to me at the moment. I don't follow your reasoning.

[Sorrit]

Hood, on 28 April 2010 - 05:22 PM, said:

You won't find much unfortunately. He's been a low poster and has random voted a couple of times. His vote on day three was a switch from Sorrit to Alkend.

He was the first vote on Sorrit, and his vote change later swung the number from Sorrit 4/Alkend 3 to Alkend4/Sorrit3. That "swing" vote makes me think Alkend's cool, and puts a question mark on Sorrit. (although voting him in the first place and leaving that vote for a good number of hours would be pretty ballsy).

Edit: added "a couple of times" for clarity

I forgot about that... yup, I really doubt it would be Alkend in that case. Thinking it's Korbas as the last Killer. Galain as a runner up, and D'riss a distant third.

lol I am all over the place.

[Eloth]

Damn Korv was inno

Edit put symp instead of inno

This post has been edited by Eloth: 28 April 2010 - 05:32 PM

[D'riss]

Hood, on 28 April 2010 - 05:22 PM, said:

You won't find much unfortunately. He's been a low poster and has random voted a couple of times. His vote on day three was a switch from Sorrit to Alkend.

He was the first vote on Sorrit, and his vote change later swung the number from Sorrit 4/Alkend 3 to Alkend4/Sorrit3. That "swing" vote makes me think Alkend's cool, and puts a question mark on Sorrit. (although voting him in the first place and leaving that vote for a good number of hours would be pretty ballsy).

Edit: added "a couple of times" for clarity

What are the chances Tulas was signaling Sorrit, and once Sorrit came out with the whole PM inno 'fiasko' and got considered CI from other people, he simply ducked down and tried to play under the radar himself?

Like I said, people CI Sorrit because he used the 'check my reveal if you are inno, you will know I am inno too' arguement - yet he got a slap in the wrist for that by having his vote removed instead of getting mod killed.I don't know if that is a valid strategy for scum to use, but like I said earlier, if Sorrit comes up as the other roled killer, I will feel 'cheated' if he was allowed to use that.

[Sorrit]

Hood, on 28 April 2010 - 05:28 PM, said:

Sorrit, on 28 April 2010 - 05:26 PM, said:

remove vote

Vote Tulas Shorn

barring a counter reveal, we are basically exchanging a symp for our remaining roled player. BUT this menas that we at least get to make the scum kill us all for a win and the majority. I'll take that tradde.

I would have liked you to hold your reveal for one more night. You were under lynch pressure, so not a likely NK... but oh well. pandora's box is opened and what can we do... that being said...

while you are still around I wonder if it wouldn't be better to look for the killer. With Tulas' vote today I would be insanely surprised if Eloth is the last scum. That makes Me, Eloth and HP VPI in my book right now. ( this is all barring a counter reveal, if that happens, I'll have to reevaluate) leaving the Killer in the Galain/Korbas/D'riss/Alkend group.

Since we now know Korbas isn't a symp, his attacks on Alkend make more sense. I am leaning towards Korbas being the remaining Killer, maybe Alkend. Imo we should save Tulas for tomorrow while we still have HP and try for the Killer today when we have more known inno's. Thoughts on that idea?

Huh? How do we now know Korbas isn't a symp? And Alkend looks pretty PI to me at the moment. I don't follow your reasoning.

Yeah, x-post. Alkend is pretty PI, I forgot about Tulas' vote swing.

So you think there were four symps and 2 killers in a 21 person game? that seems overpowered. We know Kesso Gamelon and Tulas are symps... Another symp seems overboard.

[Eloth]

What Sorrit suggested can be modkillable I believe depending on the mod.

[Hood's Path]

Granted, I may know if Korbas isn't a symp, but you'll have to pardon me if I don't share that with you.

And sorry I didn't hold off my reveal again, but I was worried Tulas could lose the game for us. And that I could be killed. I held off 2 nail biting nights as it was. Damn lynches are always in the middle of the night for me.

[Sorrit]

D, on 28 April 2010 - 05:31 PM, said:

Hood, on 28 April 2010 - 05:22 PM, said:

You won't find much unfortunately. He's been a low poster and has random voted a couple of times. His vote on day three was a switch from Sorrit to Alkend.

He was the first vote on Sorrit, and his vote change later swung the number from Sorrit 4/Alkend 3 to Alkend4/Sorrit3. That "swing" vote makes me think Alkend's cool, and puts a question mark on Sorrit. (although voting him in the first place and leaving that vote for a good number of hours would be pretty ballsy).

Edit: added "a couple of times" for clarity

What are the chances Tulas was signaling Sorrit, and once Sorrit came out with the whole PM inno 'fiasko' and got considered CI from other people, he simply ducked down and tried to play under the radar himself?

Like I said, people CI Sorrit because he used the 'check my reveal if you are inno, you will know I am inno too' arguement - yet he got a slap in the wrist for that by having his vote removed instead of getting mod killed.I don't know if that is a valid strategy for scum to use, but like I said earlier, if Sorrit comes up as the other roled killer, I will feel 'cheated' if he was allowed to use that.

I'm not scum. the fact that you can't see that just placed you with Galain on my list for possible scum. Why would I get slapped on the wrist for semi-quoting a PM that didn't exist? That would then be considered a lie, and as far as I know thats an integral part of mafia.

[Hood's Path]

Ahh, I see what you're saying Sorrit. I have to admit I've been playing with WCS Kesso actually wasn't a symp. I realize it is most likely that he was, but I didn't see what he wrote, and I won't know the real circumstances until SH.

[D'riss]

vote Tulas Shorne

[Korbas]

Right, I've returned. The GF borrowed the laptop to do work at the library and forgot it there... Just got it back.

[Hood's Path]

With that said, my vote is there. I have no more info to share really. Check into Tulas yourselves and see if you find something I missed. Sorry for not providing the killer themselves.

I am dead on my feet, so I"m off.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 7. 3 hours and 15 minutes remaining
8 Players still alive: Alkend, D'riss, Eloth, Galain, Hood's Path, Korbas, Sorrit, Tulas Shorn

5 votes to lynch, 4 votes to go to night.

4 Votes for Tulas Shorn ( Hood's Path, Eloth, Sorrit, D'riss )
1 Vote for Eloth ( Tulas Shorn )

Players not voted: Alkend, Galain, Korbas

[Eloth]

That means we have to get a killer with two lynches.

I think this might go down to the line.