[Peanutbutta]

Seemed like you were always a step behind, GK. You had to get into a position of power by finding a lynch bloc, but you couldn't really support Bill because you needed him dead. You pretty much had to side with the assassin to win, or at least The Bride for a while and then if Bill was removed, the Town or the Assassin.

This post has been edited by Peanutbutta: 17 December 2009 - 05:29 PM

[Rashan]

Fun Game PB.. i think you shortened my life by 11 minutes with all the stressing/self doubting I did.

I learned a rule this game...:

If a mothertrucker cant be NK'd after 4 kills.. mothertrucker is BP.. Damn!

I continue my streak of nnever being lynched in a Malaz mafia game tho

I had a lot of fun. thanks!

[General King]

Well pb you will want to play my dominion war game

And that was a characteristically bad game on my part

This post has been edited by General King: 17 December 2009 - 05:38 PM

[Obdigore]

I enjoyed the game. I 'missed' a lot of my sushi's, because my vote didn't matter, and by the time I knew who to vote for (Kalse/Sorrit) I doubted anyone with a voting power would actually vote for them.

I also had no idea that the bride would FM to a different alt if killed/lynched, because Baudin never told me. I was under the impression that I was all that was left of the Brides' Party.

[General King]

It was a good game. Even though I fucked up badly I enjoyed it.

[Giles]

im a bit paranoid, i didnt want you giving stuff away although what was that comment about hoping i had my provisional in

[Obdigore]

If I made a comment like that, I don't remember it, or what it was referring too.

I had no idea I became Bride 2.0 if Baudin died the final death.

[Giles]

Shadow, on 16 December 2009 - 10:56 PM, said:

@Fener - don't talk on thread, unless the game is over, and no I didn't.

Also - I hope you got your prov in Alkend.

Reading that as me, it looked like you basically just told everyone i was going to jump. Luckily only Sorrit noticed it and then only barely

[Giles]

Also why did noone believe me when i told you all Rashan was the assassin granted id worked it out firstly from meta as his kill wasnt in when HP ended the day so its probably someone who hadnt checked in and that was just me and Rashan iirc

[General King]

If I figured that you were a FM I may have swung that vote on you based on the fact you weren't bill. as I said I thought you were alive as alkend was a cf double instead.

[Sir Thursday]

All that time I spent sweating over what to say to Kalse, and she never got any of them? Man...

Really enjoyed the game PB, but a few slight criticisms:

1) I think having so many BPs in the game makes it inevitable that the game was going to go down to the wire, not because of good balancing, per se, but because the main characters are nigh-on unkillable and thus are pretty much guaranteed to be there at the end. I can just about stomach blanket night BPs, but then to increase the number of votes it takes to lynch them as well? All they have to do is low-post until the numbers decrease to the point that they're all but unlynchable, like Shadow did. Each team had a ridiculously overpowered role, so it was those roles that were left at the end, and I don't think that would have changed even if the Vipers hadn't imploded at the start. It might have been O-Ren instead of me hanging around at the end, but that's about it.

2) Making a scum victory condition that only certain members of the town need to be gotten rid of in order for them to win paralyzes the town. Everyone was reticent to throw a case out there because of the possibility that they might hit one of the Vipers (hell, the one time I conquered that fear I managed to hit Bill), which leads to stagnant days where everyone sits back and nothing happens. That was compounded by having so many roles that seemed like the best plan was to hide until the endgame.

But apart from those major criticisms, it was fun, especially the last few days. Only problem was, I don't really think I had much of a shot at winning given what I was up against, looking back. My opponents were a Big Ben with 2 NKs per night, an Unkillable symp of that Big Ben, an assassin who not only had a blanket night BP but also a 1 time lynch BP, and Quentin Tarantino. Now that's a pretty tough ask for the surviving player who was most vulnerable both during the day and during the night. All comes back to my point about the inevitability of the uber-roles being left at the end.

Anyhow, thanks for running this PB. Your scenes were great, and it's awesome to get to read through such a detailed SH for once. Just a shame that there was a bit too much defensive firepower in the game.


Sir Thursday

[Peanutbutta]

Thanks for being honest, Thursday I had a lot of fun with you.

[Mentalist]

Path-Shaper, on 17 December 2009 - 04:37 PM, said:

Well the game ended with GK suiciding on the Sorrit lynch vote. Was a lot of fun to mod. Apologies to Ment for killing him on accident early, and hope everyone had a good time!

so.... who won?

Mentalist, oblivious to the world.

Seriously, the last few days have been really hectic and without actually playing, I've had little incentive to follow the game.

in retrospect, I had fun whilst I was playing, although I was totally clueless most of the time (the only case i've made was on JA... who was a viper), but it was fun, and my playstyle probably would've let me live untill we got to a somewhat critical point, so i regret being killed by mistake. but i'm not bitter about it.

[Giles]

Path-Shaper, on 15 December 2009 - 05:33 PM, said:

Alkend, on 15 December 2009 - 05:42 PM, said:

hmm everyone keeps saying Rashan seems innocent, is it just me that thinks he could be the assassin

Path-Shaper, on 15 December 2009 - 05:42 PM, said:

I dunno, is it?!

Alkend, on 15 December 2009 - 05:46 PM, said:

Well atm he is my prime target for being the assassin and his case just now definitely smacks of him being the assassin with that afterthought post which could easily be him going "shit, just realised they need the assassin to help better tell them that or theyll think i might be"

Path-Shaper, on 15 December 2009 - 05:47 PM, said:

Well then you'll probably think you're very clever if you are correct, and very silly if you are wrong!

Just going through the posts and found this and thought id repost it for posterity

This post has been edited by baudin: 18 December 2009 - 08:54 PM