[Tapper]

Peanutbutta, on 03 December 2009 - 10:49 PM, said:

Morgoth, on 03 December 2009 - 08:42 PM, said:

Hmpf.. If they'd but waited one day to lynch me, all this would've worked out fine.

Technically, it should go on until someone wins, meaning Mockra would have to kill Eloth if there's a falling out. However, that seems unnecessary and cruel all told. It's a tough one.. I haven't been paying enough attention to assess the situation properly. Mockra not wanting to kill Eloth is too kind and sweet for my mind to comprehend.

ROFL. Well Tapper is the Lover of HHM for a reason!

I blame think it is the avatar

[Peanutbutta]

Well done reading. Good game to all, and special love to Tapper. Had a blast playing with you.

Now I think it's time for Kill Bill to finally make its debut, starting next week.

[General King]

What the list like of games like?

And would there be interest in a multithread game?

[Tapper]

Peanutbutta, on 03 December 2009 - 10:53 PM, said:

Well done reading. Good game to all, and special love to Tapper. Had a blast playing with you.

Now I think it's time for Kill Bill to finally make its debut, starting next week.

awesome, really looking forward to that. i'll start practising my Hattori Hanzo writing style.

[Tapper]

General King, on 03 December 2009 - 10:54 PM, said:

What the list like of games like?

And would there be interest in a multithread game?

page one of the mod thread has the next five numbered.

[Tapper]

Peanutbutta, on 03 December 2009 - 10:53 PM, said:

Well done reading. Good game to all, and special love to Tapper. Had a blast playing with you.

Likewise - was huge, huge fun

[Giles]

OK first yay i won
second what the hell was T45 thinking, he had to realise that as soon as he outed me i was going to screw him over to survive

[Giles]

Oh yeah and i have to say i actually really enjoyed this game it was brilliant, rep to Obdi fro creating it and rep to Dinivan for stepping in

[Mentalist]

FUCK

why the HELL was i not told what my second VC was?


I mean, yeah, i understand, try to keep the Denarians a secret and all (even though my FIRST PM lists them as the most likely "hidden faction"), but once I found Deidre, SURELY I could be told "oh, yeah, btw, you need the denarians dead, too, and only you can kill Nicodemus". Although I've made my share of mistakes in this game, knowing this would've made planning stuff a lot easier. Which is something I needed, considering almost every faction wanted me dead.

aso, why does it seem that I was the only one who was handicapped by the "double their power level to kill" mechanic.
and, I should've gotten the Lash coin and a power boost if I was in on the JA lynch. last time I let HD talk me into waiting on a lynch.
/whine


my key mistakes this game:
1) not removing my morgy vote to swing the lynch to Mockra
2) not hammering Anthras
3) not hammering JA the way I meant to.
4) not telling Bubba to hold off his action so that I could do an Ampelas find (way back)

I got completely unlucky with MTS's death, I hope he's alright.

my verdict: great game, apparently I can still be subtle in these games, even with my new job.
Also, I need a smartphone.

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 04 December 2009 - 04:53 AM

[Vengeance]

Path-Shaper, on 18 November 2009 - 04:35 PM, said:

The Faeries can offer as much as they want. The Denarians won't get the coins back if the people are killed by Harry's Team or the Knights, but should if they get killed/lynched.

I too am suprised by the utter lack of recruiting.

umm if some one had told me I could have gotten meanas coin back I would have recruited tapper for the win.... Just saying

[Jump Around]

Gavin, on 03 December 2009 - 12:41 PM, said:

Oh and great to see you back JA, how was the first game back for a while?

Lots of fun. Too many things happening that I had no clue about, which makes it hard to make plans, but I still managed to achieve a few things. A trio or roled players that can communicate off-thread was very strong, too bad you got yourself killed right away

[Mentalist]

it's only as effective as their co-ordination


my gameplan was completely dependant on the fact that me and MTS had similar timeslot, so we could coordinate well in the limited time I've had to play on weekdays.

by the way, the fact that I managed to be called a "high" poster, despite my severely cut posting times tells a lot about how the rest of you were playing,

[Jump Around]

Peanutbutta, on 03 December 2009 - 10:36 PM, said:

Jump Around, on 02 December 2009 - 05:23 PM, said:

Fucking Mockra, we were one lynch away of a potential majority (including my seduction) where we could do what we want and bring him with us to victory.

I even fake-revealed what I really was to attract a lynch from him down the line, because we needed one weather dude alive to win, and he comes up with that shitty fabulation about me betraying him. Nothing against that per se, but for the whole final counter-productiveness of it, and specially for chosing me as the target of his joke, PB is on my fucking list!

Venge should have pointed out way earlier the thing with me and Ruse. I kept urging it, but his strategy this game is full lurking. That would have been beautiful dissociation that would have sounded true, and would have forced Ruse to reveal as Harry. Anyways, I hope we still win, but I'm not sure how that will work. I have to check the SH thread to see if his recruit was successfull, although with me gone he should have vigged Rashan, since for sure he can vouch for Ruse being Harry (he's not even subtle about that on thread), and he will prevent any doubt about Ruse's reveal eventually.

And I admit I made a mistake with the guard, it was so obvious to me, and the thread was so full of lame real reveals, that I forgot I was not supposed to know that Still, who the fucks lynches someone who is obviously a finder? Rashan is trippin, I should see who this is.

Heh, the problem was the number of unknowns. I knew I could get 4 night votes with 8 players left: Nico, Gamelon, myself, and Eloth. But at 9 players, it was way too unpredictable. Sorry JA, but you still won <3

Sorry, I was angry at you at the time, but not because I thought you didn't play well or did it on purpose, just the frustration of trying to build plans with people who have no way of knowing them

Before the reveal I had you pegged as a RI with around 80% certainty. I feel for you with these stupid finder reveals, they are the bane of my existence (and I still lobbying hard to eliminate finders from our games where we have CFs). And that "betraying me" stuff was awesome, and did its role of putting chaos on thread, I was flattered of being chosen and was thinking of playing along with it for a while but I wasn't sure if it would have helped or not. I can really see now why they say you're gunning for my Weasel card.

And, yes, you are on my list

This post has been edited by Jump Around: 04 December 2009 - 06:13 AM

[Peanutbutta]

I thought you played well, Ment. Nico's team was hella strong, the Winter court was screwed from the start, and you made it to the end. The math just didn't quite add up for you, but you did very well.

[Jump Around]

Mentalist, on 04 December 2009 - 04:50 AM, said:

3) not hammering JA the way I meant to.

Admit it, deep inside you love me too much

[Peanutbutta]

lol I don't seek to take anybody's card, JA. I'll just earn my own.

[Jump Around]

Peanutbutta, on 04 December 2009 - 06:32 AM, said:

lol I don't seek to take anybody's card, JA. I'll just earn my own.

Well, maybe not gunning actively or litterally, but giving me a run for it.

We'll have to think of something good for you...

[Dinivan]

Vengeance, on 04 December 2009 - 05:43 AM, said:

Path-Shaper, on 18 November 2009 - 04:35 PM, said:

The Faeries can offer as much as they want. The Denarians won't get the coins back if the people are killed by Harry's Team or the Knights, but should if they get killed/lynched.

I too am suprised by the utter lack of recruiting.

umm if some one had told me I could have gotten meanas coin back I would have recruited tapper for the win.... Just saying

Arrrgghhh. I did wonder what happened to that coin. I thought that giving you the coin would solve matters supremely. I missed that post by Obdi. And I thought that such a coin-comes-back-mechanic would be too much power for the denarians, so I decided against it.

Big mistake found.

[Mentalist]

Jump Around, on 04 December 2009 - 06:16 AM, said:

Mentalist, on 04 December 2009 - 04:50 AM, said:

3) not hammering JA the way I meant to.

Admit it, deep inside you love me too much

nope, I just let HD talk me into being somewhat chivalrous.


my original intention was to hammer you @ 10 PM when i got home, so that night would get resolved before I went to work.

[Mentalist]

Peanutbutta, on 04 December 2009 - 06:14 AM, said:

I thought you played well, Ment. Nico's team was hella strong, the Winter court was screwed from the start, and you made it to the end. The math just didn't quite add up for you, but you did very well.

MTS not being there to defend himself against Mockra screwed me over,

since my time was limited, he was pretty much the extension of me on thread.

Still, I am happy i've managed to avoid being an early lynch. I've played it subtle, and many players did not know what teh hell I was, which was what i was aiming for in this game.