Emurlahn, on 24 October 2009 - 07:43 PM, said:
D, on 24 October 2009 - 01:14 PM, said:
there doesnt seem to be a case against telas, so i am unsure why kessobahn is suddenly voting for him. also i have to question eloth's vote simply because it comes off the back of people suggesting a link between omtose and him. The vote seems more self serving than decisive but i havent had a chance to look over the early stuff where this supposed link between the two was established to comment. Or perhaps i missed it on my skim read. The only thing i did pick up was a very panicked response to questions by omtose and a possible connection between olar and galain.
vote omtose
Right can D'riss explains this post, he talks about the only thing he picked up was OMtose behaviour and a possible connection between Olar and galain. But just in that post he also mentioned Kessobahn has put a vote on Telas which he doesn't understand, and he thinks that Eloth vote is self serving (is he suggesting that Eloth is distancing himself from some views that him and Omtose are linked).
So can he explain out of the four players still alive that he mentioned why Omtose was the one he voted for or is he jumping on the train.
Cause if you think that olar and galain are linked, why not vote for Olar?
Emurlahn, on 24 October 2009 - 08:29 PM, said:
Quote
Victory Conditions:
Town - Eliminate the Cullens, Queleti and all Killers.
Cullens - Eliminate the Evil Vampires, the Coven and all original members of the Queleti
Queleti - Eliminate the Town, and all original members of the Cullens
Evil Vampires - Kill the Cullens, Werewolves, Coven and Bella Swan
Coven - Kill Edward Cullen, Carlisle Cullen, Jacob Black, Billy Black, Charlie Swan, Bella Swan and Renesmee Swan.
Well the coven won't benefit from your death Olar if you are a cullen. And they seem to be in the lead with only 3 targets left.
Destruction of the cullens would benefit town, evil vampires and the queleti. It allows the other teams that are still in play to catch up with the coven.
But I don't think your a Cullen.
This is a bad argument. If we think Olar is Cullen, then he should NOTbe voted for. Yes, it doesn't help the Coven and it helps all otherfactions, BUT it does give the Coven a free day to do whatever they do.Plus, you have no real guarantee that Olar is actually Cullen and couldjust be wasting your time. And then you suddenly think he's not a Cullen? Weird.
Emurlahn, on 24 October 2009 - 09:50 PM, said:
So I can't ask you a question, D'riss? There a weekend break no need to rush a lynch.
But if you're not wanting to talk.
Vote Omtose
For acting squirmy on first day, with only a couple of posts agaiinst him.
Worst vote I've read so far. You don't want to rush a lynch but you are happily helping it along because some other guy hasn't responded to you.
Eloth, on 26 October 2009 - 12:09 PM, said:
*SNIP*
I assume that means that we have to eliminate the killers from evil vampires and coven but can leave the non-killing roles ('symps') or whatever else they have, alive, where the Cullens needed those dead, too. We need to get rid of all Cullens and Qs (I assume that means including recruits) whereas for the Cullens it was only the original wolves.
Had Galain been a Queleti or Coven, I wouldn't have used this kind of reasoning, nor if he was an evil vamp while Bella was alive, due to the chance he was gunning for a townie.
An additional (unlikely but still possible) support for Galain's choice: from wiki, I conclude that Carlisle was a doctor. If that translates to game mechanics, it could be Galain was a doctor, which is like a passive find. What if Omtose was wounded, went to see a doc, and ended up on Galain's surgery table?
Suppose we lynched Omtose, and suppose he'd come up as anything but town, that would be doubly advantageous for Galain: someone lynched who may be on his list, and since we lynch scum, we'd trust his instincts without wondering overly much where he got his info from, at least for a day or 2.
Mind you, all of the above is circumstantial. All of the above is farfetched and based on ifs and assumptions. I'm willing to take the gamble. We know one thing, and that is that Omtose overreacted to two votes. You can do a few things to having a few votes on you; defend comprehensively or laugh them off. He did neither, but reacted as if stung.
Wow, thanks for again resummarizing what I already wrote about possible town goals and Carlisle's possible role. Next time, maybe you should add a copyright symbol because I think this is the second time you've tried to rip off what I already wrote.
However, your logic is badly flawed. How on earth would Omtose be wounded on Day 1? And why are you confusing Galain (Edward) with Barghast (Carlisle)? I am HEAVILY tempted to vote you for the absolute BS of this logic. It reads to me like someone concocting a story and mixing up their facts.
And I could easily conclude you are trying to fake symp me with the plagarism.