[Karosis]

remove vote


cant go to bed until this is resolved.

[Thyrllan]

Tulas Shorn, on 14 October 2009 - 10:11 PM, said:

Atrahal, on 14 October 2009 - 09:20 PM, said:

Telas, on 14 October 2009 - 09:07 PM, said:

Ok so I reread the last few pages since night and I was trying to come up with info. Over the last day, these are what people are claiming in terms of role/PI/suspects. I figured it would help me try to sort stuff out and I'm posting it because I hope it helps the rest of us do the same. I believe seeing from Thyr may give us some good info, like maybe a reason why he trusts Atrahal


Alkend: RI. trusts Tulas, Karosis, Tennes. Suspects are me (telas).

Tennes: Scotty. Trusts Karosis. Suspects are me, Kaschan, Atrahal, watching Thyr

Atrahal: RI lovers. Trusts ?, suspects Tennes

Karosis: RI chef. Trusts ?, suspects Thyr, Alkend, Tulas

Tulas: guard. Trusts Alkend, Karosis, Tennes. Suspects me, Thyr, Kaschan,

Kaschan: ? ? ?

Thyr: ?. Trusts Atrahal. Suspects Tennes

Telas: RI. Trusts Karosis. Suspects either Tennes/Atrahal, Tulas(?)

I don't trust anyone who I am not bonded with. Suspects are all of you. Every thing that everyone has said or revealed seems to have holes in it, and when they don't the fact that they played in the other game which would allow them to have other knowledge causes me to suspect their reveals.

I know that kalse was Kirk. So I don't trust Tennes. Tulas has given out information that doesn't make any sense which is also why I don't trust Alkend as Tulas seems to be defending him. Kaschan and Telas and Thyrllan are all being to quiet.

Actually I guess I kind of trust Karosis. Course he is probably just luring me in.

Now he KNOWS Kalse was Kirk? And so we just disbelieve Tennes now? Whose reveal has more holes here, pray tell?

I DONT KNOW why it would affect me immediately. Because it was designed to maybe? Use your heads, this is a game designed to have checks and balances. Why is there a chef when there are replicators? That doesn't make sense either!

I changed to Alkend on night 3 because he was the scummiest at the time.

That makes absolutely no sense! guarding a player night 1 resulting in no kill, failing to guard him night 2 and there's a kill, and then you turn around to guard someone utterly different night 3? Not to mention it would seem Tennes did not actually fix the replicator.

And out of curiosity, what would've happened if you'd guarded the saboteur night 2? Is he immune to the guard ability then?

Bullshit, you're just clutching at straws to keep Telas from voting for you

[Thyrllan]

I'm a bit iffy on the what I'm allowed to reveal thing. I do however know off the communication system, which was disabled on night 3. I was hoping someone would go and claim to have been in communication with someone else after that, but no luck

[Karosis]

so you are either chekov or uhuru then?

[Telas]

ok, and Atrahal's reveal came what? during night 3 meaning that claims of communication could be legit.

Is that why you trusted his reveal at the time?

[Karosis]

one of the reason i have removed is because i dont trust atrahal and i have had suspicions about you given your extended absences.

[Telas]

another question as well, now that I think of it.

To be w/ comms I'd guess same as Karosis, so do you know anyone above/below you?

[Tulas Shorn]

Do you see other guards revealing? Where are the counter claims? That's a ballsy reveal, much more so than, oh wait, you haven't bothered to reveal, have you.

I also reasoned at the time that perhaps I COULDN"T guard Atrahal more than 1 night in a row. I thought he might have been a high ranking person, or some other reason, so I decided it might be a waste of time to continue to guard him. Especially if I'd have to try to guard him 4 nights in a row to get a decent result. So I decided to take the meager info I had and try someone else (who seemed much scummier on Day 3 than Atrahal)

Edit: at Thyr's post

This post has been edited by Tulas Shorn: 14 October 2009 - 10:22 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Day 5, 9 minutes left

8 people are still alive :Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Tennes, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn
5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night


1 vote Telas (Tennes)
3 votes Tulas shorn (Thyrlann, Atrahal, Kaschan )
1 vote Thyrlann (Tulas Shorn)

3 people have not voted: Alkend, Karosis, Telas

[Karosis]

screw it, if thyr is telling the truth then tulas and alkend could be scum but who then is the third?

[Karosis]

Tulas Shorn, on 14 October 2009 - 10:20 PM, said:

Do you see other guards revealing? Where are the counter claims? That's a ballsy reveal, much more so than, oh wait, you haven't bothered to reveal, have you.

I also reasoned at the time that perhaps I COULDN"T guard Atrahal more than 1 night in a row. I thought he might have been a high ranking person, or some other reason, so I decided it might be a waste of time to continue to guard him. Especially if I'd have to try to guard him 4 nights in a row to get a decent result. So I decided to take the meager info I had and try someone else (who seemed much scummier on Day 3 than Atrahal)

Edit: at Thyr's post

vote tulas

you already said that you couldnt guard because you were too hungry, now your claiming you reasoned you couldnt guard the smae player twice?

[Thyrllan]

Karosis, on 14 October 2009 - 10:19 PM, said:

one of the reason i have removed is because i dont trust atrahal and i have had suspicions about you given your extended absences.

I never lie about being away and you know that. I've been away because other things have been prioritized. Time with my girlfriend, studying, nights out with the sorority. Those are the reasons I haven't been around, and when I have been here I've damned well pulled my part.

[Alkend]

I AM BACK FROM A MEETING AND KNOW THERE IS LITTLE TIME LEFT.

GIVE ME A QUICK SUMMARY ON WHY WE ARE VOTING TULAS PLEASE.

[Thyrllan]

Tulas Shorn, on 14 October 2009 - 10:20 PM, said:

Do you see other guards revealing? Where are the counter claims? That's a ballsy reveal, much more so than, oh wait, you haven't bothered to reveal, have you.

I also reasoned at the time that perhaps I COULDN"T guard Atrahal more than 1 night in a row. I thought he might have been a high ranking person, or some other reason, so I decided it might be a waste of time to continue to guard him. Especially if I'd have to try to guard him 4 nights in a row to get a decent result. So I decided to take the meager info I had and try someone else (who seemed much scummier on Day 3 than Atrahal)

Edit: at Thyr's post

So you didn't know the replicators cause it now?

[Thyrllan]

Alkend, on 14 October 2009 - 10:24 PM, said:

I AM BACK FROM A MEETING AND KNOW THERE IS LITTLE TIME LEFT.

GIVE ME A QUICK SUMMARY ON WHY WE ARE VOTING TULAS PLEASE.

because he's making very little sense and there are holes enough in his reveal to drive a caravn of trucks through it

[Tulas Shorn]

@Thyr

Ok, so you revealed.

That makes Atrahal my scum choice (assuming you're telling the truth). It wouldn't surprise me, I've been wrong about scum all game (I thought Korv was scum for sure).

Remove Vote

Vote Atrahal

Why are you so quick to believe Atrahal's reveal, anyways?

[Telas]

basically that, though there is enough all around that I dislike

[Path-Shaper]

Day 5, 5 minutes left

8 people are still alive :Alkend, Atrahal, Karosis, Kaschan, Telas, Tennes, Thyrlann, Tulas Shorn
5 votes to lynch or 4 to go to night


1 vote Telas (Tennes)
4 votes Tulas shorn (Thyrlann, Atrahal, Kaschan Karosis )
1 vote Thyrlann (Tulas Shorn)

2 people have not voted: Alkend, , Telas

[Alkend]

ugh i have 3 mins to decide..... UGH.

[Tulas Shorn]

Karosis, on 14 October 2009 - 10:23 PM, said:

Tulas Shorn, on 14 October 2009 - 10:20 PM, said:

Do you see other guards revealing? Where are the counter claims? That's a ballsy reveal, much more so than, oh wait, you haven't bothered to reveal, have you.

I also reasoned at the time that perhaps I COULDN"T guard Atrahal more than 1 night in a row. I thought he might have been a high ranking person, or some other reason, so I decided it might be a waste of time to continue to guard him. Especially if I'd have to try to guard him 4 nights in a row to get a decent result. So I decided to take the meager info I had and try someone else (who seemed much scummier on Day 3 than Atrahal)

Edit: at Thyr's post

vote tulas

you already said that you couldnt guard because you were too hungry, now your claiming you reasoned you couldnt guard the smae player twice?

You're an idiot. MY GUARD FAILED BECAUSE I WAS HUNGRY (Passed out, actually). I decided to guard someone else the next day because I was thinking, maybe it happened because I'm not allowed to guard that person more than once. Passage of time too hard for you to figure out, Karosis?