[Mentalist]

hey, itried my best to help you guys out. Me and dkt practically got Edward lynched ourselves, and I was tryign to make him a Day 1 lynch, too.

[Vengeance]

The Dude, on 30 October 2009 - 07:52 PM, said:

well, good job to the Winner... I know it's tough to mod, but really... A townie who completley knows another faction... thats just Bogus. And you can't say, "If the wolves had Bella they woulda won" the chances of us getting Bella were not that great and if another faction woulda got her, their chance at winning would have been even easier. I think with some tweaking this could be made into a great game. But color me bitter, feel like I just spent a week playing a game that I lost before I started.

That being said, playing was great fun when I thought I had a chance. Thanks MEanas for giving me one more night of Life I love how I got venge pissed off about the reveal and the killing. It's really hard to be rational when you are lying your ass off

Until the next one. Dude out.

But people were buying it and it was SOOOOO obvious.... Morons...

[Illuyankas]

I wish someone had noticed there were 19 signups and 20 alts during the thread. Hell, I even used American spellings for most of my posts.

Perfect timing though, Halloween parties would have killed my time to play. Oh, and I haven't played Mafia in over a year and I could still tell that Olar Ethil was Morgoth after that rant near the start.

[General King]

I think it was becuase the other factions went after each other.

Ok no proper killing role for the WW a bit messed up, but other games have the same problems.

[Bent]

So Beru didnt post in spoilers at all? Did anyone send out the pm? Or think to say, tough luck, but noob mistakes happen? Poor Beru...

[Mentalist]

I posted a lot of condolences IN SPOILERS...

but tbh, i haven't seen him around the forums for a while.

I must say, i've told you all not to lynch him, but NOOO...

[General King]

I was the first to die in my game on Modcraft but that was second day.

[General King]

My view is ok he may have been a new player but it is amiss not to lynch a player if he screws up badly.

[Mentalist]

yes, but once again, if we were thinking he's a symp, WHY NOT LYNCH WHOMEVER HE WAS SYMPING FIRST?

no one that's voted for Beru ever explained that point to me

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 30 October 2009 - 08:58 PM

[General King]

It was just as good as lynching Beru lol

[General King]

lol it not a gmae of mafia if the new player isn't killed on his first day.

it no fault of your own Beru it juyst indoctrination into the fold.

[Mentalist]

initiation's the word, I believe.

[General King]

yeah you may be right.

[Impirion]

Mentalist, on 30 October 2009 - 08:57 PM, said:

yes, but once again, if we were thinking he's a symp, WHY NOT LYNCH WHOMEVER HE WAS SYMPING FIRST?

no one that's voted for Beru ever explained that point to me

Cos we weren't sure he wasn't fake symping and being an ultra sneaky noob.

[Mentalist]

I still say we should've lynched edward first...

btw, Imp, how's that Supernatural mafia game coming along?

[Morgoth]

All right, I've read through the spoilers...

Tiss was a very thought through and organized game, d'rek. I had a lot of fun playing even though the only part of my role I ever got to use was knowing Ruse to be the doctor. I must say though, that the werewolves could only have won by some sort of miracle. They had the weakest line up by far - shit they were weaker than the town faction - a spy who listened in on their night communications and the most difficult victory conditions. It's absurd, and I do sympathize with DiBs here.

However, all the rest was brilliant though, and I did have fun even though I detest support roles. I have to rein myself in all the time instead of just hammering at the keyboard until Sarah pulls me away to ease my blood pressure. The possibility of recruitment completly threw me though.

Where did all my pms go? Alt guesses, tagging Korvalain as the finder when Serc's CF came up, HP as a likely scum, Telas as scum from one of his firsts posts day 1! .. I feel unappreciated..

@Illy - Brilliant to have you back. One must wonder why Talf decided to suicide instead of just lynching you, but it must've been beautiful to behold for you. God, I would've giggled way into the dawn if that happened to me.

@Tapper - what the hell?

[General King]

Well I was correct that I suspected it was a smart and devious bastard behind Olar.

[Mentalist]

Morgoth, on 30 October 2009 - 09:57 PM, said:

All right, I've read through the spoilers...

Tiss was a very thought through and organized game, d'rek. I had a lot of fun playing even though the only part of my role I ever got to use was knowing Ruse to be the doctor. I must say though, that the werewolves could only have won by some sort of miracle. They had the weakest line up by far - shit they were weaker than the town faction - a spy who listened in on their night communications and the most difficult victory conditions. It's absurd, and I do sympathize with DiBs here.

However, all the rest was brilliant though, and I did have fun even though I detest support roles. I have to rein myself in all the time instead of just hammering at the keyboard until Sarah pulls me away to ease my blood pressure. The possibility of recruitment completly threw me though.

Where did all my pms go? Alt guesses, tagging Korvalain as the finder when Serc's CF came up, HP as a likely scum, Telas as scum from one of his firsts posts day 1! .. I feel unappreciated..

@Illy - Brilliant to have you back. One must wonder why Talf decided to suicide instead of just lynching you, but it must've been beautiful to behold for you. God, I would've giggled way into the dawn if that happened to me.

@Tapper - what the hell?

Once I died and started modding, I posted all new PMs I saw.

any earlier ones might be missing, but I'm not responsible

[Gavin]

Read spoilers, good game all - I enjoyed myself at least.

Sorry to the Werewolves for outing them like that - I did ask about my role Night 1 as it didn't seem right.

@D'rek, don't be put off by modding and creating new games most people had a lot of fun! I agree with what the Dibster said, but really you were only out by one role for a good balance. If you had taken my role and replaced it with that 1 Vig Werewolf you left out I reckon it would have been a whole lot closer to balanced. 3 Werewolves with 3 Vigs + the Guard, and 1 symp seems a whole lot fairer.

[Giles]

im not bitter that i got lynched because 2 people mentioned my name at all...
il have to say the werewolves were probably slightly underpowere but the main thing about this game has to be the absolutely ridiculous reveals, i still dont understand why most of them were made