[Mentalist]

Sir Thursday, on 31 October 2009 - 08:50 PM, said:

Well, I enjoyed that game, but because my role was fairly basic, a lot of the subtleties passed me by. I can see that this could have been far more messed up than it was if Bella had stayed in play for a bit longer. I was kind of thinking the right way before all the reveals came out (at one point I almost said "Screw it, Vig D'riss"...damn my self-doubt!), just didn't have the time to investigate my shortlist properly. Sorry for lowposting a bit, but my computer takes ten seconds to register what I've typed and crashes every 30 minutes or so, which limits my enthusiasm for posting.



Sir Thursday

my laptop does the typing ting, too, most of the time.

annoying as hell.

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 31 October 2009 - 11:26 PM

[Giles]

im happy everyone is wondering about Belaa staying in the game more though i am annoyed that i got lynched because two random people mentioned my name :@

[drinksinbars]

Impirion, on 31 October 2009 - 09:15 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on 31 October 2009 - 11:53 AM, said:

Impirion, on 30 October 2009 - 06:10 PM, said:

I think this game has been awesome D'rek, if it's any consolation, even if our faction was screwed from the outset. The number of times I just burst out laughing at what was happening....

@Dibs. If you read through, you will see we have covered the one way we could have won, which was to recruit Bella
Oh and what was your reason for NKing me?

forgot to answer this. my original plan was to nk morgochop, but then everyone was on him during the night and it looked like a possible morgo lynch which was more satisfying, i thenk skipped through the various players to decide who to kill and ended on you. you were very middle of the roadand i thought possibly scum. just didnt consider you may have been our scum as i was under the distinct impression that moc was jacob and amp was billy. to say i was confused by your cf is an understatement.

Ah okies, lol my CF did generate quite a lot of discussion. When I read the spoilers, I was expecting you and The Dude to go, WTF who the hell is ampelas then?

well blame the scene writer as it was at this time the clearwater stuff began so i assumed amp must have been a werewolf. thats why i told mockra to rerecruit amp incase they had been turned...

[Impirion]

drinksinbars, on 01 November 2009 - 12:19 PM, said:

Impirion, on 31 October 2009 - 09:15 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on 31 October 2009 - 11:53 AM, said:

Impirion, on 30 October 2009 - 06:10 PM, said:

I think this game has been awesome D'rek, if it's any consolation, even if our faction was screwed from the outset. The number of times I just burst out laughing at what was happening....

@Dibs. If you read through, you will see we have covered the one way we could have won, which was to recruit Bella
Oh and what was your reason for NKing me?

forgot to answer this. my original plan was to nk morgochop, but then everyone was on him during the night and it looked like a possible morgo lynch which was more satisfying, i thenk skipped through the various players to decide who to kill and ended on you. you were very middle of the roadand i thought possibly scum. just didnt consider you may have been our scum as i was under the distinct impression that moc was jacob and amp was billy. to say i was confused by your cf is an understatement.

Ah okies, lol my CF did generate quite a lot of discussion. When I read the spoilers, I was expecting you and The Dude to go, WTF who the hell is ampelas then?

well blame the scene writer as it was at this time the clearwater stuff began so i assumed amp must have been a werewolf. thats why i told mockra to rerecruit amp incase they had been turned...

Was a good call, would have worked if we actually had a recruiter

[Peanutbutta]

Path-Shaper, on 23 October 2009 - 04:12 PM, said:

Well, PB has now completely obliterated his team by not even trying to defend either of his teammates. On the upside, maybe he'll just go crazy and do 2 day vigs. That'd be awesome.

Well, not really sure how else I could have played this one. I didn't want to defend and look sympish, although Olar Ethil managed to do that and get away with it, but he had a reveal that supported him just enough to get by.

Tough break, but not really sure I could have done any better.

[Peanutbutta]

Mentalist, on 29 October 2009 - 08:51 PM, said:

the Dude, lamenting:

Mockra, on 29 October 2009 - 07:58 PM, said:

Why couldn't I let the Emur thing go... coulda just let it slide... WTF dumbass bad play by me. Hopefully, if Amp hasn't been turned he will jump on my side. then need 2 for Kess, 3 for me. I have a good fake reveal planned. as Jason Jenks. Just hope D'rek didn't throw then in the game as a throw away player. but if it looks like it's gonna be me, well, I might have to roll the Dice. Damn you ment.. why did you have to die so early! The one time I want you to live.. out in 2 days .. grrrrrrr

I blame you not taking the bullet for me,

-ment

all in all, ironic, given that I WANTED to be recruited by the wolves

Funny thing, and I never posted it to SH because I was paranoid about eavesdroppers, but I was planning on fake revealing as Jenks myself because I knew Emur was the mayor after the fake kill. I was going to say that I knew Bella and could protect her, and I knew the Mayor because I spent a lot of time at City Hall. Then I saw you do it and I was so glad I hadn't, lol.

[Peanutbutta]

Morgoth:

Olar Ethil, on 30 October 2009 - 12:27 AM, said:

Still not a single person visiting the doctor? This must be the most frustrating role I've ever had.

So, Kaschan, Kessobahn, Meanas and Eloth? That sounds... excessive.

Mockra's guard claim is interesting. Serc might still be in the werewolf faction. I don't see why Billy Black wouldn't be..

That leaves Silanah, Hood's Path, Ampelas, Telas and Korvalain. I don't like how Ampelas slunk off upon receiving pressure. Telas.. there's something wrong, I just can't put my finger on it. Gawd, if he's scum he's playing so awesome he deserves to win. I hope he's just a power inno. Korvalain also plays like a disinterested inno. If he's scum he's a c*nt. If he's inno he's still a dickwad, if not quite as bad as if he'd be scum.

Why thanks, Morgy. I actually thought I was doing pretty well for my crippled position. I do have a bit of a bad taste in my mouth knowing that it was all pointless because Bent knew me from the first night.

[Peanutbutta]

baudin, on 30 October 2009 - 03:01 PM, said:

Lol at Telas' reveal in Im a vampire but im not a cullen Also is there a reason all the vampries are deciding to reveal as vampires

lol I had that one in my back pocket as an emergency reveal, knowing full well it had almost no chance of success. I really should have saved the vig I used on Emur because I think the best chances I had to win for my faction were to just wait until the reveal fests and then hope I could lynch someone and then vig the last two people to win. Long shot but about all I had.

[Peanutbutta]

And done.

Werewolves definitely were boned. Even with Bella I'm not sure they could have won.

I think it's fun you included two solo players but a bit silly for you to guarantee the super strong one to one guy and then stick DKT with the other one, who was really fragile. I also think that the independent and 'hidden' factions should not take first place, they can tie for first with the town, simply because I don't believe it's good practice to have hidden characters with hidden VCs that supersede known VCs. Plus Kesso was virtually unkillable.

Cullens and Evil vamps were fine, we both just had personnel implosions.

I don't think it was a good idea to let Bella know each 'boy' because it just played into her hands to try and get to the faction she wanted. She should have been an object of affection, not a willing participant in any given game.

I think you probably overdid it with the BP mechanic, too. Spycraft taught me how powerful a single BP can be.

Overall, not too surprised town won. They probably were a bit on the powerful side but not invincible for most of the teams, although again, WWs were never really in it with the hidden spy.

Setup was very good in most respects and I'm glad I played, even if I never really had a chance after the early symp problems. Please tell beru to get back here and play some more!

[dktorode]

luckily...im just not in the mood to bitch and moan...

[Morgoth]

dktorode, on 02 November 2009 - 08:41 AM, said:

luckily...im just not in the mood to bitch and moan...

It cannot be!