[Eloth]

Cheers PB(?), I was starting to feel like that Charlton Heston in that film where he's the last man left alive on earth!

[Galain]

I said that Korv was the most likely to be vigged because that's what I thought. He'd gotten a couple of people's backs up and garnered a couple of votes yesterday. Nothing about the other two struck me as scummy, so I didnt see why a vig would have gone for either. Unless something screwy is happening with the mechanics, one of the three kills had to be a vig. It would be poor form for a vig to take a shot in the dark, much more likely they would target one of the two main suspects of the day to save on a lynch.

I also don't see how two people who voted for me dying makes me look scummy, for the reasons people have stated.

As for me voting Korv - Rashan put forward a decent case, unlike the people that had voted for him before that. There weren't any other options that late in the day, so I added my vote to the train.

[Eloth]

I'm not alone after all!

I agree one of the kills is almost certainly a vig. I was merely asking how you could be so certain, as I couldn't (and still can't) see anything in the thread that could be construed as evidence. This makes me think "he knows something I don't know" and seems scummy.

I can also understand why you voted Korv - there was a big train on you and you wanted to avoid lynching. However in the very same post in which you voted you said you didn't think Korv was scum, but voted for him anyway. Again this seems scummy.

As for two of your train dying - on it's own, not particular peculiar, but added to the rest of the information I have it reinforces my suspicions about you, i.e you are scummy!

[Eloth]

To correct para 2 above, it should read "how you could be so certain Korv was vigged".

I feel this is too big a change to edit the post.

[Galain]

I just explained why I think Korv was vigged. I'm not certain, but looking at the three kills, Korv is the only one that wouldn't be a stupid target for a vig.

And I didnt say that I didnt think Korv was inno, just that meta reasoning was affecting my judgement of him, causing me to let more of the things he said slide than I would from a different player. Like I also said in that post, it can be a bad thing. I'm not 100% sure he's scum but will put down a vote is very different from I think he's inno but will lynch him anyway.

[Eloth]

Meh, just you and me here at the moment anyway, so do you have anyone else in your crosshairs now that Korv is dead?

[Rashan]

on briefly, going to sit down and watch a film. as far as knowing who was vigged and who wasnt, the vig could come forward, it wouldnt CI them, but might narrow down our possibilities for today. I am tempted to vote galain to gain info from yesterdays train but dont have enough time to make that case on emurlahn so it will have to wait until tomorrow morning.

[Serc]

 Rashan, on Aug 29 2009, 04:11 PM, said:

on briefly, going to sit down and watch a film. as far as knowing who was vigged and who wasnt, the vig could come forward, it wouldnt CI them, but might narrow down our possibilities for today. I am tempted to vote galain to gain info from yesterdays train but dont have enough time to make that case on emurlahn so it will have to wait until tomorrow morning.

Wait what? Where does Emurlahn factor into this?


Am I really oblivious, or do we have a slip here?

edit: Underlined the two parts I'm talking about.

This post has been edited by Serc: 29 August 2009 - 09:07 PM

[Eloth]

I believe he mentioned earlier that he was going to have a look at Emur. Let's hope its a short film.

[Galain]

Well I definitely wouldn't say I have crosshairs. I do admit though I'm still suspicious of you, mainly because I feel you misinterpreted a lot of what I said earlier on in this thread and seem to be driving the easy lynch. Other than that I'm not really sure. I'm going to bed now, and there's still lots of time today, I will see what I can come up with tomorrow morning.

[Eloth]

 Galain, on Aug 29 2009, 10:35 PM, said:

Well I definitely wouldn't say I have crosshairs. I do admit though I'm still suspicious of you, mainly because I feel you misinterpreted a lot of what I said earlier on in this thread and seem to be driving the easy lynch. Other than that I'm not really sure. I'm going to bed now, and there's still lots of time today, I will see what I can come up with tomorrow morning.

This is exactly my problem with you.

All the way through the game you have promised content. You have promised deduction, interpretation, theorisation. You have delivered...nothing. And now you're off to bed promising you "will see what you can come up with tomorrow".

I will admit than when I first made a case on you it was due to nothing more than a slight whiff of wrongness, but with every post you make that smell has become a malodorous, reeking, putrid miasma of scumminess.

My vote stands.

[Emurlahn]

Morning all. Nice to see some discussion while I was gone.

Sadly, I see we are yet to have Rashan's case against me presented, which is disappointing, tbh.

As for vigs coming forward, well...that only works if they are out of vigs, and if they are in fact vigs, and are not killers pretending to be vigs.

One thing with the assumption on Korv being vigged - he DID get a lot of people's backs up (my own included, I might add), but the problem with this, you see, is that we have two scum factions. Logically, he could as easily have annoyed one of them as a vig thinking he was bad for us. Anomander and Kessobahn's posts could be worth a re-read, to see if we can divine any scummy hints that a vig may have latched on to.

I am also getting frustrated with Ruse right about now. 10 posts in how long? O.o

[Eloth]

Just noticed this - take a look at the following, salient parts are underlined:

 Rashan, on Aug 29 2009, 09:11 PM, said:

on briefly, going to sit down and watch a film. as far as knowing who was vigged and who wasnt, the vig could come forward, it wouldnt CI them, but might narrow down our possibilities for today. I am tempted to vote galain to gain info from yesterdays train but dont have enough time to make that case on emurlahn so it will have to wait until tomorrow morning.

Rashan mentions he's tempted to vote Galain. Perhaps Rashan now sees Galain as a liability and is distancing himself. (By the way, it must be a long film as he's still not back - is it the Godfather box set Rashan?)

Galain responds:

 Galain, on Aug 29 2009, 10:35 PM, said:

Well I definitely wouldn't say I have crosshairs. I do admit though I'm still suspicious of you, mainly because I feel you misinterpreted a lot of what I said earlier on in this thread and seem to be driving the easy lynch. Other than that I'm not really sure. I'm going to bed now, and there's still lots of time today, I will see what I can come up with tomorrow morning.

Again, quick post and he's disappeared, but the underlined segment is the spooky bit. Does Galain think Rashan still hasn't picked up his symp clues so in his very next post he tries to re-inforce it?

[D'riss]

hi, everyone.

I'm back after working parking all day.

need to shower, eat, etc, then i'll catch up on the thread.

[Galayn Lord]

Ok a little bit of information for you guys before I go out to dinner. The reason that there was no kill on the first night is that I was targetted. I know this because I had a Bp and it was used up. I wanted this to happen as I got a vig if my Bp was targeted. I like having a vig. I was also looking for someone to attack me. My thinking was that the killer would try to have me lynched since they weren't able to Nk me the night before. Since Andomandaris was the only one to come after me and did so with a hard on. I vig him last night. I retrospect I should have killed either Rashan, Galain, Kesso or Eloth. Who at various times I had provisionals on. I figured that in a WCS there would be 3 kills last night. Which is why I didn't vote for a lynch. I strongly suspect that Kesso is the SK/Killer and that either Galain or Rashan is a SK/Killer. Eloth I am not sure about.

As Galain has a lot of votes and I have no idea if the clock is running now I am going to put my vote down on

VOTE KESSO

[Eloth]

You sure about that vote? It makes about as much sense as the rest of your post

[D'riss]

errm, wat?

Kesso's dead, dude.

[D'riss]

hmm, well things took longer than usual

to recap: I'm going to have to look at the Galain case again tomorrow morning (hooray for a day off!)

for now, at least, GL's reveal seems legit, especially since it backs up my own wild idea that Ano wa the vig target (see above)

i'm exhausted and will probably head to bed soon. not expecting anything groundbreaking till I wake up, at least.

[Emurlahn]

GL's reveal seems legit, because the only way he'd reveal and then vote a dead person was if he is either drunk or extremely tired. Therefore, it's more likely he is telling the truth. XD

A most interesting development. However, now that we know Kesso is innocent, GL, how does that change your opinion on Rash/Galain/Eloth?

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 4. 12 hours and 12 minutes remaining

9 Players still alive: D'riss, Eloth, Emurlahn, Galain, Galayn Lord, Hood's Path, Rashan, Ruse, Serc

5 votes to lynch, 5 votes to go to night

1 vote for Galain: ( Eloth )

Players not voted: D'riss, Emurlahn, Galain, Galayn Lord, Hood's Path, Rashan, Ruse, Serc

I cannot count that vote on Kessobahn because he is, in fact, dead.

Highly unlikely I will be around when the day times out, I'll most likely be travelling. So consider this my last update for quite some time. Sorry if Morgy isn't around until I get back.