[Eloth]

ugh since all the scenes weren't posted on the P-S account I can't search them easily.....so annoying.

[Ampelas]

So you're no longer commenting on the GL leader business you started?

I don't think you're immature enough for it to be true, but I'm curious why you fingered him. Was it just because he was arguing with you, or do you have a deeper reason?

[Karatallid]

i just looked through to try and work it out in my head and by my reckoning the dead so far are
D'riss- GK
Emu-GB
Gam-Bars
HP-Spi
Kasch-Spi
Kor-GB
Lio-GK
Meanas-Bars
Mockra-GB
so we have 2 lost from both GK and Bars and 3 from GB. Im not sure what the starting numbers would be but i think were probably at a 3-3-3 now but if someone has a better idea of which factions started at higgher numbers feel free to correct me.

[Karatallid]

also i may be slightly wrong with some of the factions of the dead there so feel free to correct me if im wrong.

[Eloth]

No way. Spider's had to of had 5 people to start because to divide them they would have to be divided evenly, meaning one of the three remaining people to each team. Otherwise, people are going to scream holy hell when they get to SH if 2 teams got a spider and 1 team didnt. That leaves 13 players divided between the 3 other teams to start, likely 4, 4 and another 5. making them 5, 5, and 6 after the addition of the spider team. There is only a 33% chance GB had five player's to start which is the only scenario that puts it at 3, 3 and 3 right now. It's much more likely one team is at 4, 66% chance in fact.

[Karatallid]

i think your assumption there was definitely 5 is flawed as if there were 4 they would still have distributed them. Noone could really complain if it was done randomly so its a bit hard to work out than you make it seem.

[Ampelas]

Quote

The following named roles are present:

Anjais Barsavi
*Bug
*Calo Sanza
Capa Barsavi
Cheryn Berangias
*Galdo Sanza
*Jean Tannen
*Locke Lamora
Nazca Barsavi
Pachero Barsavi
Raiza Berangias
Roland
The Falconer
The Gray King
The Spider

(stars are mine)

There are 5 names there that are definitely GBs, right? So if you're claiming Spiders had 5, then it should be 3-3-3 now. The fact that you claim you don't think GBs started with 5 is mighty suspicious.

[Eloth]

Karatallid, on Jul 10 2009, 02:41 AM, said:

i think your assumption there was definitely 5 is flawed as if there were 4 they would still have distributed them. Noone could really complain if it was done randomly so its a bit hard to work out than you make it seem.

You honestly believe mods would give two teams a player and one team none? No way. 5, 5, 4 and 4 are the likely starting and it fits easily with what would be considered fair after the so called buttfucking of the spiders. It also shortens the game making it easier to achieve majority with more players and the mods were worried the game might extend longer than normal after no kills on the first night.

[Eloth]

Ampelas, on Jul 10 2009, 02:44 AM, said:

Quote

The following named roles are present:

Anjais Barsavi
*Bug
*Calo Sanza
Capa Barsavi
Cheryn Berangias
*Galdo Sanza
*Jean Tannen
*Locke Lamora
Nazca Barsavi
Pachero Barsavi
Raiza Berangias
Roland
The Falconer
The Gray King
The Spider

(stars are mine)

There are 5 names there that are definitely GBs, right? So if you're claiming Spiders had 5, then it should be 3-3-3 now. The fact that you claim you don't think GBs started with 5 is mighty suspicious.

Don't strawman I said quite clearly 33% chance we did, keep in mind we are down one additional player so there is no way we can have 4. I also said quite clearly there is a 66% chance one of the other teams (still in the game) did.

[Karatallid]

but if 5 of those names are definitely GB how is it a 33% chance?

[Path-Shaper]

fear not, children, i'm back from my swim/workout

gotta shower/grab something to eat, i'll post morning in about half an hour

-ment

[Eloth]

Karatallid, on Jul 10 2009, 02:55 AM, said:

but if 5 of those names are definitely GB how is it a 33% chance?

Has Path-shaper EVER given all the knowledge exactly as it is in the game right up front? It's also missing 3 people, omg well they must not have existed in the game! I'm sure there are extra names on there to stop people from guessing the set-up up front. It's a huge disadvantage if you know for sure the GB's have five from Day 1, so don't count on it to be correct. Evidence shows people hungry for the win and that's what I draw my conclusions of the balance on, not names on a list.

[Galain]

Eloth, on Jul 9 2009, 08:50 PM, said:

Ampelas, on Jul 10 2009, 02:44 AM, said:

Quote

The following named roles are present:

Anjais Barsavi
*Bug
*Calo Sanza
Capa Barsavi
Cheryn Berangias
*Galdo Sanza
*Jean Tannen
*Locke Lamora
Nazca Barsavi
Pachero Barsavi
Raiza Berangias
Roland
The Falconer
The Gray King
The Spider

(stars are mine)

There are 5 names there that are definitely GBs, right? So if you're claiming Spiders had 5, then it should be 3-3-3 now. The fact that you claim you don't think GBs started with 5 is mighty suspicious.

Don't strawman I said quite clearly 33% chance we did, keep in mind we are down one additional player so there is no way we can have 4. I also said quite clearly there is a 66% chance one of the other teams (still in the game) did.

So you are officially revealing GB now? Or did you make it official earlier and I just forgot?

[Karatallid]

Well he claimed he and Emu were lovers with GL as their leader. So yes he did make it official

[Eloth]

Really Galain? I would thought it was quite obvious. Shall I go back to me old ways...two parts Luna Lovegood, pinch of Dooby and a flourish of Kreacher. Filthy muggles!

[Eloth]

Err is it Doby? Eh whichever.

[Path-Shaper]

the night has been long (well, longer , since 5 hours is still not that bad) but you eventually awaken to find that here has been no blood spilled this night.

the traditional daily aanouncement this time reads:

"Ah, Locke Lamora... the lies you tell have finally caught up with you."


no-one died

it is day 5, 32 hours left.

no-one has voted.


i'm off for some time. behave yourselves

PS: it has come to the mods' attention that there's been talks of modkills on thread again. I'd like to remind you all that this type of decision is EXCLUSIVELY up to the moderators, who are the only ones fit to judge whether or not a player's actions can be considered harmful to his own team or not.
the ONLY instance when the living players should talk about modkills is in the context of an inactivity modkill.
this is your first and last warning about such things.
-ment

[Galain]

Karatallid, on Jul 9 2009, 09:32 PM, said:

Well he claimed he and Emu were lovers with GL as their leader. So yes he did make it official

Ah yes, my memory is fail. Feh, its late.

Eloth, on Jul 9 2009, 09:50 PM, said:

Err is it Doby? Eh whichever.

Its Dobby, innit? Harry Potter fellow?

[Galain]

So, interesting night result. I'm not gonna be on any more tonight, think I'll leave a vote on

Eloth

We all know why

[Eloth]

Galain, on Jul 10 2009, 04:12 AM, said:

So, interesting night result. I'm not gonna be on any more tonight, think I'll leave a vote on

Eloth

We all know why

cause you are looking for an easy lynch on a team that CAN'T have 4 people, and could have 2 people.