[Kaschan]

Damnation, I though we'd agreed to stay in last night. I hope Thyr had a good reason. I wouldn't automatically assume Sil was inside, just because he wasn't mentioned in the scene doesn't mean he was hiding, but there's no way to tell. So, who had motivation to want Thyr and Sil dead? And does motivation automatically make mean scum?

[Galain]

Kaschan, on Jun 27 2009, 10:13 AM, said:

Damnation, I though we'd agreed to stay in last night. I hope Thyr had a good reason. I wouldn't automatically assume Sil was inside, just because he wasn't mentioned in the scene doesn't mean he was hiding, but there's no way to tell. So, who had motivation to want Thyr and Sil dead? And does motivation automatically make mean scum?

Yeah I know we shouldn't assume, I was just hypothesizing. I've seen a lot of these games, however, where they say there are no clues in the scenes, but then use that as an excuse to actually write a scene very close to what the night actions were.

I've contemplated asking everyone what their choice was, but since it SEEMS like at least one town was out in addition to Thyr (and maybe Sil), I'm not sure anybody would want to reveal that because it seems pretty clear that the killers know what they did and anybody revealing they went out is a likely candidate for a lynch or a night kill.

[Galain]

I have to run some errands so I'll be back later.

[Kaschan]

Galain, on Jun 27 2009, 01:08 PM, said:

Gamelon, on Jun 27 2009, 03:51 AM, said:

Well i hope the rest of you wake up and realise galain is scum.

Until counter-revealed otherwise, you got a town power role, but that does not make you, in any way, some kind of authority on scum detection. You have already lied about your night actions in some kind of attempt to save Hood's Path. You, IMO, wasted your time on night 2 by trying to heal someone other than D'riss (think, if D'riss had been saved by a healer, you would have had to spend the next night disinfecting him or whoever revealed on Day 3, making it still a net loss of one to the town). I realize you probably think you were being helpful by trying to find the DG, but your job is to keep the town from being overrun by the DG at night.

Finally, you have basically PId Eloth with your statement. You obviously tried to cleanse him for a reason. OK, he's not the DG. He could still be scum. You make a case on me for trying to find the DG first and hey, it's a decent case, but in the process of accusing me of putting the blinders on for scum, you have put the blinders on for the DG.

Now, the GOOD news is that with 2 infected deaths, and the current state of reveals, we can pretty much assume we still have the DG alive with 2 recruits. I assume you stayed in last night, Gamelon, and thus can't prove someone else is not the DG? We should also assume 3 or 4 scum are still alive at this point, making it basically 6 or 7 people of TWELVE still alive that are anti-town.

Now I'm out for a bit.

Well then, if your numbers are right, there's only 2-3 people I can vote for that aren't either scum or DG team. At the moment, however, any vote I could lay down just now is perfectly random. The only person currently alive whose play has so far seemed more or less detrimental to the team is Meanas, and that's because I don't remember anything at all of content from him. So, until I've finished reading over the other living people,

vote Meanas

[Path-Shaper]

Galain, on Jun 27 2009, 05:30 PM, said:

Kaschan, on Jun 27 2009, 10:13 AM, said:

Damnation, I though we'd agreed to stay in last night. I hope Thyr had a good reason. I wouldn't automatically assume Sil was inside, just because he wasn't mentioned in the scene doesn't mean he was hiding, but there's no way to tell. So, who had motivation to want Thyr and Sil dead? And does motivation automatically make mean scum?

Yeah I know we shouldn't assume, I was just hypothesizing. I've seen a lot of these games, however, where they say there are no clues in the scenes, but then use that as an excuse to actually write a scene very close to what the night actions were.

I've contemplated asking everyone what their choice was, but since it SEEMS like at least one town was out in addition to Thyr (and maybe Sil), I'm not sure anybody would want to reveal that because it seems pretty clear that the killers know what they did and anybody revealing they went out is a likely candidate for a lynch or a night kill.

Tiss depends very very much the mod running the game now don't it?

[Kaschan]

Okay, I actually feel very comfortable with my vote for Meanas. He should have been modkilled if not for weekend freeze, and has been posting just enough to subsist without getting sufficiently under our skin to warrant a lynch. This seems very scummy to me, and Korlat has been behaving the same way. I'm gonna leave my vote on Meanas.

[Eloth]

Two kills, neither of them infected. Cant think why either of them would have decided to go out, or what they have done to draw a vig/NK even if they did. Other than Thyr constantly getting confused as to the mechanics I cant think of much that he's said, same with Silanah. Hopefully Gam will be on sometime tomorrow morning to tell us if HP was infected. There's a chance the DG decided to infect someone he wouldn't be forced to SO and it will help to know what's going on.

Other than that I dont have tons of thoughts - it's still early in the day and the thread seems pretty dead.

[Kaschan]

You don't have any opinion at all on Meanas?

[Eloth]

Kaschan, on Jun 27 2009, 09:15 PM, said:

You don't have any opinion at all on Meanas?

To be honest I cant remember a single thing he has said, so you make a pretty valid point. I would have to do a reread before I can give more of an opinion than that. Unfortunately I need to pack now and head to bed shortly thereafter - I have to be up early tomorrow, followed by a long drive.

[Liosan]

We could have had zero f-ing kills if everyone had just stayed indoors, but oh well.

I agree Meanas and Korlat need to start giving us content. Their posts are pretty much nil on content so far. If they don't start posting by later today, I will consider voting for one of them.

[Kaschan]

Good night Eloth. Lio, I don't really expect to see either of them until Monday at the earliest. However, if my suspicion is correct and either of them is scum, I anticipate that they'll be monitoring the thread and will be on soon.

[Gamelon]

Wow galain. One little tongue and cheek comment by me and galain puts in a huge pseudo defense for no reason at all. If i weren't on a phone id be able to respond properly but i can't. I like the way you are trying to discredit me. I might not be an authority on scum detection. But if i recall correctly you aren't exactly finding scum by the droves yourself galain so wats your point? In fact you've done miserably compared to me. U even wanted hp.(Running out of characters space, will continue in next post)

[Gamelon]

Then you have the nerve to say me not disinfecting D'riss was a bad call? Last time i checked he fucking died that night so my decision was fucking spot on correct. And you are using my lying about the hp disinfect like its a bad thing that i tried to get you guys off of my partner? You got to be kidding me right? I KNOW he is not the DG so its actualy not a lie at all. But you trying to use this to discredit me is just ridiculous. And how on earth have i PI'd eloth. Were does this cum from? He just aint DG

[Emurlahn]

Thyrllan, on Jun 26 2009, 03:16 PM, said:

I think there is only one, but regardless ti seemed weird the way you just went striaght into 2 killers when such info was not even under consideration at this point. weird

the conspiracy theorist bit i mean dont get all paranoid debating the person's hidden agenda and whatnot too much, main focus has to be on what we know theyve done!

hmmm, i may of killed thyrllan. I kind of had him down as a symp after this post as he seems pretty sure of how many killers there should be and thinks there is only one. It ran contrary to everything else we haddiscussed and it wasnt the first time he said it. Now there was the possiblitiy put forward of multiple symps knowing various killers or replacing them and his insistenc eof only one had me dubious.

So i went after him last night on the understanding that if he was a symp he might be trying for someone else.

Just thought you would all like to know that. The reason i didnt make a case was that i wasnt sure and i thought given the nature of the festival it was a good way of finding out.

will be back on tomorrow to look over the galain case (from yesterday) and the meanas case.

[Gamelon]

I don't like the way galain is trying to make out like i don't know what i am doing. He also insinuates that i am not duncan. Even though the real duncan would surely have revealed if i faked. I don't see what the point of his slander is, or how it helps anyone but himself to do this. He admits the case i made on him was good. He must be pretty fucking confident.

[Gamelon]

Vote galain

[Meanas]

As I said before, I won't be on much this weekend, it looks better for me when the new week begins though. Ofcourse I would rather you didn't lynch me while I'm away, and before I've had a chance to contribute. That said I completely understand if you lynch me (read: for having a life).
My only vote target at this time is HP, which might not or might not be a good choice - I wouldn't know for sure until I have time to actually catch up. Reveals I am always skeptical about, but I have to get back to you on those aswell I'm afraid. I would definitely remind everyone that the default mafia opinion always should be skepticism. Just like the scientist. Peace out again.

[Gamelon]

Im pretty confidant too. Confidant that when a good case gets pushed aside for a easy lynch that its most likely the work of
Some decent symps or partners doing what they do best. Galain is one smooth mofo... Ill give him that much.

[Gamelon]

Well meanas i can confirm that hp is my sister. Surely either the real duncan or his sister would have counter revealed by now if we were lying.

[Gamelon]

Oh and i did not receive any pm that hp was infected. So he wasn't. I can only assume the DG opted for a bp.