edit: Formatting is just a mess, it should be semi-easy to read. I'm non-italics and non-quote stuff.
Korvalain said:
D'riss said:
Okay, here's my thought. I voted Korvalain last night for what I felt was BLATANT scumminess. The guy basically fake-gasped at the events and was completely active at the time of the lynch, and the night scene shortly thereafter. Yes, I realize a lurker or someone else could have been around to confirm NAs, etc, BUT after thinking it over, Korvalain's really looking suspect to me.
- Seemed surprised at the idea that there were two kills. GASP VIGS NO WAY?! It was an odd time for vigs to use a vig. Esp. if there's only one. get over it.
- Completely "forgot" Kessobahn was DEAD. Never did, that was someone else
- Completely "forgot" UB and BB can't communicate off-thread. Never played Benses game b4, figured would operate like a normal master/symp. Fixed that mistake.
- Acts helpful? Says, "Good morning, lets get to work." Its called friendliness, try it sometime.
I could care less about the vig issue. It was stupidly done, enough said.
You're right, it was someone else that forgot Kesso died. My mistake.
You are the first-but-not-the-last person to bring up a case based on mechanics. Specifically UB and BB's (incorrectly perceived) ability to communicate off-thread. You respond that it would operate like normal master/symp instead of the special Benses game (which I've never played before, either)? Um, news flash. Symps cannot communicate with their masters in normal games. So tell me how this is a simple mistake to make?
Korvalain, on May 14 2009, 08:02 AM, said:
SNIP
Right now Fener has more credibility with me because he's keeping his emotions in check.
^^ Posted at 802 AM
The time matters why? You taking issue at me for mentioning the fact that Fener had more credibility than a raving loony?
The time matters because less than an hour later you throw away Fener's credibility and instead bestow it upon your case, Gamelon.
Korvalain, on May 14 2009, 08:15 AM, said:
Okay, read through Gamelon, and most of the stuff was worthless.
SNIP.
But in his third post, something caught my eye. Its easy to pass off as a spelling mistake, but it seems awfully convenient given the subject matter of this game.
SNIP
For those who want to know, or don't know, the correct spelling is unwarranted. I doubt spelling will get anyone lynched ever, but I think this is worth a vote, in my mind.
vote Gamelon
^^Made a huge post about voting Gamelon for a possible intentional spelling slip. I was all over Korlat yesterday for a 'slip' but he was innocent, so I'm not entirely sure this is necessary. Since BB and UB can't even communicate off-thread, why signal and potentially give yourselves away? You have no way of coming up with a private code for each other. He quickly changes his mind when he realizes BB and UB can't talk to each other (gasp doesn't know rules?)
Yes, fine, I tried to contribute and fucked up. I fail to see why that's case worthy.
It's case-worthy because it's ANOTHER FUCKING RULE YOU MISSED. So either you just don't ever read the rules or you lie about them to make scum cases.
Korvalain, on May 14 2009, 08:59 AM, said:
Okay, see ya Gamelon.
SNIP
Fener has been quiet, but has been harping on Sil almost non-stop, until today when he mentions Sil as symping Ruse. As I said, Fener and Meanas have been symping each other, but if its UB and BB, then I think Fener is more likely BB.
vote Fener
^^Less than an hour later, is all buddy-buddy with Gamelon and suddenly doesn't like Fener anymore. Also, why on earth would Benses symp each other? BB knows his symp!
Not buddy-buddy, again some basic friendliness. Christians try to be friendly. Its not a bad gig, you should give it a shot. I don't know what Benses would do. I've never played a Benses before. Just cuz he knows the symp doesn't mean a symp has no point. He still has to attempt to deflect attention, which each was doing for the other.
Now you're back to being friends with Gamelon and think Fener is scum. You managed to completely 180 in less than an hour, all on account of missing a single rule? By MY guess, it's more about you just making another scum case when your first one falls apart.
Korvalain, on May 13 2009, 06:47 PM, said:
Hmm, in addition, D'riss, we already killed one inno because, as I gather, you "picked up on slips" and put them in big letters. Don't make me the same mistake with me.
^^Oh yeah, he threatened me too. Seriously, LOL? But of course.... vvv
Not a threat, unless you consider warning about big mistakes a threat. Killing me won't help, it's just another inno down.
Korvalain, on May 13 2009, 04:05 PM, said:
I haven't liked Korlat's play all game and agree with D'riss that his slip was pretty major.
^^ HE AGREED WITH THE SLIP.
Yes, I agreed, apparently so did 6 others. However, it was a MISTAKE! Lets not make the same mistake twice simply because I don't play very well, lets actually look at the scummy players.
Bull shit. You know that 6 other players didn't agree with my case. In fact, MAYBE one person agreed with it. Korlat got lynched for two reasons. One, the early-day case against him, which was a case you happily joined in upon. Two, people saw he was the closest to lynch and time was running out on the day.
He basically missed a good chunk of Day 1, dodging most of the spam fights, and has been friendly with both of the targets he has voted on today. He was on the lynch yesterday as an early vote, meaning he can deny being a 'train' vote. Something is very fishy about his play, so....
I missed day 1 cuz it started early and I was at my friend's house playing Halo all day. We wound up seeing Wolverine, which I thought was pretty good. I was rather dissappointed, it looked like it woulda been fun. I was on the Korlat train before it was a train because I didn't like his play. I stayed on the train because it was a legit (if possible) day 1 train. Why is this scummy?!
It's scummy because nobody can confirm what you are saying. It's a convenient excuse that can't be confirmed. Even if it's true, it is zero proof of your innocence. Even scum can play Halo.
Korvalain said:
So ya, that case was shit.
The only thing that is shit is your rebuttal. All I see is a pattern of suspicious posting times, feigned surprise at various outcomes, and you scared running back here to defend yourself.
This post has been edited by D'riss: 15 May 2009 - 03:16 AM
Help
