[Vengeance]

Dead thread is dead...

[Yellow]

Whooch, finally got some time to sit on my arse and play mafia

 Bubba, on Mar 26 2009, 11:21 AM, said:

I cant find anything

You guys are all playing equally clean.........(pissing me off)

hat off to who ever you are...

going to work





Shot in the dark....venge was setting off my radar last night.

Veng/Morgy

vote venge

Yeah, this definitely would have made me vote for the guy, has to be said. Maybe he was the symp, but meh, have to assume he wasn't. Bad, bad play from Bubba.

Can't say I'm too surprised about the Dk NK. I said this morning that I had a suspicion him and dibs were just innos comparing dick sizes, so it's not too surprising that the killer decided to take out a vocal player. The following did make me laugh out loud though

 dktorode, on Mar 26 2009, 03:02 PM, said:

Dead men don't talk...sorry dk, I bet that took some time to type, lol.

So far, I'm thinking Morgoth and JA have been playing this very sweet and steady. Neither have had to do much except defend themselves against fairly weak accusations. No cases from either of them, which is a little disconcerting.

 Mentalist, on Mar 26 2009, 03:08 PM, said:

go ahead with that...

I'll be really pissed if our scum are kurt and yellow.

Well, I've already stated what I felt about Kurt. I dunno if he started playing after getting called out, but he kind of threw me off his trail (which I was actually pretty fucking pissed about, cos that monster post took me about 20 minutes and I was late for work).

That other guy doesn't look suspicious at all

I should be around most of the night, boys. And I have beers.

[Yellow]

Gah, dead thread. I might watch Flight of the Conchords.

But I am still here if anyone wants to talk.

[Vengeance]

Well right now I feel that Gavin is so low that he is practically invisible but I am still highly suspicious of both Morgy and JA and Mental.

[Yellow]

What's the mental case, again? I had a lot to read over, can't remember what it comes from.

[Vengeance]

I haven't bothered to make one but hang on and I will piece a quick on together. Although basically it comes down to him doing suspicious shit.

[Mentalist]

I'm suspicious of Morgoth.

reasons stated above.

that, and i just got up from a nap.

[Yellow]

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 06:42 PM, said:

I haven't bothered to make one but hang on and I will piece a quick on together. Although basically it comes down to him doing suspicious shit.

Lol. Best case ever.

[Vengeance]

Ugg I went back and read half of Mentals posts...Blah blah blah my hard drive died. I am going to take a nap....Blah blah blah....Going to a lecture... Going to go take a nap....

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

[Kurt Montandon]

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 11:54 AM, said:

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

I'm up for a JA lynch, but that's sort of meta.

[Yellow]

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 06:54 PM, said:

Ugg I went back and read half of Mentals posts...Blah blah blah my hard drive died. I am going to take a nap....Blah blah blah....Going to a lecture... Going to go take a nap....

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

Woah, man. You say that you think Mental is scum, but you think we should lynch either JA or Morgoth? What, do you want the good players out of the way or something?

Plus, you voted like 3 seconds into the day, which seems like you're just eager to lynch off any old fucker. You need to make a better case than the one above.

[Yellow]

 Kurt Montandon, on Mar 26 2009, 07:01 PM, said:

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 11:54 AM, said:

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

I'm up for a JA lynch, but that's sort of meta.

Hmm, you think?

edited - Blargh, now I feel I need to qualify that. People might have cases against JA, but Kurt's statement struck me as a guy who has contributed little but wants rid of the good players. Which is what I was saying against Venge as well.

This post has been edited by Yellow: 26 March 2009 - 07:04 PM

[Vengeance]

 Yellow, on Mar 26 2009, 02:02 PM, said:

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 06:54 PM, said:

Ugg I went back and read half of Mentals posts...Blah blah blah my hard drive died. I am going to take a nap....Blah blah blah....Going to a lecture... Going to go take a nap....

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

Woah, man. You say that you think Mental is scum, but you think we should lynch either JA or Morgoth? What, do you want the good players out of the way or something?

Plus, you voted like 3 seconds into the day, which seems like you're just eager to lynch off any old fucker. You need to make a better case than the one above.

I voted for gavin as he has been under no pressure at all for the entire game. I do think that Mental is probably scum but upon review of half of his posts (I am to lazy to read them all) I can't find the ones that stood out for me when I did my reread yesterday. The fact that almost all of the players who have died has been suspicious of JA and Morgy and that most of the remaining players are also suspicious of JA and Morgy. Plus the fact that while they both have gotten a couple of votes nothing serious has been turned up on them. Morgy led the drive for bubba's lynch. JA has been sly and hasn't really laid anything down that can stick to him. As for the making of huge gigantic cases. It is my belief that 90% of the time they are made by scum. So if we go back and look at who has made the major cases so far in this game we have Morgy and you yellow. DKT did also but he was innocent.

[Vengeance]

 Yellow, on Mar 26 2009, 02:02 PM, said:

 Kurt Montandon, on Mar 26 2009, 07:01 PM, said:

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 11:54 AM, said:

Really that his 75% of his posts. So the main reason that I suspect him is gut. I feel that we need to lynch either JA or Morgy today. Unfortunately Gavin is sound asleep for another 6 hours and won't be on till after I go home. I do find him suspicious as he hasn't said shit about shit and his excuse for not saying shit after I put him at l-3 was crap.

I'm up for a JA lynch, but that's sort of meta.

Hmm, you think?

edited - Blargh, now I feel I need to qualify that. People might have cases against JA, but Kurt's statement struck me as a guy who has contributed little but wants rid of the good players. Which is what I was saying against Venge as well.

Are you saying that Morgy and JA and Mental are the only good players left in the game and if they are innocent then they are the innocents only shot at winning?

[Jump Around]

OK, I'm back.

I had to leave before dktorode's case, but here is my thought on it:


Basically he's not accusing me of anything besides associating me with Morgoth. All I can see is this: I never attacked Morgoth.

Well, the simple truth is, I didn't find anything to attack Morgoth with so far. And he's not pinging my radar, so I can't stir some bullshit to put some pressure just to see. Now, he might be a killer, and I might make an ass of myself just writing this, but that's what it is.

I have also made fewer cases or stir less shit than I normally do. For this, the honest reason is that I didn't expect to live that long. I actually expected to be the lol-NK on night 1, so I coasted day 1 to not get too involved. I guess I overestimated the head-hunting against me, which sounds pretty convincing in sign-up threads

Plus, I did try to poke some players that actually did say things I didn't like, like Mentalist and dktorode. Everyone should be attacked, I agree, but I don't have the responsibility to do it myself, we're a bunch in the team. After my bout with dktorode, I was satisfied that he wasn't a killer, so I let him go. When he said he was preparing something against Morgoth, I was intrigued, but sadly even Morgoth's part is completely to connect him to me, and I know i'm inno.


Now, for today, I will suggest that we discuss, but do not lynch. We have nothing to gain today by lynching IMO.

[Yellow]

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 07:10 PM, said:

So if we go back and look at who has made the major cases so far in this game we have Morgy and you yellow.

Yeah, and the conclusion of my "major case" was that I actually didn't have a case. Which was weak as fuck, but there you go. At least I didn't try to twist it into some bullshit thing to try and get the guy lynched, which some people might have done in that situation.

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 07:15 PM, said:

Are you saying that Morgy and JA and Mental are the only good players left in the game and if they are innocent then they are the innocents only shot at winning?

No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying that people latching onto The Weasel Excuse to just get rid of people they feel threatened by will cost us the game.

If you (or anyone) thinks JA or anyone else is guilty, then a case has to follow, otherwise it's just fear-mongering.

[Jump Around]

 Mentalist, on Mar 26 2009, 05:05 PM, said:

well, shit
what now?

haha, another post I hate.

Ment, Ment, what will I do with you?

[Jump Around]

 Mentalist, on Mar 26 2009, 05:08 PM, said:

go ahead with that...

I'll be really pissed if our scum are kurt and yellow.

Why?

[Vengeance]

 Yellow, on Mar 26 2009, 02:21 PM, said:

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 07:10 PM, said:

So if we go back and look at who has made the major cases so far in this game we have Morgy and you yellow.

Yeah, and the conclusion of my "major case" was that I actually didn't have a case. Which was weak as fuck, but there you go. At least I didn't try to twist it into some bullshit thing to try and get the guy lynched, which some people might have done in that situation.

 Vengeance, on Mar 26 2009, 07:15 PM, said:

Are you saying that Morgy and JA and Mental are the only good players left in the game and if they are innocent then they are the innocents only shot at winning?

No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying that people latching onto The Weasel Excuse to just get rid of people they feel threatened by will cost us the game.

If you (or anyone) thinks JA or anyone else is guilty, then a case has to follow, otherwise it's just fear-mongering.

Well unfortunately the only real thing against JA is that he has been very very clean so far this game. I have voted for Kurt twice, Morgy, Mental, Bubba and now Gavin. The reason that I haven't voted for JA is that nothing at all that he has done has stuck me as scummy. Which when I think about it is probably why I suspect him. Now morgy has done several things that could be construed as suspicious. Mental has some comments but I am to lazy to go and find them. Kurt and Gavin just seem to be sliding through the game.

Who are your suspects and why Yellow?

[Mentalist]

 Jump Around, on Mar 26 2009, 03:25 PM, said:

 Mentalist, on Mar 26 2009, 05:08 PM, said:

go ahead with that...

I'll be really pissed if our scum are kurt and yellow.

Why?

Because those two are people that have given us absolutely NOTHING to go on.

at the moment, I think the best bet's morgoth, for several reasons.

Dkt's case on him, and, as WIFOM as this may sound, he was fairly high on DiBs' list as well.

Venge's symping of him, whether it was intentional or not.

the fact that he generally doesn't play th eway he usually does.