[Ruse]

Seems yet another day with hardly anyone to discuss things with....

[Path-Shaper]

Ruse, on Jan 28 2009, 01:29 PM, said:

Seems yet another day with hardly anyone to discuss things with....

[D'riss]

Ruse, on Jan 28 2009, 12:14 PM, said:

D'riss, on Jan 28 2009, 01:07 PM, said:

Lunch time, back soon.

Just keeping you all informed

You mean boost that post count...

Yep

Did you see any merit in my small case against Mockra. His half reveal was weird as well.

[Ruse]

I dunno what to make of the guy.
I think he could be a symp, so your case corresponds with my feelings somewhat.
Although you imply he is more likely necro, which i dont believe... especially now after his half reveal.
As the killers will very likely go for him tonight. Not a very smart thing for a necro to do.

[D'riss]

I thought undead recruit more likely but symp certainly fits. If he was recruited he would keep his role, so may be revealing just to try to add some inno cred. If nothing much happens this afternoon, he's nailed on for my vote.

[Ruse]

Sigh...this is exactly why i havent placed a vote in how long.
I am leaving in 2 hours, there is either no cases, or the main suspect is l-1.

I leave with 28 hours left and someone gets speed lynched while i am gone.


I would like Mockra to explain himself more thoroughly...
Also what happened to the HP case?....people dont like it anymore?
I thought it had some merit.

And there are a few other players that are hardly saying anything these last few days so its difficult to get a read.

[D'riss]

I'll have a re-read of the HP case now.

[Mockra]

lousy POS alarm clocks... how I HATES them....

sigh

so, all right, since people are getting frustrated with my "half reveal",

I'm the witch
I used my power last night
I did NOT use it on night 3, which is what makes me suspect that there may be more cultists there than we'd like to presume.

@ D'riss and his case: now that I don't have a role, it matters less for the innos if I get lynched, so I can finally say this.
the reason I didn't want to vote for ST was because I found myself agreeing with a lot of his reasoning, including his opinion about the Kas lynch. I missed that lynch, b/c I was sick. Reading back on it, I was able to get some perspective, and looking at both the cases and YEllow's reaction to them, a large portion of it seemed very WIFOM-based of Morgy's death. And no matter how awesome a player Morgoth may be, NKs are still WIFOM in my book.

Since Ano's lynched was based off the unconfirmed assumption that Kas was scum, which I did not fully share, you may understand why I was thinking what I did.

However, I had LESS doubt about the GL lynch--far less. Why? because there we were going off CONCRETE info--his reaction to confirmed scum's lynch, and his reaction to a confirmed medium's reveal.
so yes, yesterday my logic was: "GL was the creature. he's dead. the only way necros remain a threat is through the survival of killers. Ano is suspected Necro off the assumptions I don't fully share. even if I'm wrong and he is Necro, if we kill the psychos, he's useless. if we find the psycho, we can kill Ano at our leisure, while avoiding another NK"

and I wanted to avoid NKs. reasoning? in the WCS, Necros recruited 1 person night 1. they then could have gotten 2 recruits night 3. assuming 3 to start with, and only 2 gone (Fener + GL, since im still thinking WCS), that left us with 4. this night it could have become 5, and then we'd have been 1 incorrect lynch away from victory.

Based on the above logic, I tried to get people to look for possible psychos, becasue I like to look ahead and not be stuck in the present day. We've been tunnel-visioned by hunting the cult ever since Kesso revealed on day 2. if we kept it up, even if we rootedout all cult, finding the scum would have become much more difficult with nothing to go on.

oh, and for the record, D'riss, you omit Meanas making the case on Ruse, to which i've added the second vote, and Shadow was the one that made a case on you, not me. I have not voted for you on day 5.

[Mockra]

HP's case, incidentally was abandoned by ppl, b/c HP claimed that it was a mistake in what they wrote.

[D'riss]

Vote Mockra

I know now he is scum, because I am the witch. So I will die tonight but as we have advantage in numbers we can now lynch a definite scum of one or the other faction. I'm begging you people, don't let me die in vain, VOTE MOCKRA, he is scum!!!

Grrrr! Scum! Scum!

[Ruse]

hmmm...what i thought you might say.

cross post

This post has been edited by Ruse: 28 January 2009 - 01:51 PM

[Mockra]

hah
so you're the one that blocked night 3?

lol
i guess it's possible JA could have put 2 such roles in.

[Ruse]

sigh...like i said....he must be a symp.
We dont need to kill symps...we want there masters.
So for now i am willing to ignore mockra.

[Mockra]

sigh
this hasn't been my best game anyhow
if you send me to spoilers i'll either feel quite silly for believing ST if him and Kas were scum, or get the minute satisfaction of the "I told you so"s, if I was right all along that we were being played by the scum and necros.

ETA: anyhow, that's my take on the game, whether you believe it or not, it's up to you. Feels good to finally be able to sya this on thread rather than in spoilers, since now I no longer have to fear getting lynched before I can be useful to my team. now that i'm just an RI I can freely express my opnion, no matter how outlandish it is.

This post has been edited by Mockra: 28 January 2009 - 01:59 PM

[Ruse]

Who the fuck is ST
Jesus, if your going to do an acronym at least make it SOMEWHAT understadable

[Mockra]

ST-Sir Thursday
ie Ano. you're not from around here, are you?

[Ruse]

How the fuck can you gruop a player alt and a goddamn real alt.
God all mighty...

Yes i am very new...never played here before...

[Mockra]

we all know each other... and peolple do it all the time,

[D'riss]

Ruse, on Jan 28 2009, 01:53 PM, said:

sigh...like i said....he must be a symp.
We dont need to kill symps...we want there masters.
So for now i am willing to ignore mockra.

OK, if he's merely a symp we can just ignore him for now and go after bigger fish. I thought my case against him was pretty weak but it seems to have been the straw that broke the camel's back, and he panicked into a fake reveal. Cool

However, If I'm still alive tomorrow you'll have to lynch me because I would have been recruited.

Just for confimation, I very nearly used the BP to save Kess. However, I'd convinced myself (through admittedly dodgy logic) that all was not well with him. If I'd have used the BP firstly I'd have difficulty letting you all know without revealing and secondly others may have wasted a lynch on him on the assumption he'd been recruited.

I actually used it on the night that fell over the weekend. Quite a few players had said they would not be around so it would have been an ideal time for a few scum to force a lynch. Still not sure I made the right decision, but hey ho, this is my first attempt at Mafia and its all a bit bloody overwhelming

And now, I go for my final meal....

edit: for unwanted smiley

This post has been edited by D'riss: 28 January 2009 - 02:10 PM

[Ruse]

Mockra, on Jan 28 2009, 03:07 PM, said:

we all know each other... and peolple do it all the time,

yes they do it in the regular forum, for all i know you are refering to shadow...thinking he is Shadow Thrown....ie ST


pfffft


there, go eat it

This post has been edited by Ruse: 28 January 2009 - 02:10 PM