[Mockra]

Original cult could be a likely BP though, so I reckon recruit is more likely.
Also, assuming anything about that is probabaly a bad idea, cause if we go with best scene scenario, we will probably get some nasty surprises.

[Emurlahn]

Gamelon, on Nov 13 2008, 05:58 PM, said:

Just got back in and noticed Thyr and Omtose are gone. Got to cook the tea before I have a look back and see what has been happening. Does anybody have any idea how many cult are in game? A guesstimate even.

Well i think were pretty sure that they started at 2. but we're unsure how many they can recruit a night. Worst case scenario would be 2 a night which would mean they could be on 7 already but that is very unlikely, more likely is 1 a night or 1 every 2 nights so at most they would have 3 left, maybe only 2.

[Mockra]

Got to say, Galayn Lord was in my mind kinda.
Cant put my finger on why though.

What about someone flying under the radar.

Edit: I was thinking say, Ruse, Fenerm Emurlahn, or something.

This post has been edited by Mockra: 13 November 2008 - 06:06 PM

[Emurlahn]

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 06:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

Yeah I am thinking Gaylan Lord, his post when he just came back seemed very suspicious, when he just came back and went, oh look Rashans dead, so who we going for meanas, Omtose or (galain i think he said),
when at this point omtose had been only briefly pointed out by shadow for a reasonable high number of posts while not being remembered so it seemed like he was clutching at straws.
Apologies if ive slightly misquoted there will go back and look for the exact quote in a bit.
I have been saying for a while that meanas does look scummy because of not voting Ano on the first day.

[Galayn Lord]

Mockra, on Nov 13 2008, 10:03 AM, said:

Got to say, Galayn Lord was in my mind kinda.
Cant put my finger on why though.

What about someone flying under the radar.

Have I been?

I've tried for some contributive content, rather than spam or circular arguments with others (me and Gamelon, for example, could have thoroughly thread-spammed back and forth OMGUS, etc., but that was fortunately short-circuited).

My next focus was supposed to be on Meanas, but I can't remember why. Of course, I was rather wrong about Serc, thinking he was Cult, so ...

[Ruse]

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

I had that same strange gut feeling about galayn lord earlier. I made a semicase against him earlier, but nothing he's said is overly suspicious. Although it was the same gut feeling that would have made me suggest omtose if Shadow hadn't beaten me to it, so it could be worth listening to. For some reason I also wanna take a look at Fener, dont ask me why.

Alright, there's like 8 people online, let's hunt us some scum!

@Mockra, true enough. Assume there's still scum until you've won

This post has been edited by Ruse: 13 November 2008 - 06:10 PM

[Hood's Path]

Ruse, on Nov 13 2008, 10:00 AM, said:

A cultist, nice. What are the opinions? Original member or recruit? I dont think his playstyle changed over the course of the game, which is slightly indicative of being an original member, but I'm probably just being hopeful here.

He was fairly consistent throughout and his post stayed relatively contentless. I would lean towards original. I think Laton might have a BP so if I had to place money o it, I would say he was Camilla (or whatever the tramps name is)

[Mockra]

Sorry, got to go.
Will be back before the deadline. Assuming no speed lynch.

See you all later.

[Galain]

My best candidate for the missing Ivet would be Meanas for his good-timing internets meltdowns. If not him, then we're in for a tough hunt because I don't remember anyone else acting bizarre during the Ivet lynches. Except, ironically, Serc.

[Fener]

Whoa, first two killers then a cultist, we're on a roll! Could that be a vig, or is it the killers?

I don't particularly like Ruse's way of chalking down Thyrllan's modkill to 'information'. How could Thyrllan's death be of help to us? Unless he knows anything we don't?

Other than that, I'm still pissed at Meanas for skipping a vote for Ano. I'd like to find out what that was all about. Now we know Rashan was scum, so to me it's quite logical to put pressure on Meanas. Thoughts?



Edit: changed Rashan to Ano.

This post has been edited by Fener: 13 November 2008 - 06:12 PM

[Ruse]

Did anyone try defend Omtose? I dont think so... I dont remember anyone but me and shadow talking about him, so not much to look at there unfortunately.

[Emurlahn]

Galain, on Nov 13 2008, 06:10 PM, said:

My best candidate for the missing Ivet would be Meanas for his good-timing internets meltdowns. If not him, then we're in for a tough hunt because I don't remember anyone else acting bizarre during the Ivet lynches. Except, ironically, Serc.

As said Im inclined to go that way as well, He also managed to miss the second Rashan Lynch as well as the Ano lynch. I know he was on the first Rashan lynch but i think that can be put down to him obviously being on at that time and under suspicion so not placing a lynch on Rashan after such overwhelming evidence from Tennes would have been suicidal.

[Hood's Path]

Ruse, on Nov 13 2008, 10:08 AM, said:

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

I had that same strange gut feeling about galayn lord earlier. I made a semicase against him earlier, but nothing he's said is overly suspicious. Although it was the same gut feeling that would have made me suggest omtose if Shadow hadn't beaten me to it, so it could be worth listening to. For some reason I also wanna take a look at Fener, dont ask me why.

Alright, there's like 8 people online, let's hunt us some scum!

@Mockra, true enough. Assume there's still scum until you've won

Glad you brought this up... I think Fener is suspect as well. He was his normal kinda spammy self first day and night, after night 1 he kinda shut up. I think Fener is a cult recruit. Just keeping that in mind. Not necessarily gonna go after him because I am assuming recruit, but something to keep an eye on.

Saw

[Hood's Path]

Ruse, on Nov 13 2008, 10:08 AM, said:

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

I had that same strange gut feeling about galayn lord earlier. I made a semicase against him earlier, but nothing he's said is overly suspicious. Although it was the same gut feeling that would have made me suggest omtose if Shadow hadn't beaten me to it, so it could be worth listening to. For some reason I also wanna take a look at Fener, dont ask me why.

Alright, there's like 8 people online, let's hunt us some scum!

@Mockra, true enough. Assume there's still scum until you've won

Glad you brought this up... I think Fener is suspect as well. He was his normal kinda spammy self first day and night, after night 1 he kinda shut up. I think Fener is a cult recruit. Just keeping that in mind. Not necessarily gonna go after him because I am assuming recruit, but something to keep an eye on.

Saw he just

[Hood's Path]

Ruse, on Nov 13 2008, 10:08 AM, said:

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

I had that same strange gut feeling about galayn lord earlier. I made a semicase against him earlier, but nothing he's said is overly suspicious. Although it was the same gut feeling that would have made me suggest omtose if Shadow hadn't beaten me to it, so it could be worth listening to. For some reason I also wanna take a look at Fener, dont ask me why.

Alright, there's like 8 people online, let's hunt us some scum!

@Mockra, true enough. Assume there's still scum until you've won

Glad you brought this up... I think Fener is suspect as well. He was his normal kinda spammy self first day and night, after night 1 he kinda shut up. I think Fener is a cult recruit. Just keeping that in mind. Not necessarily gonna go after him because I am assuming recruit, but something to keep an eye on.

Saw he just posted and still want's Meanas- This would fit with Meanas being the last Ivet.

Just speculation- I really have nothing but feelings on the Fener front.

EDIT: LAst part cause I accidentally hit send and changed Serc to Meanas

This post has been edited by Hood's Path: 13 November 2008 - 06:47 PM

[Ruse]

I agree that Meanas is a good subject at this point. Although we shouldn't be hasty, we have a nice long day ahead of us. I'm gonna go back and look at Rashan's day two train, see which people just dropped by to place a vote then disappeared. Like it's been said before, agreeing with the obvious course of action isn't scummy, but it's a good place for scum to hide.

[Hood's Path]

Bah- sorry for the double

[Galayn Lord]

Just read through all of Meanas' posts, and it's about 90% "Just dropping in" stuff.

Not quite enough to get a vote, but ... he hasn't really taken a hard stance against anyone.

[Ruse]

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:16 PM, said:

Ruse, on Nov 13 2008, 10:08 AM, said:

Hood's Path, on Nov 13 2008, 08:01 PM, said:

OK- was waiting for night to end. I think we really need to look at Meanas and Gaylan lord. Meanas for the obvious reasons, Gaylan Lord becasue... well, let me get back to you. Going to do a re-read on his posts.

I had that same strange gut feeling about galayn lord earlier. I made a semicase against him earlier, but nothing he's said is overly suspicious. Although it was the same gut feeling that would have made me suggest omtose if Shadow hadn't beaten me to it, so it could be worth listening to. For some reason I also wanna take a look at Fener, dont ask me why.

Alright, there's like 8 people online, let's hunt us some scum!

@Mockra, true enough. Assume there's still scum until you've won

Glad you brought this up... I think Fener is suspect as well. He was his normal kinda spammy self first day and night, after night 1 he kinda shut up. I think Fener is a cult recruit. Just keeping that in mind. Not necessarily gonna go after him because I am assuming recruit, but something to keep an eye on.

Saw he just posted and still want's Serc- This would fit with Serc being the last Ivet.

Just speculation- I really have nothing but feelings on the Fener front.

EDIT: LAst part cause I accidentally hit send

Uhm, Fener didnt say anything about Serc. Noone has (other than galain commenting that he acted wierdly, which he did) cos he's dead...

[Fener]

What do you mean, I've shut up? We've had more than one speed lynch, and I've been talking as much as you, Hood's path. Incidentally you've got only 4 more posts than me. Besides, there haven't been much discussion of interest during the time we've gone after Rashan. But go ahead and make a case, we definitely need more activity now. Personally I'd like to look closer at Meanas and maybe Galayne Lord. And we seem to have completely forgotten about Gamelon?



Edit: @ Hood's Path

This post has been edited by Fener: 13 November 2008 - 06:23 PM