[J_Slr]

Wait... Peter could protect against recruitment?
*goes to page one*

[Mentalist]

lol, the fact that I vigged 2/3 of D'riss and Adam before him helped, too..

[dktorode]

ahlf my team also won..crazy shit.

I am left out in the cold because i wanted to accomodate there winning conditions aswell
just my luck...they win...i dont.
Last time im being nice

[Mentalist]

Venge would say "about time"
I stopped being nice in this game.
when I took the gamble by vigging D'riss night 2.

[dktorode]

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:38 AM, said:

lol, the fact that I vigged 2/3 of D'riss and Adam before him helped, too..

i wouldn't brag about accidentally knocking over a serial killer

[dktorode]

still...our original winning conditions were def impossible

[Mentalist]

dktorode, on Nov 5 2008, 03:40 AM, said:

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:38 AM, said:

lol, the fact that I vigged 2/3 of D'riss and Adam before him helped, too..

i wouldn't brag about accidentally knocking over a serial killer

it wasn't a complete accident
I narrowed it down to 2 people
and he acted scummy.
more of an "educated guess"

[J_Slr]

OOO!!! Dibs game has a sign up!!!

[dktorode]

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:42 AM, said:

dktorode, on Nov 5 2008, 03:40 AM, said:

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:38 AM, said:

lol, the fact that I vigged 2/3 of D'riss and Adam before him helped, too..

i wouldn't brag about accidentally knocking over a serial killer

it wasn't a complete accident
I narrowed it down to 2 people
and he acted scummy.
more of an "educated guess"

i would call a last minute change of vig pretty accidental

[J_Slr]

Ummm.... did anyone alt guess me btw?

[Mentalist]

dktorode, on Nov 5 2008, 03:41 AM, said:

still...our original winning conditions were def impossible

catching Claire would be hard.
i think you'd pull off Adam.
for Peter/Sylar, you'd need the Haitian to mind-wipe them for the day phase, so they wouldn't be able to send the mods the escape action
and catch the other one the following night
that's provided you picked up Adam and Claire too.

difficult to say the least.
but if you had previously left 2 tokens on one of the leaders, doable even with the minimal starting company.

[Mentalist]

dktorode, on Nov 5 2008, 03:44 AM, said:

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:42 AM, said:

dktorode, on Nov 5 2008, 03:40 AM, said:

Mentalist, on Nov 5 2008, 11:38 AM, said:

lol, the fact that I vigged 2/3 of D'riss and Adam before him helped, too..

i wouldn't brag about accidentally knocking over a serial killer

it wasn't a complete accident
I narrowed it down to 2 people
and he acted scummy.
more of an "educated guess"

i would call a last minute change of vig pretty accidental

lol, I had a REASON!
Adam targetted Ruse. thus Ruse can't be Adam
Galain was next down the list of "potential scum"

@ J: i thought you were q21 at first, but then you mentioned you never played killer before. so i thought you were either one of the fresh newb crop. later irealised that it might be you, but didn't bother sending in a guess PM.

[Tapper]

Phew, wrestled my way through spoilers.
Nice to see that my first altguesses were all good...

Morgy, if I sound perfectly sane, intelligent and reasonable and you WANT to agree... it's because I am all that. It's not because I might be JA
second time in a row you like me, should Sara get worried you're into manlove now?

On to the game:

Great game Gem, I loved it, especially when reading the thoughts and checks and balances behind it now. The whole set-up is brilliant. I especially like how the whole voting concept is out of the window. Lynches are not important in this game, so it's all about planning and strategizing.

Minor comment on Nathan's role:
Since it isn't interactive and since you have to have a wincondition, the best way to get a win-condition is, in hindsight, NOT using it and revealing day 1 so that Sylar and Peter fight over it, or company has to force its hand or see an unknown big power get even more powerful.
Later in the game, it's useful for Sylar only I think, as he can kill and fly.

This game, I stood by the sidelines twiddling my thumbs and singing a song while whoring myself out to the highest bidder... and there were no takers Not a huge amount of fun and fairly passive, as there's also little lynching/casemaking to be done as the road to victory here isn't about scum/thinning the ranks. It was just keeping myself away from modkill for day 3.

I'd tweak the role slightly and say that by using 2 tokens (out of the 3 flying tokens), you can lift up someone else with you. It hardly breaks the game, but it is a very nice and proactive effect and a boon to Peter's side as well. It also gives the Nathan player something to do... he's otherwise just a vote in a game that will be low on lynches as he has no info, no investigations and is generally a waste of actions only.

Also, I would add for Simone and Ando that they win when Isaac/Hiro win, but that's just me.

[Morgoth]

all right, having read through the spoilers I have some things to add.

First and foremost, for those of you that I cursed loudly in here and haven't appologised to.. well.. sorry about that. I've been sick again ad not in the best of moods.

for those complaining about information and all. I had none. I knew that Ruse was peter and that was it. I didn't know that Sylar needed two tries to kill me, I did not get any information about who had been captured by Peter and had no idea tat anyone else knew who I was. Yet I had figured most of the game out before the role reveals, so hah!

I dunno whether people thinking I was JA is a good thing or not. I'm kinda insulted and kinda flattered ..

And mercy dk? There's no room for mercy

[q21]

Path-Shaper, on Nov 1 2008, 03:58 AM, said:

Man, I just LOVE Telas reveal.

It was good wasn't it. Had everyone believing I was BP for the rest of the game... it was great.

[J_Slr]

Thank you for telling him Morggy

Now maybe next time round he will listen to his crazy captive!

[J_Slr]

@q21: You may have had them fooled, but I was not! MWUHAHAHA!

[q21]

D'riss response:

Quote

I'm sorry but the whole 2 people with BP can see all night actions and provisionals is a little overpowered, so I am going to keep switching everytime someone mentions my NAs!

There were two BP night action readers?

[Jump Around]

q21, on Nov 5 2008, 03:14 PM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Nov 1 2008, 03:58 AM, said:

Man, I just LOVE Telas reveal.

It was good wasn't it. Had everyone believing I was BP for the rest of the game... it was great.

I called bullshit on that, but apparently this was not a lynching game

[dktorode]

Morgoth, on Nov 5 2008, 03:04 PM, said:

all right, having read through the spoilers I have some things to add.

First and foremost, for those of you that I cursed loudly in here and haven't appologised to.. well.. sorry about that. I've been sick again ad not in the best of moods.

for those complaining about information and all. I had none. I knew that Ruse was peter and that was it. I didn't know that Sylar needed two tries to kill me, I did not get any information about who had been captured by Peter and had no idea tat anyone else knew who I was. Yet I had figured most of the game out before the role reveals, so hah!

I dunno whether people thinking I was JA is a good thing or not. I'm kinda insulted and kinda flattered ..

And mercy dk? There's no room for mercy

mercy?