[J_Slr]

I still can not believe that Fener did not block Shadows NA though!

[Mentalist]

Fener's win came from Claire living
he was, in fact playing for Peter the entire last day,

[J_Slr]

I know

[J_Slr]

You know I spent half of my saturday waiting for a response from the mods with regards to wtf Mockra was messaging me and calling me mohinder for.

[Mentalist]

yeah, there were some serious miscommunications there..
I blame Venge.

also, stupid q21... he freaked me out with that "you can't kill Sylar/Peter" thing..

thank god I decided to just "waste" my vig on you in the end... The Dude must hate my spontaneity...

[J_Slr]

Yeah! Well I read your role and put that together with the second last PM I received and felt that it was not fair! Technically the mods changed the rules!

But then I am bitter because I lost!

[Jump Around]

I read the first few posts of SH, and let me get this straight:

1) Peter wins if Claire is alive
2) Sylar wins if he kills Claire
3) Only Sylar can kill Claire.

So, by simple logic, this game will be won by Peter or Sylar. Why the hell add a Company?

You center the game on those three, and Claire is invincible, Peter and Sylar BPed up the ass, it just becomes a game of whack-a-mole between those two, and since the rest has no clue they just spam and make lynch trains on people they can't kill anyways.


As for me being lost all game, well fuck, there was 60+ pages of posts during the second day/night containing purely role assumptions and strategies, with Liosan in the heart of things. And I "knew" he was lying about his own role, so I just skipped the whole thing thinking it was misinformation.

I mean, fuck, now I know my votes were pointless for the outcome of the game, on top of that the lousy role I get had me make an ass of myself. I should have been Ando.

This post has been edited by Jump Around: 05 November 2008 - 06:46 AM

[Mentalist]

sigh
company was there to make things complicated.
since half of them were actually Peter's potential symps....

EDIT: read my comments in spoilers--the long one.
the game was fun, but some roles would have been a lot more fun than others in this set up.
Matt, Nathan, Ando and Simone really became absolutely peripheral once the mass reveal staged by the company happened.

the only reason Liosan retained importance after the death of Adam was because he gained a recruitment abilty
also, blame venge for the liosan-Lisheo PM fuckup.... i'm sure that would mess up your game as well...

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 05 November 2008 - 06:53 AM

[J_Slr]

Actually JA, I needed both Peter and Claire dead.

[J_Slr]

I liked the set up, I just think Adam should have been more Claire like or I should have been able to talk to him!

Ugh! I feel so cheated right now!

[Mentalist]

J_Slr, on Nov 5 2008, 01:51 AM, said:

I liked the set up, I just think Adam should have been more Claire like or I should have been able to talk to him!

Ugh! I feel so cheated right now!

lol, imagine how the Dude must feel towards me now... I took him out with a lucky last minute change of my NA...

[J_Slr]

Well shit does happen!

[Mentalist]

yah, it was funny..

"I'm bored. Vig ruse."
"no wait. I should look for Adam, b/c Everyone's talking about him. Vig Meanas"
"yeah, poor Lisheo (meanas)... confirm kill"
"oh, well Elle must be a vig (lightning and all). no point in double-vigging him. Switch back to Ruse."

and then at the end of the day.
"Wait, Adam's poisoning Ruse? so it can't be Adam!
vig Galain!"

[J_Slr]

That was awesome!
But ADAM has the same power as Claire! Why oh Why did he die like that?????

:rant::rant:

[Jump Around]

Let me get this straight - I got the wrong PM and fucked up a whole week worth of mafia because the mods confused "Liosan" and "Lisheo" ?

...

And they were making fun of him because he was asking to "capture Claire" instead of the alt. My, my, my...

[Mentalist]

sigh
blame Venge
it's the only answer.
I'm really sorry for you, JA--I can imagine haw that could fuck up your game, esp when dealing with a prolific player like Grief...
but yeah, venge just screwed up, b/che got an unalted post from Lisheo and sent it to you instead of a Liosan's PM. that would've told you that he was Mohinder, most likely.

[Mockra]

huh....well that sucked.

Being in the dark really blows.
All these unknown winning conditions.
while EVERYONE know mine...very fair

[Mentalist]

hey, I played 2 days without even having one..
lol
good game, dkt
from spoilers, it's obvious that you did the best you could to lead the company.

[Mentalist]

J_Slr, on Nov 5 2008, 01:44 AM, said:

Yeah! Well I read your role and put that together with the second last PM I received and felt that it was not fair! Technically the mods changed the rules!

But then I am bitter because I lost!

hmm
read spoilers
I adressed that question there
Gem wasn't herself sure what it meant. I put my order LONG before clarification--the kill was on you all day, but I kept joking around with Liosan to prevent a block by the Haitian.
also, technically, I removed your 2 BPs. Ruse killed you.

logging off now. enough spamming for one evening.
great game, everyone. Virtual rep all around.

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 05 November 2008 - 07:31 AM

[J_Slr]

Yeah I am reading and I can not help but think that our mods influenced your decision to vig me damn it!

This post has been edited by J_Slr: 05 November 2008 - 07:42 AM