[Obdigore]

Baudin, Dktorode, Jump Around, Lacedaemonian, Lisheo, Mocker, Obdigore, Silencer, The Dude

You want to hear my thoughts? How nice of you to ask for them before you build a bullshit case and nearly lynch me while I sleep ;P

Baudin: Honestly, I forget he is playing until I see his dancing devil pig.
DK: Cozy Cozy with JA, but that might be JA's plan, and not evil on DK's part.
JA: Throwing shit around at different people all game, but avoiding real confrontations until yesterday. He also has yet to miss a lynch train, and anyone who comments that he has been playing funny ends up NKed.
Lace: This is a tough one. He is PLAYING, but I can't tell if he is inno or evil.
Lisheo: This is one of the two who I would guess is JA's partner or symp.
Mocker: Not a big read here. Much like Baudin I really forget he is playing...
Obdi: I signed up to give you guys a full player list, and I didn't really have hte time to play until yesterday and today. I was almost lynched for it, but hey, you guys do what you want.
Silencer: Dosen't post a lot. Problem is that he ALWAYS plays like this, whether he is inno or not.
The_Dude: It hink he is JA's other partner/symp candidate. Followed his lead quite a bit, helped throwing random stuff around. He could be the 'silent partner'.

[Lacedaemonian]

I think I have played this game more than most and am happy at my involvement but disappointed with my results. I felt abject guilt when Morg and Veng turned up Inno - presuming they truly were. I am also going to believe DK, simply so that I can reduce my levels of paranoia and enjoy a slightly smaller case load.

We should have lynched Baudin on Monday as a birthday treat.

I could list everybody here but these are the issues that stick:

Obdi's tantrum yesterday made me a little wary of him.

Silencer/Baudin/Mocker - for their lacking of game.

The Dude - purely for playing a seemless game.

JA - for his easy relationship with DK yesterday prior to the revelations.

Lisheo - for just being an all round dodgy bastard. His game stinks of something and he is the lone survivor of my Mondays list. Saying that his game stinks of something is a valid reason in my mind.

Lacedaemonian - For posting a Wind in the Willows quote when pissed last night.


All valid reasons.

PS Baby sleeps currently...............................

EDIT: Cross post lol - Look at me and you in cahoots!!!

This post has been edited by Lacedaemonian: 24 October 2008 - 01:44 PM

[Lisheo]

Dodgy bastard?
What does my game stink of? I had noodles for dinner last night, maybe...

[Lacedaemonian]

Lisheo, on Oct 24 2008, 02:43 PM, said:

Dodgy bastard?
What does my game stink of? I had noodles for dinner last night, maybe...

You not notice the fact I listed everybody?

[Jump Around]

Well, that was worth the wait

I'll answer the parts relating to me:

Obdigore, on Oct 24 2008, 04:37 PM, said:

JA: Throwing shit around at different people all game, but avoiding real confrontations until yesterday. He also has yet to miss a lynch train, and anyone who comments that he has been playing funny ends up NKed.

What you call "throwing shit around", is noting what I find suspicious when a player does it. What else can you do, besides spamming?

You say I avoided real confrontation until yesterday, well until now you were ranting I was railroading all game. Yesterday I took it in my hands because, for the first time, the lynch candidate was my choice. Sorry, but you can't just ask everyone to vote for who they think is scum and hope for a majority. If you do that you end up with 0-3 votes per person and nothing happens.

You say I haven't missed a lynch train, it's because the only time I wasn't around for the lynch deadline, there was no lynch, and sometimes (Morgoth), my vote was needed. What is the preferable alternative to you?

As for the players getting NKed, from the killers I would think J_Slr, Yellow, Dibs and Gavin. I don't remember J_Slr and Yellow commenting about me, and if anything Dibs and Gavin said they trusted me. What do you think, as a killer I want to win, or make my life impossible for the endgame?

[Path-Shaper]

it is day 4, 7 hours and 10 minutes left

9 people still grooving to the beat: Baudin, Dktorode, Jump Around, Lacedaemonian, Lisheo, Mocker, Obdigore, Silencer, The Dude

takes 5 votes to lynch or 5 to go to night

1 vote: mocker (Jump Around)
1 vote: Obdigore (Silencer)

Note Voted: Baudin, Dktorode, Lacedaemonian, Lisheo, Mocker, Obdigore, The Dude

[Giles]

The more i think about it and the more people bring it up JA does start standing out to me as a well hidden Scum. I'm not sure what it is he's just so clean. I think being someone being nice just makes me suspicious.
As i may not be on again before the lynch i will throw out a vote, if i do manage to get on later it may change but for now
Vote JA

[Obdigore]

Oh no, Both Gavin And DIBS said you were playing 'differently' than you normally do, and they both ended up NKed.

Yesterday, for the first time, you led a lynch against an inno, while being perfectly happy to let other people lead the inno lynches before you, and you just jumped on the train.

The throwing shit around is because you have basicly wiped your list at every night and gone after 3-4 different people.

[Jump Around]

baudin, on Oct 24 2008, 04:50 PM, said:

I think being someone being nice just makes me suspicious.

If we were alted, and didn't know you were a new player, you would see how nice I can be with players who play like you did so far this game

[Lacedaemonian]

J_Slr and Yellow both made comments about me before they died. Either the killers think I am their Symp or they think I am their Symp. Losers.

I am trying to think of trains that got derailed. We might not have killed a killer but surely we have had a train on one. Obdi reacted bad to his. JA has reacted badly to the suggestion of one on him. Silencer came to life with one on him. I was cool as fuck with my train - dont care what you say. Think I only needed one more vote and I was gone.

Something tells me that maybe only Obdi could be a killer from this list. Some players have not been tested with a train, which is a shame. Lish, Dude or Baudin???? Still the list remains too big.

[Jump Around]

Obdigore, on Oct 24 2008, 04:51 PM, said:

Yesterday, for the first time, you led a lynch against an inno, while being perfectly happy to let other people lead the inno lynches before you, and you just jumped on the train.

I have to admit, I didn't put a random vote on an out-of-nowhere player like you did a few times.

Then again, I don't have the ObdiRadar, the one that knew he didn't risk anything tying his fate to Vengeance's yesterday

[Lisheo]

I've also made a point of JA taking this game seriously, I'm still here. I don't think those nks were chosen for any other reason than to make us argue amongst ourselves and also to take out the strongest, most vocal players. I haven't had a huge amount of influence on the game, and I'm still here, but I have commented on JA. I haven't allied myself with him earlier in the game either, but I always had my eye on SIlencer, and it seemed that Veng, you and him were in on something, Obdi.

[dktorode]

Looks like ts come down to JA vs Obdi

To be honest....i dont know wich way i will vote. Obdi screams scum, but JA is making me nervous. Prolly just my paranoia acting up....fneh

This post has been edited by dktorode: 24 October 2008 - 02:02 PM

[Jump Around]

OK, I really hope I won't get lynched, on this important moment in the game, because I played like an inno, making little mistake, so by WIFOM and high-school paranoia I must be a killer.

If you think I played well, nice and without sounding scummy, it's because I'm inno, and I made an effort to play a good game. I made one mistake so far, with Vengeance, but last time I checked I didn't "trick" anyone in voting him, I made a case.

I know that sometimes many prefer to lynch an inno, than risk the 1 in a hundred chance that the inno is a disguised killer. I call this "fearing the humiliation rather than playing to win". I don't give a shit, I got humiliated at this game a few times and I'm still alive, and I wouldn't mind you lynching me if this was not an important day for the game.

If you really think I'm a killer, then look for my partner, shit, I can't be alone. Then at least I know there's a chance you'll be right, and there's only one Weasel on thread if it makes you feel better, so possibly my partner didn't play a "perfect inno" game.

[Lacedaemonian]

We missed a lynch one day. Do you think that made it harder for us to win?

[Obdigore]

Jump Around, on Oct 24 2008, 08:54 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Oct 24 2008, 04:51 PM, said:

Yesterday, for the first time, you led a lynch against an inno, while being perfectly happy to let other people lead the inno lynches before you, and you just jumped on the train.

I have to admit, I didn't put a random vote on an out-of-nowhere player like you did a few times.

Then again, I don't have the ObdiRadar, the one that knew he didn't risk anything tying his fate to Vengeance's yesterday

ObdiRadar also cleared Gem, Morgy, and DIBs.

And in fact, I was against voting for anyone you suggest, JA, because I think you are the killer. That is what made me so sure Vengeance was innocent in your eyes. It also partially clears Silencer, but then you (and all the rest of us, pretty much) forgot all about Silencer after the clusterfuck yesterday, didn't we.

[Jump Around]

dktorode, on Oct 24 2008, 05:02 PM, said:

Looks like ts come down to JA vs Obdi

Why? We can still lynch a new player like Mocker or Baudin.

I trust Obdi is a killer, I explained why yesterday's events with Vengeance being inno doesn't clear him (on the contrary), but I see it's not shared by everyone. I don't mind looking somewhere else, it's like for me, if he's a killer he's not alone.

[Jump Around]

Lacedaemonian, on Oct 24 2008, 05:05 PM, said:

We missed a lynch one day. Do you think that made it harder for us to win?

You're thinking day 2.

Without the CFs on those that we, during the day, put pressure on, would we know where we stand?

Do you think the killers would NK the players involved in arguments so we know which way to stand, or kill one another by mistake?

[Jump Around]

Obdigore, on Oct 24 2008, 05:05 PM, said:

ObdiRadar also cleared Gem, Morgy, and DIBs.

The fact that ObdiRadar has gotten EVERYONE right so far is not something the ObdiRadar owner should keep bragging about.

[Obdigore]

Jump Around, on Oct 24 2008, 09:10 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Oct 24 2008, 05:05 PM, said:

ObdiRadar also cleared Gem, Morgy, and DIBs.

The fact that ObdiRadar has gotten EVERYONE right so far is not something the ObdiRadar owner should keep bragging about.

Oh don't worry, Im sure the WeasalSonar was right about them all being inno as well, but you want to kill innos.

The case on you comes down to this: If you are inno, you are playing a horrible game. If you are a killer, you are playing a very very good game. So, what do people think of JA, is he a poor, deluded player, or a very good one? He isn't called the weasal because he gets confused and dosen't know what he is doing.

Edit: Spell Sonar right.

This post has been edited by Obdigore: 24 October 2008 - 02:13 PM