[Gavin]

So.. current vote count is:

4 votes for Silencer (Jump Around, Lisheo, Morgoth, The Dude)
1 vote for Lisheo (Obdigore)
4 votes Morgoth (Lacedaemonian, Yellow, Tapper, Silencer)

Not sure how we are going to get a lynch really. DKT and I are both to vote that pushes it up to 6. If JA switches we get 7 on Morgoth. If Lace switches (I see you reading) we get 7 on Silencer. Tapper was around that would make 8 if he was willing to switch as well. If not we need to hope someone else shows up in the next two hours that isn't voting for Morgoth.

As I said before I'm happy to vote either.

[Jump Around]

Well, we need 4 votes on either trains.
Not counting personal opinions, but only player's presence:

Potential Morgoth votes: Me, dktorode, Gavin, The Dude

Potential Silence votes: dktorode, Gavin, Lace, Tapper

So it can go either way. Opinions of those concerned?

edit: cross-post with Gavin, who is fine with both. Who else?

edit 2: sorry if this sounds bossy, but I just got wind I'll miss the last hour due to a meeting, so if my vote is needed I would need to know before that

This post has been edited by Jump Around: 22 October 2008 - 08:58 AM

[Tapper]

Gavin, on Oct 22 2008, 10:54 AM, said:

So.. current vote count is:

4 votes for Silencer (Jump Around, Lisheo, Morgoth, The Dude)
1 vote for Lisheo (Obdigore)
4 votes Morgoth (Lacedaemonian, Yellow, Tapper, Silencer)

Not sure how we are going to get a lynch really. DKT and I are both to vote that pushes it up to 6. If JA switches we get 7 on Morgoth. If Lace switches (I see you reading) we get 7 on Silencer. Tapper was around that would make 8 if he was willing to switch as well. If not we need to hope someone else shows up in the next two hours that isn't voting for Morgoth.

As I said before I'm happy to vote either.

No, I'm not willing to change targets.
Silencer wanting to lynch to me as his objective for this game sucks for me personally. If he lets it prevail above team inno's win conditions it would be amateurnight. I trust he won't do that if he's scum.
But I have no case on him, apart from him being a lowposter and thus potentially a killer. I do have a case on Morgoth that I will drop if it doesn't rally enough votes for a lynch, but that I want to see through to the end today.

Silencer did what I asked of him, he asked if I was satisfied and i replied that I'd take it at face value. For today, that settles it for me.

[dktorode]

Tapper, on Oct 22 2008, 12:00 PM, said:

Gavin, on Oct 22 2008, 10:54 AM, said:

So.. current vote count is:

4 votes for Silencer (Jump Around, Lisheo, Morgoth, The Dude)
1 vote for Lisheo (Obdigore)
4 votes Morgoth (Lacedaemonian, Yellow, Tapper, Silencer)

Not sure how we are going to get a lynch really. DKT and I are both to vote that pushes it up to 6. If JA switches we get 7 on Morgoth. If Lace switches (I see you reading) we get 7 on Silencer. Tapper was around that would make 8 if he was willing to switch as well. If not we need to hope someone else shows up in the next two hours that isn't voting for Morgoth.

As I said before I'm happy to vote either.

No, I'm not willing to change targets.
Silencer wanting to lynch to me as his objective for this game sucks for me personally. If he lets it prevail above team inno's win conditions it would be amateurnight. I trust he won't do that if he's scum.
But I have no case on him, apart from him being a lowposter and thus potentially a killer. I do have a case on Morgoth that I will drop if it doesn't rally enough votes for a lynch, but that I want to see through to the end today.

Silencer did what I asked of him, he asked if I was satisfied and i replied that I'd take it at face value. For today, that settles it for me.

You wont vote for silencer even if it means no lynch?

[Gavin]

Tapper, on Oct 22 2008, 05:00 PM, said:

Gavin, on Oct 22 2008, 10:54 AM, said:

So.. current vote count is:

4 votes for Silencer (Jump Around, Lisheo, Morgoth, The Dude)
1 vote for Lisheo (Obdigore)
4 votes Morgoth (Lacedaemonian, Yellow, Tapper, Silencer)

Not sure how we are going to get a lynch really. DKT and I are both to vote that pushes it up to 6. If JA switches we get 7 on Morgoth. If Lace switches (I see you reading) we get 7 on Silencer. Tapper was around that would make 8 if he was willing to switch as well. If not we need to hope someone else shows up in the next two hours that isn't voting for Morgoth.

As I said before I'm happy to vote either.

No, I'm not willing to change targets.
Silencer wanting to lynch to me as his objective for this game sucks for me personally. If he lets it prevail above team inno's win conditions it would be amateurnight. I trust he won't do that if he's scum.
But I have no case on him, apart from him being a lowposter and thus potentially a killer. I do have a case on Morgoth that I will drop if it doesn't rally enough votes for a lynch, but that I want to see through to the end today.

Silencer did what I asked of him, he asked if I was satisfied and i replied that I'd take it at face value. For today, that settles it for me.

So no wanting to vote for someone who has been actiing killerish, and has said the only reason he votes for you is because he has decided thats his objective and he doesn't care if your inno or not? Cos I find that attitude to be particularly bad, hell if he said that Day 1 I'd have voted for him right there, i'm tempted to now actually.


Regardless I find this attitude strange Tapper, killerish strange. Unless you somehow know Silencer is innocent?

[Tapper]

only if you accumulate L-1 votes on Silencer without my help.
Right now, it can still go both ways and I vastly prefer Morgoth, so i'm not going to switch unless it is crystal clear that it is Silencer or no lynch.

[Jump Around]

Well, I have to go for lunch, I should be back before my meeting and deadline.

[Tapper]

Also, I need to change that post of mine. Should be this: italics should change to bold.

Quote

No, I'm not willing to change targets.
Silencer wanting to lynch to me as his objective for this game sucks for me personally. If he lets it prevail above team inno's win conditions it would be amateurnight. I trust he won't do that if he'sscum. should be if he is inno.
But I have no case on him, apart from him being a lowposter and thus potentially a killer. I do have a case on Morgoth that I will drop if it doesn't rally enough votes for a lynch, but that I want to see through to the end today.

Silencer did what I asked of him, he asked if I was satisfied and i replied that I'd take it at face value. For today, that settles it for me.

This post has been edited by Tapper: 22 October 2008 - 09:16 AM

[Tapper]

Also Gavin, you have been steering remarkably clear of both Morgoth's case and my case against him.
I can see how you can think one or both are utter crap, but right now, there is nothing from you on it.

[Tapper]

Anyway, if Silencer's plan to see me lynched is true and he comes up scum, I'm VPI.

This post has been edited by Tapper: 22 October 2008 - 09:16 AM

[Tapper]

Making a lot spelling mistakes, but that's cause I'm on and off the phone and working at the same time. Will take a 30 min break now.

[Gavin]

Tapper, on Oct 22 2008, 05:12 PM, said:

Also Gavin, you have been steering remarkably clear of both Morgoth's case and my case against him.
I can see how you can think one or both are utter crap, but right now, there is nothing from you on it.

Well I don't have really anything to add, I'm not sure about either. We have reached the point where we need a CF on Morgy to
tell us one way or another about him, and then we can go from there. This is why I am willing to lynch Morgoth. The cases haven't added or changed my opinion on that which I wrote in my first post today 6 or 7 hours ago.

[dktorode]

Im not sure wich way to vote...

there has just been ALLOT of attention on morgoth. In a way its might be best to vote him off, firstly he could very well be scum. And if he isnt, there will be allot of people having to answer for there actions with regrads to him.

Silencer lynch gives us fuckall, BUT he is too quiet and bloody well deserves to be lynched just for that alone.

Edit - spelling and cross post

This post has been edited by dktorode: 22 October 2008 - 09:24 AM

[Gavin]

Tapper, on Oct 22 2008, 05:16 PM, said:

Anyway, if Silencer's plan to see me lynched is true and he comes up scum, I'm VPI.

I wouldn't go that far, I'd be inclined to think your trying to create an excuse there to cover up if Silencer does come up guilty.

[Gavin]

dktorode, on Oct 22 2008, 05:23 PM, said:

Im not sure wich way to vote...

there has just been ALLOT of attention on morgoth. In a way its might be best to vote him off, firstly he could very well be scum. And if he isnt, there will be allot of people having to answer for there actions with regrads to him.

Silencer lynch gives us fuckall, BUT he is too quiet and bloody well deserves to be lynched just for that alone.

Edit - spelling and cross post

Our votes don't really matter unless we get someone else new on whose willing to vote one or the other. Lace was reading the thread about half an hour ago but didn't post which is rather annoying.
I'll be around for the lynch so can cast my vote on whatever train needs it. If your going to be around I suggest you hold off as well.

[dktorode]

yea im here all day bud

[dktorode]

Shit...so no matter what...we need another player online?

This will be mafia SIN if we cant get another lynch today....bloody fucking bollocks

[Giles]

Have just finished skimming through, have lectures now will read up properly later
right now
vote morgoth
because it was a choice between him and silencer and i dont think what people have said has really cleared him much in my eyes from the other days

[Jump Around]

back.

Nothing happened? Uuuuuurgh!

[Tapper]

baudin, on Oct 22 2008, 11:52 AM, said:

Have just finished skimming through, have lectures now will read up properly later
right now
vote morgoth
because it was a choice between him and silencer and i dont think what people have said has really cleared him much in my eyes from the other days

That's 5. A morgoth lynch is now possible.