Help
I reckon one of them is BB.
Simply, its stupid for UB to fake silence after silencing someone at night. Surely he knows hed get called up on it.
Therefore, if Galain turns out inno im probably gonna look very closely at Gamelon.
Edit: The question I really want answering is, why hasnt gamelon voted. He started this WHOLE thing. When I asked earlier he said he was "waiting for a reaction, and to look for BB" now this immediately struck me as odd.
As I said earlier, any inno KNOWS he's inno. So if gamelon KNOWS he's inno and silenced, he therefore is CERTAIN galain is scum. So why no vote.
And even now, when Galain has had time to defend himself etc, he still hasnt voted. It just strikes me as incredibly strange.
Mafia 27: The Escape of the Benses (Game Thread)
#922 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:02 PM
Kaschan, could you remove your vote for a minute so that we could just discuss this a little bit. I think we should lynch Galain, but I want to have a quick discussion beforehand and I don't want anyone drive-by voting and effectively killing Galain while we're discussing his survival.
#923 Guest_Serc_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:02 PM
I am back and have caught up.
Why the hell would someone pretend to be silenced? I don't get it at all.
The worst part is, we won't be sure we get UB, at least not for a couple turns after he is dead...
Bah Bah Black sheep, have you any wool...
Why the hell would someone pretend to be silenced? I don't get it at all.
The worst part is, we won't be sure we get UB, at least not for a couple turns after he is dead...
Bah Bah Black sheep, have you any wool...
#924 Guest_Galain_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:04 PM
Telas;376135 said:
Ok, before I vote for Galain, I would like this question answered: Why do some people, especially Gamelon, believe Galain is UB? That makes no sense, unless Gamelon is lying about being silenced. After all, UB knows who's silenced, as he does the silencing. Why would he silence another player and then claim to be silenced himself? Thus, Galain is either BB, or Gamelon is lying.
#925 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:10 PM
Why would Gamelon hold off voting? The reason I interpreted from his pics is because he wants to see our reactions and because he thinks Galain is UB. That makes no sense, Galain can't be UB, as I've said.
So could Gamelon himself be UB - holding off voting because he knows Galain will come up inno and wanting it to seem like that's alright, because Galain is UB anyway. But why do that - because then UB can't use his power again (if he's Gamelon) without exposing the lie, and that effectively makes him useless.
So could Gamelon himself be UB - holding off voting because he knows Galain will come up inno and wanting it to seem like that's alright, because Galain is UB anyway. But why do that - because then UB can't use his power again (if he's Gamelon) without exposing the lie, and that effectively makes him useless.
#926 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:11 PM
Another thing - Gamelon hasn't exactly been a sparkling contributor - why silence him?
#927 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:12 PM
I haven't exactly been the biggest fan of Galain, and I would love it if he turned out to be BB and proved my instincts correct for once, but is it me or do some things not add up here?
#928 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:14 PM
They dont, but the thing is, if Galain comes up inno(since its completely illogical for him to be UB) then Gamelon will obviously be the next target. We just have to hope we get it right.
#929 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:15 PM
Telas;376143 said:
Another thing - Gamelon hasn't exactly been a sparkling contributor - why silence him?
So, neither were you particularly. Seems to me he just picks randoms so that they cant be connected to him.
#930 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:16 PM
Aye, the sensible thing seems to be to lynch one - and if he turns out inno - lynch the other, just like always.
But surely Gamelon of all people should not be thinking that Galain is UB? That just makes me think that he KNOWS Galain will come up inno.
But surely Gamelon of all people should not be thinking that Galain is UB? That just makes me think that he KNOWS Galain will come up inno.
#931 Guest_Galain_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:17 PM
Kaschan;376136 said:
I reckon one of them is BB.
Simply, its stupid for UB to fake silence after silencing someone at night. Surely he knows hed get called up on it.
Therefore, if Galain turns out inno im probably gonna look very closely at Gamelon.
Edit: The question I really want answering is, why hasnt gamelon voted. He started this WHOLE thing. When I asked earlier he said he was "waiting for a reaction, and to look for BB" now this immediately struck me as odd.
As I said earlier, any inno KNOWS he's inno. So if gamelon KNOWS he's inno and silenced, he therefore is CERTAIN galain is scum. So why no vote.
And even now, when Galain has had time to defend himself etc, he still hasnt voted. It just strikes me as incredibly strange.
Simply, its stupid for UB to fake silence after silencing someone at night. Surely he knows hed get called up on it.
Therefore, if Galain turns out inno im probably gonna look very closely at Gamelon.
Edit: The question I really want answering is, why hasnt gamelon voted. He started this WHOLE thing. When I asked earlier he said he was "waiting for a reaction, and to look for BB" now this immediately struck me as odd.
As I said earlier, any inno KNOWS he's inno. So if gamelon KNOWS he's inno and silenced, he therefore is CERTAIN galain is scum. So why no vote.
And even now, when Galain has had time to defend himself etc, he still hasnt voted. It just strikes me as incredibly strange.
vote gamelon
#932 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:19 PM
Serc;376138 said:
I am back and have caught up.
Why the hell would someone pretend to be silenced? I don't get it at all.
The worst part is, we won't be sure we get UB, at least not for a couple turns after he is dead...
Bah Bah Black sheep, have you any wool...
Why the hell would someone pretend to be silenced? I don't get it at all.
The worst part is, we won't be sure we get UB, at least not for a couple turns after he is dead...
Bah Bah Black sheep, have you any wool...
I thought that wasnt PC these days...
#933 Guest_Galain_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:20 PM
Telas;376147 said:
Aye, the sensible thing seems to be to lynch one - and if he turns out inno - lynch the other, just like always.
But surely Gamelon of all people should not be thinking that Galain is UB? That just makes me think that he KNOWS Galain will come up inno.
But surely Gamelon of all people should not be thinking that Galain is UB? That just makes me think that he KNOWS Galain will come up inno.
#934 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:22 PM
Fener;375988 said:
well then
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
Man, that Khellendros. I can't decide whether he's the best or the worst thing to happen to Malazan Mafia.
#935 Guest_Galain_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:24 PM
#936 Guest_Serc_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:25 PM
vote gamelon
He is super sick, not able to contribute, but once we start voting for him he can? Then, even though he is one of the lowerst contributors, he gets silenced?
I'm not buying it.
He is super sick, not able to contribute, but once we start voting for him he can? Then, even though he is one of the lowerst contributors, he gets silenced?
I'm not buying it.
#937 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:28 PM
If UB is NOT one of these players (and if he is he can only be Gamelon), but BB is, doesn't it actually make more sense that it would be Gamelon again? As he and UB can't communicate, wouldn't he wait to make sure no one else was silenced before faking being silenced?
Edit: And then, seeing someone else was silenced, attempting to frame them?
Edit: And then, seeing someone else was silenced, attempting to frame them?
#938 Guest_Telas_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:29 PM
I'm sorry, I'd love to vote for Galain, but this is all weird and I could be badly wrong, but
Vote Gamelon
Vote Gamelon
#939 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:29 PM
The more I think the more I suspect Gamelon.
For now I will stick by Galain, but I reckon you def. have a point.
For now I will stick by Galain, but I reckon you def. have a point.
#940 Guest_Serc_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 08:29 PM
Well, who was the first to post silenced? Galain or Gamelon?
I thought it was Gamelon, which would mean Galain 'pretending' to be silenced is idiotic.
I thought it was Gamelon, which would mean Galain 'pretending' to be silenced is idiotic.
