Help
I'm here. Catching up.
Mafia 27: The Escape of the Benses (Game Thread)
#822 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:24 PM
Now THATS interesting.
Both silenced.
That means at least one is faking, and one of them is evil.
There are two ways I think are likely this is:
Galain is evil and Gamelon is revealing his silence to show Galain isnt.
Gamelon is evil and is trying to force a lynch on Galain.
Personally I reckon its Galain.
Why would Gamelon fake silenced just to show up Galain, when, if Galain showed inno, there is a large chance of him being lynched.
Edit: I also think whiever is evil is probably BB. I mean, why would UB fake silence when he KNOWS that he has silenced someone else. Its just foolish.
Both silenced.
That means at least one is faking, and one of them is evil.
There are two ways I think are likely this is:
Galain is evil and Gamelon is revealing his silence to show Galain isnt.
Gamelon is evil and is trying to force a lynch on Galain.
Personally I reckon its Galain.
Why would Gamelon fake silenced just to show up Galain, when, if Galain showed inno, there is a large chance of him being lynched.
Edit: I also think whiever is evil is probably BB. I mean, why would UB fake silence when he KNOWS that he has silenced someone else. Its just foolish.
#823 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:24 PM
wtf?
so, one of the two must be faking
interesting
Since Galain was all uppity about Telas "faking it" yest, i'd beinclined to think it was his idea.
so, one of the two must be faking
interesting
Since Galain was all uppity about Telas "faking it" yest, i'd beinclined to think it was his idea.
#824 Guest_Gamelon_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:24 PM
Kaschan;375973 said:
On another note, Gamelon, care to tell the reason for the vote?
#825 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:24 PM
cross-post with Kaschan
now, the question is, would it be UB or BB that would pull such a stunt?
now, the question is, would it be UB or BB that would pull such a stunt?
#826 Guest_Gamelon_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:25 PM
fener;375980 said:
since galain was all uppity about telas "faking it" yest, i'd beinclined to think it was his idea.
#827 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:25 PM
@ Gamelon
you thought he was BB
and, if you may, use smaller piccies..
you thought he was BB
and, if you may, use smaller piccies..
#830 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:28 PM
well then
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
#831 Guest_Liosan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:29 PM
What the...two players silenced? :confused:
I need to read more, but I just wanted to say that I have no qualms lynching silenced players - if they're suspicious enough. Also, I think maybe the Gamelon vote yesterday needs discussing. I'm gonna read some more now.
I need to read more, but I just wanted to say that I have no qualms lynching silenced players - if they're suspicious enough. Also, I think maybe the Gamelon vote yesterday needs discussing. I'm gonna read some more now.
#832 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:32 PM
Ok then. Im certian one is BB(why would UB fake knowing someone was silenced), and am more inclined to believe its Galain.
His accusing Telas of faking it thing.
He was the first to claim silence. Almost immediately. Gamelons seems more like a counter-reveal.
I reckon theres more reason for Galain to fake it. Why would Gamelon, knowing Galain was already silenced.
He hasnt contributed much, neither have, but Gamelon claims a reason at least.
Therefore:
Vote Galain
This is one of those cases where I am fine with lynching someone silenced. Because, even if we unfortuneately hit an inno, we will get an evil the next day. I reckon theres more chance Galain is evil, so am voting him, which will hopefully prevent losing an inno. If hes inno, then Gamelon, you're next.
His accusing Telas of faking it thing.
He was the first to claim silence. Almost immediately. Gamelons seems more like a counter-reveal.
I reckon theres more reason for Galain to fake it. Why would Gamelon, knowing Galain was already silenced.
He hasnt contributed much, neither have, but Gamelon claims a reason at least.
Therefore:
Vote Galain
This is one of those cases where I am fine with lynching someone silenced. Because, even if we unfortuneately hit an inno, we will get an evil the next day. I reckon theres more chance Galain is evil, so am voting him, which will hopefully prevent losing an inno. If hes inno, then Gamelon, you're next.
#833 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:33 PM
Fener;375988 said:
well then
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
Kaschan, Liosan, suggestions?
I'm willling to vote fro Galain right now, although of course it'd be interesting to see what his rebuttal would be.
And may god have mersy on his soul if he's decided to pull another Khellendros...
If he is I will be going for him for meta reasons in many games to come...
#834 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:34 PM
heh
there are problems with doing that, but in this case, I don't feel much pity for Galain.
While this is getting kinda close to WIFOM, it may also explain why Telas was silenced Yeterday--he was all up on Galain's case Day 1, it may have been done to shut him up--which it did, kinda nicely, since instead everyone went looking @ Gamelon, and then HP.
As for the why do this now--I think BB may have taken a gamble in trying ot get some roled players to reveal to clear Gamelon who was under suspicion yesterday.... Wait, that only works if he KNEW that Gamelon would be the one silenced. And since there's no off-thread comms b/w the Benses, that'd mean he's UB... not that I have a problem with voting off a possible UB. After all, scum is scum.
there are problems with doing that, but in this case, I don't feel much pity for Galain.
While this is getting kinda close to WIFOM, it may also explain why Telas was silenced Yeterday--he was all up on Galain's case Day 1, it may have been done to shut him up--which it did, kinda nicely, since instead everyone went looking @ Gamelon, and then HP.
As for the why do this now--I think BB may have taken a gamble in trying ot get some roled players to reveal to clear Gamelon who was under suspicion yesterday.... Wait, that only works if he KNEW that Gamelon would be the one silenced. And since there's no off-thread comms b/w the Benses, that'd mean he's UB... not that I have a problem with voting off a possible UB. After all, scum is scum.
#835 Guest_Fener_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:36 PM
cross posts all around
It would be gutsy for BB to "claim" silenced, so I'm not quite sure Galain's BB. But, hell, if he is, all the better.
anyhoo
vote Galain
and let's see where this will go
It would be gutsy for BB to "claim" silenced, so I'm not quite sure Galain's BB. But, hell, if he is, all the better.
anyhoo
vote Galain
and let's see where this will go
#836 Guest_Gamelon_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:38 PM
#838 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:39 PM
Ah, you reckon UB is doing it to get roles to reveal?
Seems kinda strange, after all, normally when its a choice between two both are killed unless the first turns out evil.
The annoyance with the possibilty of it being UB is that if we do lynch one, and it turns out inno, we have to get the other, as we wouldnt know.
Seems kinda strange, after all, normally when its a choice between two both are killed unless the first turns out evil.
The annoyance with the possibilty of it being UB is that if we do lynch one, and it turns out inno, we have to get the other, as we wouldnt know.
#839 Guest_Kaschan_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:41 PM
Its also possible BB gambled to try get a reveal, knowing he could still win. Although with so many people left I doubt it.
#840 Guest_Gamelon_*
Posted 28 August 2008 - 04:42 PM
Path-Shaper;375932 said:
This is day 3. 27 hours and a half left in the day.
