Abyss, on 19 June 2017 - 03:33 PM, said:
polishgenius, on 19 June 2017 - 03:26 PM, said:
...
I've cottoned on to what Yoon Ha Lee's series reminds me of. If you took the weirder parts of Faith by John Love and built an entire interstellar empire on those principles, Machineries of Empire is a lot what it would look like....
SOLD.
...related aside, still annoyed at what a mess Love's second book Evensong was....
Ha, I thought you might like that description.
Lee does dump you into a chaotic and extremely weird world with very few explanations, but I can't imagine a Malazan fan will be bothered by that. I don't think it's as obtuse as, say, Quantum Thief's world, if only because while the means and motivations behind doing certain things are obscure, the actual things themselves are a bit more straightforward (to whit: space battles! Also: ground battles!).
I appreciated Evensong as a flawed-but-worthy attempt to do a twist on the cyberpunky-noir-agent thing but looking back it did meander and the very ending was unsatisfying (although the climactic bit just before that very ending was fine).
Andorion, on 19 June 2017 - 03:51 PM, said:
I loved Tchaikovsky's ending more in the sense that he went in a very unconventional way I absolutely did not expect. Vinge focussed more on the weirdness of the planet and the strange behaviours it encouraged, but Tchaikovsky went deeper into biology and social psychology and his long term approach really elevated the book.
If you haven't read it, I urge you to read Helliconia. It's not quite the same because (1) it's centered on humans, on a very alien world (orbiting a binary star, leading to century-long seasons, the central principle behind it) and (2) it's not tracking the evolution of anything from the start, but it has a similar epically long-term structure and deep focus on scientific exploration of what life in a place like that would mean.
I've been meandering through a re-read actually, mostly because I never quite finished the third book (it's a monster as a complete cycle, and I didn't take enough breaks, so I sorta burned out). Good stuff.
I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you.