Page 1 of 1
Questions...
#1 Guest_grrmfan100_*
Posted 07 August 2005 - 09:26 PM
I'm halfway through Deadhouse Gates, but there are a couple of things about GOFTM that I'm puzzled about. (OK, more than a couple, but these are the big things...)
1. Why was Hairlock in the story? Quick Ben obviously takes great pleasure in destroying him. But Ben preserved Hairlock's life originally by transferring him to the puppet (and what was up with *that*?). Why did Ben do this?
2. Why did Cotillion, when he possessed Apsalar, kill a village full of innocent fisher-folk?
3. While we're on that, I'm unclear as to why Lorn and Paran seem to have forgotten all about investigating Sorry once Paran is taken over by Oponn. (Have I got any of this right?)
If anyone has a take on these questions, I'd appreciate the help.
If I'm just not paying enough attention, or if all will be explained later in the saga, it's OK to just tell me that. (Politely, of course.)
Thanks!
1. Why was Hairlock in the story? Quick Ben obviously takes great pleasure in destroying him. But Ben preserved Hairlock's life originally by transferring him to the puppet (and what was up with *that*?). Why did Ben do this?
2. Why did Cotillion, when he possessed Apsalar, kill a village full of innocent fisher-folk?
3. While we're on that, I'm unclear as to why Lorn and Paran seem to have forgotten all about investigating Sorry once Paran is taken over by Oponn. (Have I got any of this right?)
If anyone has a take on these questions, I'd appreciate the help.
If I'm just not paying enough attention, or if all will be explained later in the saga, it's OK to just tell me that. (Politely, of course.)
Thanks!
#2
Posted 07 August 2005 - 10:19 PM
1: QB takes pleasure in destroying Hairlock due to hairlock becoming to powerfull and unpredictable. he was delving too far into chaos to control proberly and causing more problem for QB rather than helping investigate tays and the rest of the people who were trying to destroy the BB
2: the killing of all the people by the hounds was done by shadowthrone not the rope. the reasons for that aren't really explained other than to be said to be a diversion for the possesion of sorry
2: the killing of all the people by the hounds was done by shadowthrone not the rope. the reasons for that aren't really explained other than to be said to be a diversion for the possesion of sorry
#3
Posted 08 August 2005 - 05:09 AM
i think the village was destroyed because shadowthorne and cotillion wanted to cover the tracks of their house and their actions
#4
Posted 08 August 2005 - 04:41 PM
using the hounds of shaddow to kill all those people kind of gave it away that it was them that had done it. and it was easy enough for the adjuct to find out that 2 people disapeared after the slaughter
#5
Posted 09 August 2005 - 01:10 AM
only we knew it was the hounds of shadow, otherwise there was no proof. i mean it looked like they were torn apart by animals, but otherthen that there was nothing.
also this was basically where we first met paran the soldier right? i think it was important that we associate paran with the hounds
also this was basically where we first met paran the soldier right? i think it was important that we associate paran with the hounds
#6
Posted 09 August 2005 - 06:30 PM
1. Quick Ben transferred hairlock to the puppet due to a deal struck between the two... hairlock seemed to know or at least suspect tays plan to destroy teh old gaurd and so struck a deal with quick to avoid death, he'd serve quick in his puppet form and investigate stuff for him in return for not being killed. hairlock then went out of control and quick takes great pleasure in removing his untrustworthy ally...
2. The killing of the hounds was to worry lasseen and hide the tracks of the possesion. this probably would have worked save for Lorn who was familliar with the cast of the mind of mages and so realised that there was a track to follow... Of course a suspicious mind would wonder whether the possesion attempt was meant to succeed... for example if apsalar really wished to assasinate the empress why go to genabackis about as far away from the empress as she could get, and theres some further little titbits revealed in DhG, somehow don't think the wheels within wheels in shadowthrones mind will ever be got to the bottom of.
3. I'm not sure what you mean about investigating sorry... paran and lorns job was to locate her and then kill her... paran was killed before he could do anything and by the time lorn was in a position to do anything sorry had been de-possesed
2. The killing of the hounds was to worry lasseen and hide the tracks of the possesion. this probably would have worked save for Lorn who was familliar with the cast of the mind of mages and so realised that there was a track to follow... Of course a suspicious mind would wonder whether the possesion attempt was meant to succeed... for example if apsalar really wished to assasinate the empress why go to genabackis about as far away from the empress as she could get, and theres some further little titbits revealed in DhG, somehow don't think the wheels within wheels in shadowthrones mind will ever be got to the bottom of.
3. I'm not sure what you mean about investigating sorry... paran and lorns job was to locate her and then kill her... paran was killed before he could do anything and by the time lorn was in a position to do anything sorry had been de-possesed
#7 Guest_Klipper_*
Posted 12 August 2005 - 01:40 AM
1. Hairlock was supposed to investigate a few things. But then he got out of control so Quick Ben had to destroy himto protect the warrns from further damage.
2. He killed them for a number of reasons. Zero Wittnesses, weakens laseen, and a devertion to help cover up the tracks of Sorry being posessed.
3. Paran Hated Lorn Remember thats why he was distracted. Lorn had lost track of sorry after she was released from the rope's grip. That and she died before she could get to Sorry.
2. He killed them for a number of reasons. Zero Wittnesses, weakens laseen, and a devertion to help cover up the tracks of Sorry being posessed.
3. Paran Hated Lorn Remember thats why he was distracted. Lorn had lost track of sorry after she was released from the rope's grip. That and she died before she could get to Sorry.
#8 Guest_diamonium_*
Posted 20 August 2005 - 12:21 PM
1. Ben and Hairlock and Kalam, as far I remember the whole Bridgeburners group wanted Laseen revenged. Hairlock was the tool.
#9
Posted 28 August 2005 - 10:52 PM
S P O I L E R Warning!
Apsalar was going to assassainate Laseen only after she becomes the Sha'ik Reborn and drags the Empress all the way to Seven Cities. Fiddler says in DG that the Rope-possessed Sorry would never be suceed in killing Laseen, with the Claw and the Adjunct's Otataral sword. I am begining to think like this:
Rope and Shadowthrone killed the whole regiment ad send Sorry to Genabackis in order to make sure that te Adjunct FINDS OUT about the possession, witch would send her flying to Darujhistan, straight into Rake's hands. Then, Rope de-possessed Sorry deliberately, knowing that the Bridgeburners would send her home via the Seven Cities. There, on their way to Tremorlor (the fastest transport) they come across Iskaral Pust and his Servant which is Sorry's father. She is lead to become the Sha'ik Reborn, leads the rebellion and draws the Empress herself to Seven cities. There, she kills her with her god-given powers.
Am I good, or what? Just a joke
Apsalar was going to assassainate Laseen only after she becomes the Sha'ik Reborn and drags the Empress all the way to Seven Cities. Fiddler says in DG that the Rope-possessed Sorry would never be suceed in killing Laseen, with the Claw and the Adjunct's Otataral sword. I am begining to think like this:
Rope and Shadowthrone killed the whole regiment ad send Sorry to Genabackis in order to make sure that te Adjunct FINDS OUT about the possession, witch would send her flying to Darujhistan, straight into Rake's hands. Then, Rope de-possessed Sorry deliberately, knowing that the Bridgeburners would send her home via the Seven Cities. There, on their way to Tremorlor (the fastest transport) they come across Iskaral Pust and his Servant which is Sorry's father. She is lead to become the Sha'ik Reborn, leads the rebellion and draws the Empress herself to Seven cities. There, she kills her with her god-given powers.
Am I good, or what? Just a joke

And one by one the gardens died
#10
Posted 29 August 2005 - 12:41 AM
Dude...all that you write contradicts everything we've been told...just read on
<div align='center'>You must always strive to be the best, but you must never believe that you are - Juan Manuel Fangio</div>
#11 Guest_Klipper_*
Posted 30 August 2005 - 04:26 AM
SPOILER
Aspler dosn't become Sha'ik reborn. Get the book strait.
Aspler dosn't become Sha'ik reborn. Get the book strait.
#12
Posted 30 August 2005 - 09:48 AM
Klipper said:
SPOILER
Aspler dosn't become Sha'ik reborn. Get the book strait.
Aspler dosn't become Sha'ik reborn. Get the book strait.
Maybe not, but its possible that was just a cock-up

O xein', angellein Lakedaimoniois hoti têde; keimetha tois keinon rhémasi peithomenoi.
#13
Posted 30 August 2005 - 03:07 PM
caladanbrood said:
Maybe not, but its possible that was just a cock-up
Nothing goes to plan in these books;)


<div align='center'>You must always strive to be the best, but you must never believe that you are - Juan Manuel Fangio</div>
#14
Posted 24 September 2005 - 08:54 AM
I am rereading GOTM right now, and I am also puzzled by the massacre of the village at the start. Totally unnecessary and even detrimental to the plans of Shadowthrone and the Rope. They could've just taken the fisher girl and that's it...no one would've cared much about it, certainly the Adjunct would have never been involved.
Also did Lorn really intend to try to kill a girl possessed by The Rope on her own? Is she suicidal or what? She doesn't have even a glimmer of a chance, Otataral sword or not.
Also did Lorn really intend to try to kill a girl possessed by The Rope on her own? Is she suicidal or what? She doesn't have even a glimmer of a chance, Otataral sword or not.
#15
Posted 26 September 2005 - 07:21 AM
'Eager, are we? Then go!'
Silently, the Hounds bolted down the road.
Their master turned and said to the man beside her, 'Something to gnaw on Laseen's mind.' He giggled again.
'Must you complicate things?' the other answered wearily.
this suggests, at least to me, that dancer wanted to piss laseen off, and kellnaved knew it wasent gonna be helpful but was basically just like, ya whatever.
Silently, the Hounds bolted down the road.
Their master turned and said to the man beside her, 'Something to gnaw on Laseen's mind.' He giggled again.
'Must you complicate things?' the other answered wearily.
this suggests, at least to me, that dancer wanted to piss laseen off, and kellnaved knew it wasent gonna be helpful but was basically just like, ya whatever.
#16
Posted 26 September 2005 - 04:25 PM
Er actually it's kelvanned who wanted to piss lasseen off and dancer didn't, kel is the insane one after all...
#18
Posted 26 September 2005 - 08:03 PM
CountChocula said:
'Eager, are we? Then go!'
Silently, the Hounds bolted down the road.
Their master turned and said to the man beside her, 'Something to gnaw on Laseen's mind.' He giggled again.
'Must you complicate things?' the other answered wearily.
this suggests, at least to me, that dancer wanted to piss laseen off, and kellnaved knew it wasent gonna be helpful but was basically just like, ya whatever.
Silently, the Hounds bolted down the road.
Their master turned and said to the man beside her, 'Something to gnaw on Laseen's mind.' He giggled again.
'Must you complicate things?' the other answered wearily.
this suggests, at least to me, that dancer wanted to piss laseen off, and kellnaved knew it wasent gonna be helpful but was basically just like, ya whatever.
Lol, only Erikson could predict the criticisms that would come and address them so well.
#19
Posted 26 September 2005 - 08:33 PM
So that's pretty much explained. Still I can't understand why Lorn would be so confident she'd be able to kill The Rope. Maybe she was just suicidal.
#20
Posted 26 September 2005 - 08:36 PM
thing that bugs me is they call her laseen. i mean, first, they knew her as surly for waaaaay longer, and i dunno, the name laseen is like a barb against kell
Share this topic:
Page 1 of 1