[bubba]

Fuck it... I think Gnaw is playing us


vote Gnaw

[Vengeance]

It is now day 2

Alive : Bubba,EM,Gnaw,SBS523,
26 hours and 19 minutes

It takes 3 to lynch and 3 to go to night.

1 vote for Gnaw (Bubba)

[Gnaw]

Schmarbs523, on 17 October 2014 - 04:48 PM, said:

Bubba, on 17 October 2014 - 04:24 PM, said:

Kuk having had 4 players is fucking up every attempt I make at figuring out this game..GRRRRRRRR

I could see this going any number of ways. Clearly the teams don't have to be completely balanced. Kuk was a team of 4. I'd say there's an ever so slight chance they had more than 4 but it's doubtful. That leaves 7 players unaccounted for. If there's a rogue predator in the game then that leaves 6 players for two teams. It could break down for two teams of 3 or even possibly a team of 4 and a team of 2. But as far as I know, there doesn't have to be a rogue predator. So then it could be a team of 4 and a team of 3. Such a conundrum.

Back from store.

11 players started. My assumption was 3 teams of 3 and two rogues. But Tatt's CF shows us there were 4 Kuk

So, 2 teams of 3 + 1 of 4 == 10 + rogue == 11

Or, 2 teams of 4 + 1 of 3 and 0 rogue == 11. ??? Which would mean I didn't kill my clan's chances when I offed Messremb. Hmmm.

[bubba]

Gnaw, on 17 October 2014 - 05:16 PM, said:

Schmarbs523, on 17 October 2014 - 04:48 PM, said:

Bubba, on 17 October 2014 - 04:24 PM, said:

Kuk having had 4 players is fucking up every attempt I make at figuring out this game..GRRRRRRRR

I could see this going any number of ways. Clearly the teams don't have to be completely balanced. Kuk was a team of 4. I'd say there's an ever so slight chance they had more than 4 but it's doubtful. That leaves 7 players unaccounted for. If there's a rogue predator in the game then that leaves 6 players for two teams. It could break down for two teams of 3 or even possibly a team of 4 and a team of 2. But as far as I know, there doesn't have to be a rogue predator. So then it could be a team of 4 and a team of 3. Such a conundrum.

Back from store.

11 players started. My assumption was 3 teams of 3 and two rogues. But Tatt's CF shows us there were 4 Kuk

So, 2 teams of 3 + 1 of 4 == 10 + rogue == 11

Or, 2 teams of 4 + 1 of 3 and 0 rogue == 11. ??? Which would mean I didn't kill my clan's chances when I offed Messremb. Hmmm.

Staring really hard at you with my avatar....

[Gnaw]

From my notes last night:

Quote

11 players.

3 clans of 3 members Kuk, Duk, Bak

• Healer 1 kill / 1 find
• Finder 1 kill
• Youth 1 BP 1 NIGHT kill / 1 find can upgrade to 1 normal kill / 1 heal / 1 extra find
• Killer 1 find
• One class not present

2 Rogue

• 1 BP
• 1 reactionary NIGHT BP

Mess present 10:25
Khell present 10:29
Unfound present 10:36
Obdigore present 10:39 am

Vengeance update. 10:44 am
Khell is dead he was a member of Clan Kuk.
The Unfound is dead he was a member of Clan Duk



Possible killers: Mess, Khell, UnF, Obdi.
(WCS has Khell and UnF killng each other)

Gust Hubb present 11:02
SBS present 11:04

Vengy update 11:09
Gust Hubb is dead he was a member of clan Kuk
Possible killers: Mess, Obdi, SBS


WCS: 2 kills still available

Inane present: 12:43 pm
EM present: 1:17

Vengy update 1:28
Inane Babble is dead he was a member of Clan Kuk
Possible killers: Mess, Obdi, SBS, EM (Mess accuses EM, EM claims)


WCS: 2 kills still available

Not present: Bubba, Gnaw, Tatts

WCS: 4 kills available. (not counting mine of course.


BCS:

• Khell and UnF did not use their kills. Mess and Obdi have both used theirs.
• SBS killed GH
• EM killed Inane.
• zero kills available in 'present' players

Assume Khell and/or UnF targeted Mess or Obdi -> Mess/Obdi is either Killer, Youth, or Rogue


Bak
Bak
Bak
Duk
Duk
Rogue
Rogue

SWAG: Bak == Mess, EM, Tatts

Deathbringer the Adorable, on 16 October 2014 - 05:22 PM, said:

Messremb, on 16 October 2014 - 05:21 PM, said:

EmperorMagus, on 16 October 2014 - 05:17 PM, said:

Hey morons.
How you doing imbeciles?

Fine thanks, how fare the lilly-livered?

Good you tatt looking piece of mafia scum.

[Schmarbs523]

Bubba, on 17 October 2014 - 04:59 PM, said:

Fuck it... I think Gnaw is playing us


vote Gnaw

As much as I want to believe you, I'm waiting to cast any votes until EM chimes in, be it to refute your find on him or to lend a supporting find on Gnaw, you, or me.

[Gnaw]

Quote

Bubba present 10:04 pm
gnaw present 10:59 pm

Vengy update 11:06 pm
Messremb is dead he was a member of clan Bak.
Killer was gnaw (and lkfhg hgkhg)

Tatts present 01:42 am

Vengy update 8:24
Obdigore is dead he was a member of clan Bak.
double a;rgh athg pajef'g

Possible killers: EM, SBS, Bubba, Tatts,

goes to night on votes. 9:19
no fatalities during night. day starts 9:22
time gap suggests a double checking of orders, so maybe someone did a find?

vengy update 9:42
Tattersail is dead he was a member of clan Kuk

Hmmm. 4 kuks. means one of them was a youth. so had a BPs to eat through.


2 Duks and Me plus rogue. Or 2 Baks???

[Gnaw]

Kuk had 4 people. That means a Killer and a Youth i.e. BPs. So it took 6 kills (or finds) to get them all.

[Gnaw]

Mess present 10:25
Khell present 10:29
Unfound present 10:36
Obdigore present 10:39 am

Vengeance update. 10:44 am
Khell is dead he was a member of Clan Kuk.
The Unfound is dead he was a member of Clan Duk



Possible killers: Mess, Khell, UnF, Obdi.
(WCS has Khell and UnF killng each other)

Gust Hubb present 11:02
SBS present 11:04

Vengy update 11:09
Gust Hubb is dead he was a member of clan Kuk
Possible killers: Mess, Obdi, SBS


SBS is claiming he did a find last night. So he's out of the running for GH's death. (Assuming we believe him.)

[Gnaw]

Bubba, on 17 October 2014 - 05:20 PM, said:

Gnaw, on 17 October 2014 - 05:16 PM, said:

Schmarbs523, on 17 October 2014 - 04:48 PM, said:

Bubba, on 17 October 2014 - 04:24 PM, said:

Kuk having had 4 players is fucking up every attempt I make at figuring out this game..GRRRRRRRR

I could see this going any number of ways. Clearly the teams don't have to be completely balanced. Kuk was a team of 4. I'd say there's an ever so slight chance they had more than 4 but it's doubtful. That leaves 7 players unaccounted for. If there's a rogue predator in the game then that leaves 6 players for two teams. It could break down for two teams of 3 or even possibly a team of 4 and a team of 2. But as far as I know, there doesn't have to be a rogue predator. So then it could be a team of 4 and a team of 3. Such a conundrum.

Back from store.

11 players started. My assumption was 3 teams of 3 and two rogues. But Tatt's CF shows us there were 4 Kuk

So, 2 teams of 3 + 1 of 4 == 10 + rogue == 11

Or, 2 teams of 4 + 1 of 3 and 0 rogue == 11. ??? Which would mean I didn't kill my clan's chances when I offed Messremb. Hmmm.

Staring really hard at you with my avatar....

You outed EM as Duk. If you're telling the truth, then you're presumably Bak. And you killed no-one yesterday.

[Gnaw]

Gnaw, on 17 October 2014 - 05:40 PM, said:

You outed EM as Duk. If you're telling the truth, then you're presumably Bak. And you killed no-one yesterday.

And that would in turn mean that SBS is Duk.

[Gnaw]

IF Myself, Bubba and SBS are telling the truth, then we're at 2 Bak and 2 Duk.

IF Myself and Bubba are telling the truth, then we're at 2 Bak and 2 Duk with SBS lying about finding.

IF Bubba and SBS are telling the truth with my lying, then we're at 1 Bak (Bubba), 2 Duk, and Me being Bak or Rogue depending.

IF Myself and SBS are telling the truth with Bubba lying then we're at 1 Bak (me), 2 Duk, and Bubba being Bak or Rogue.

[Gnaw]

So who killed tatts?


Vote EM

[Gnaw]

Aw shit.

IF Bubba and SBS are both lying, then odds are they're both Duk.


Remove Vote

[EmperorMagus]

Vote Gnaw

I'm the Duk finder.

[Gnaw]

So 2 duks vs Bubba and I


Vote EM

[Gnaw]

Bubba, we lose regardless of what we are if either of us is lynched.

[Schmarbs523]

I'm a little concerned right now. Did you do a find last night, EM?

But for now: vote Gnaw

[Schmarbs523]

Actually

remove vote

I truly think that If there's a rogue predator left, I think it's Bubba.

[Schmarbs523]

Meh, screw it.

vote Gnaw