Ok, Caught up. Fuck yeah Tiam! Great job! second, @shadow...nah nah nah nah boo boo, stick your head in doo doo.
So on the read up I have a few thoughts. First being this post by Hanas. Holy hell, can you say wishy washy. Let me paraphrase; "I could go shadow, or I could go cast, or I could go whoever is most likely not my master" I know he can't be a killer, but based on this post he has rocketed up to Shadow levels of being on my symp scumdar.
Hanas, on 07 June 2013 - 02:53 PM, said:
Karatallid, on 07 June 2013 - 01:36 PM, said:
Atrahal, on 07 June 2013 - 01:26 PM, said:
Karatallid, on 07 June 2013 - 01:22 PM, said:
Hmmm, been a fairly quiet day so far. So who we looking at today?
A few seem to think Cast is supicious and possibly GL's symp. I am thinking Shadow's play is very defensive and could lead to scum. Have a read, we got a scum CF, form your own opinion.
Although the scum CF is great, that doesn't help us pick out the second scum. We're basically shooting blindly again. Gonna have to look for anyone symping GL to try to tie that person to a 2nd potential scum, methinks.
We're not as blind as we were. I think that we should go to freeze. That way those of us who want can go back to the front and do a re-read.
I could maybe go for Shadow today but I can't decide whether that's because he decided I could be the symp or because he's been all over the place.
Or maybe Cast. But for now I buy (barely) his explanation that he thought Tiam was a fake reveal.
I like Korlat's post in regards to Cast. Though I see him more as a killer type than a symp. Cast had played rather low key until his name was brought up and now he is posting much more. That is fishy and it's the same thing that happened last game.
Here's a pet project of mine that I will research if I have the time. Day 1 Shadow and Desra got into a pissing match. I initially blew it off as a 2 inno, day 1 BS. But since then, they have had relatively little interaction and Desra has basically faded into the woodwork. Could the day one feud have been staged by shadow in an effort to distance from his killer? It's a risky strategy in that he risks a night kill night one, but if he can avoid that, they have a perfect out for not being connected. Like I said, I haven't fleshed it out, but in my experience. Usually day 1 head butting continues until one person is lynched and that usually happens quickly. Why didn't that happen here?
I have no real read on Karatallid which is a bit scary. I initially had him as town in my notes based off some day one interactions...but thats always a bit of a stretch. HP has been playing very under the radar. Always hanging around the thread and popping off posts that comment on others, but very rarely ruffle feathers or attack someone. Atrahal has put in some good effort, but it seems that effort was after Cast started getting heat. So I could maybe see a connection there. But he is more likely town imo Korlat is playing pretty town like in my eyes. Throwing around cases. Maybe a symp, but probably not a killer. Like I said Earlier Hanas' post really threw me and if shadow isn't the symp, then I think Hanas is and I need to go look back at Hanas' interactions. Am I missing anyone? If so..they are probably the Killer
Honestly, I'd like a Desra lynch but doubt that will get any traction until I bring more to the table. I just won't have time to really get down and dirty with it until around Monday. Probably it will come down to shadow or Cast and I think I am leaning towards cast. A Cast lynch would help establish if he is/isn't a killer and it would shed some light, for me anyway, on shadow as I believe that if cast comes back inno that Shadow is a good symp possibility and we can look for people who fit a killer profile that shadow hasn't implicated in anything. Off the top of my head, that list will be pretty small. I am not sure I want to waste a lynch on shadow this early as I think he has been playing to fast and loose to be the remaining killer.
Help
