[Gnaw]

hmm looks like STD is negotiating his price,

[Adjudicator]

EM, STD we are waiting on you two.

[Sir Thursday]

Gah, I thought I'd sent the message saying I was on holiday last week...will get some orders in ASAP.

ST

[Adjudicator]

Austria Orders

Spoiler

F AEG S F SMY-CON
A SER-BUL
A GAL-SIL
A BOH S A GAL-SIL
A BUD-VIE

[Adjudicator]

Results for Fall, 1904 (Movement)

General Notices:
All dislodged units destroyed; advancing to next phase.Order
resolution completed on 28-Jan-2013 at 20:30:03 PST

Order Results:

Austria:
Austria: F aeg Supports F smy - con Support failed. Supported unit's order does not match support given.
Austria: A boh Supports A gal - sil
Austria: A bud - vie
Austria: A gal - si
lAustria: A ser - bul

England:
England: A den - lvn No Convoy route.
England: A fin - stp Bounced with stp (2 against 2).
England: F kie - ber Failed because Germany: A ber - sil failed.
England: F nth Convoys A yor - den
England: F nwy Supports A fin -; stp
England: F swe - bot
England: A yor - den Failed because England: A den - lvn failed. Convoy path taken: yor→nth→den.

France:
France: A bur Supports A mun
France: A gas - spa
France: A hol Supports F kie Support failed. Move orders must be supported explicitly.
France: F mar - lyo
France: A mun Holds
France: A ruh Supports A mun
France: F spa/sc - wes

Germany:
No order for unit at Baltic Sea. Hold order assigned.No order for unit at Prussia. Hold order assigned.Germany: F bal Holds
Germany: A ber - sil Bounced with gal (1 against 1).
Germany: F pru Holds

Italy:
Italy: F ion - gre Bounced with bul (1 against 1).
Italy: F smy Holds
Italy: A syr Supports F smy
Italy: A tyr Holds
Italy: F tys Holds

Russia:Russia: A lvn Supports A stp
Russia: F rum Supports A ser - bul
Russia: A stp Holds
Russia: A ukr - war

Turkey:
The Army in Bulgaria cannot retreat; unit destroyed.
Turkey: A bul - gre Bounced with ion (1 against 1). Dislodged from ser (2 against 1).
Turkey: A con - bul Bounced with ser (1 against 1).
Turkey: F eas - ion Failed because Italy: F ion - gre failed.

This post has been edited by Adjudicator: 30 January 2013 - 02:45 PM

[Adjudicator]

So I need peoples opinions on something. Here were Gnaws orders

German fleet convoys british army denmark to StP
German fleet Livonia supports British army Denmark
German army Berlin -> Silesia

So as submitted they were not valid orders. But the intent of the orders were clear that he intended to convoy the English army in Denmark to the mainland and support to the mainland. So do I adjust the orders per the intent or do I leave them as he submitted.

The results of the resolution change drastically one way versus the other.

[Tapper]

Adjudicator, on 29 January 2013 - 04:39 AM, said:

So I need peoples opinions on something. Here were Gnaws orders

German fleet convoys british army denmark to StP
German fleet Livonia supports British army Denmark
German army Berlin -> Silesia

So as submitted they were not valid orders. But the intent of the orders were clear that he intended to convoy the English army in Denmark to the mainland and support to the mainland. So do I adjust the orders per the intent or do I leave them as he submitted.

The results of the resolution change drastically one way versus the other.

In table top, it would not really matter as a player would point out how he wants his movement interpretated. In PBP I'd say it could be considered illegal and due to the amount of time involved, it would be resolved incomplete. We have a mixture of both here, so go with the golden middle road: allow him to re-submit.

[Bonecaster]

Not sure you're interested in my opinion. Lol. Of course, you know what it is without asking. But, jeez, Gnaw, you shoulda sent Berlin to Tunis and been done with it. heh

[Bonecaster]

On second thought, I have a more thorough opinion on this. We were discussing something down south. But orders were not issued as I expected them to be. Could be someone changed their mind. But it could be they accidentally wrote the wrong thing. So under how many different types of circumstances can orders that were accidentally written one way be changed?

[Vengeance]

Hey Twelve,

I have an issue coping and pasting those orders. Could you past them in where shit isn't -&gt. Of course if it is just me then ignore.


V

[twelve]

Vengeance, on 29 January 2013 - 04:31 PM, said:

Hey Twelve,

I have an issue coping and pasting those orders. Could you past them in where shit isn't -&gt. Of course if it is just me then ignore.


V

Usually I spend time to manually delete that crap out before I post it but I was feeling lazy.

[Gnaw]

Adjudicator, on 29 January 2013 - 04:39 AM, said:

So I need peoples opinions on something. Here were Gnaws orders

German fleet convoys british army denmark to StP
German fleet Livonia supports British army Denmark
German army Berlin -> Silesia

So as submitted they were not valid orders. But the intent of the orders were clear that he intended to convoy the English army in Denmark to the mainland and support to the mainland. So do I adjust the orders per the intent or do I leave them as he submitted.

The results of the resolution change drastically one way versus the other.

do it however you wish, but if you're going to ask opinions it might help if you posted the whole thing:

Quote

To reiterate:German fleet convoys british army denmark to StP

German fleet Livonia supports British army Denmark

German army Berlin -> Silesia



I don't have a copy of my earlier post of orders, so don't know if I stuck in the Germany fleet.convoys British army

Don't want any confusion..

[Gnaw]

Actually the "German fleet Livonia supports British army Denmark " is a clear fuckup.

It should be resolved as you would any other order from anyone else that used the wrong province name.

[Bonecaster]

That's only one problem. Worse is that Germany is not capable of convoying anything to stp.

[twelve]

It's like Gnaw thought that his troops were in different locations that they really were. Even with the maps posted on thread.

I think I'll leave the resolution as it stands. I'll do a map update later tonight so for now build orders for

Austria x1
Russia x1
France x1

England x? Did you get a build?

Germany needs to disband 2 units.

Edit: I think England was a wash. He gained Den but lost STP.

This post has been edited by twelve: 29 January 2013 - 07:00 PM

[Bonecaster]

Russia builds an army on Moscow.

[Gnaw]

Eh. I know how it happened but that doesn't excuse it happening. Sorry EM.


Disband F Prussia and A Berlin.

Edit: Since, according to the maps, you haven't processed this yet, I'm changing it.

Disband the fleets. Leave Army in Berlin

This post has been edited by Gnaw: 30 January 2013 - 08:35 PM

[Bonecaster]

I know how it happened, too. Naked Russian babes with vodka showed up at Germany's HQ. They got the Germans so drunk they didn't have any idea where there forces were. And in the spring, my best infiltrator kidnapped and took the place of the English forces, and told them to leave St Pete's. You guys shouldn't oughta mess with Mother Russia!!!

[Tapper]

Can we get a map?

[Adjudicator]

Sorry for the Delay. I passed out early last night and didn't even log in.

Fall 1904 movement

Spoiler

 Fall, 1904 Movement.jpg (114.07K)
Number of downloads: 0

Spoiler

 Fall, 1904 Adj.jpg (105.43K)
Number of downloads: 0

This post has been edited by Adjudicator: 30 January 2013 - 06:50 PM