Ok, so Sil's reveal is that she is a finder and found me as scum night 1, Korbas as inno night 2 and Sorrit as inno night 3. If this were true, this would mean she had me down as scum from the very start of day 2. In her own words, she was "campaigning hard at me" yesterday.
So, go back and re-read day 2 everyone, it's not that long. Sil, early in the day, makes a summary post of every other player and concludes by voting me. Ok, that's not much content for a case, but it still goes with her reveal. But then again, if I were scum and was gonna fake reveal on D-Day I'd pick the person I voted for previously as scum, too.
Thing is, after that pair of summary posts, Sil hardly pushes her "case" at all. She posts it, votes and most people only comment a little or ignore it outright. She's online plenty afterwards, but doesn't draw anyone's attention to it, doesn't try to reiterate it, doesn't ask for anyone to comment on it or anything. Sure, she trash-talks and strawmans me a bunch, but not in the context of her case at all and therefore not pushing other players to vote for me. That's not unusual for most "cases", where nothing is certain, but she's claiming that she had certain knowledge that I was scum at this point, so why isn't she trying harder?
And then the end of day approaches and...
Silanah, on 20 July 2012 - 02:18 AM, said:
Well, I am heading to bed. Amp case is obviously not going anywhere today. In the interest of getting a lynch:
remove vote
vote Karosis
WHAT?!
So Sil, you're claiming that you KNEW that I was scum, and you still decided to change votes to the person that *I* had built a case on? You thought "Well I know for sure that Amp is scum, but maybe he's throwing his partner under the bus on day 2 for shits and giggles, so I better vote for Karosis?"
Voting "in the interest of getting a lynch" makes sense for an RI, who has no information but what is on-thread. It makes sense for a finder who doesn't know the lynch train target's alignment. But it makes ABSOLUTELY NO FUCKING SENSE for someone who is town to vote for someone that they can deduce with 99% certainty is also town.
That is not how a finder would act. That is now how TOWN would act.
Your reveal is shit because you are scum who didn't think it through and are just trying to steer the thread into an easy town lynch on D-Day.
Vote Silanah