[Rashan]

Osseric, on 04 July 2012 - 01:30 PM, said:

Town will not win through lynching after another faction genius!

So you're saying lynching someone you might suspect to be scum is WORSE than getting random people lynched?

[Osseric]

I dont get why all of you jumped after the dead alt who had not said anything and we had no reason to trust him.

[Osseric]

I am saying lynching someone that another faction is going to lynch is like lynching a town knowingly.

[Serc]

Osseric, on 04 July 2012 - 01:30 PM, said:

Town will not win through lynching after another faction genius!

Quote

Core Setup:

This is a Town vs Cult game. There are only two factions:

[Tellan]

Barghast, on 04 July 2012 - 01:30 PM, said:

Rashan, on 04 July 2012 - 01:26 PM, said:

Barghast, on 04 July 2012 - 01:24 PM, said:

the scene says cut to shreds and there's a woman clinging to a barbarian who may be acting more shocked than she really is, that suggests to me that she knows what happened to Kalse

I was thinking it could be an NA/vig but night hadn't started yet when it happened, so I guess a mechanic is at work

Well, the fact that 15 people had voted for the random Kalse lynch makes it obvious it's a random lynch

right, I'm just trying to work out how that happened

I think it's probably random, but maybe there's a Day Action that chooses who gets lynched if theres a no lynch?

[Osseric]

OMG, who says dead are in the town faction?
you are just qouting things and not answering questions,why jumping after dead silanah and not other 2 trains.
and why silanah vote is a scum suspect?

[Serc]

Osseric, on 04 July 2012 - 01:41 PM, said:

OMG, who says dead are in the town faction?
you are just qouting things and not answering questions,why jumping after dead silanah and not other 2 trains.
and why silanah vote is a scum suspect?

YOU ARE SAYING THERE IS AN EXTRA FACTION WHEN THERE ISN'T/

[Serc]

Silanah's vote was done and removed. I'm thinking the mechanic has something to do with the Esper's. Two to one odds are in our favour there.

[Path-Shaper]

I've got a replacement player taking over the Anomandaris alt and role, since the original player seems to be away.

[Osseric]

I am saying there is a guy named silanah, he has been dead as long as we remember and then suddenly votes.
1.we don't know if dead are among town faction or not.
2.we dont know if silanah has SH access or not.
3.why should i trust silanah and vote after her?
I apologize for actually thinking before voting.

[Tellan]

Why would PS let a player still playing ( no matter whether theyre alive or dead) have SH access? It would break the game. So to answer question 2, unless Drek has gone mad, No.

[Anomandaris]

You really love to spam, don't you? But I suppose I can count myself lucky that I only have 8pages to catch-up on and not 15.

[Osseric]

If the player only has vote and other harmless(no killing ability) it a possibility.i just mentiones that cause she was dead.

[Serc]

Osseric, on 04 July 2012 - 01:55 PM, said:

I am saying there is a guy named silanah, he has been dead as long as we remember and then suddenly votes.
1.we don't know if dead are among town faction or not.
2.we dont know if silanah has SH access or not.
3.why should i trust silanah and vote after her?
I apologize for actually thinking before voting.

Okay. There is a cult. Cult grow each day.

There is a town. Town get to try and find cult and lynch them.

Lynching each day is the only way to win the game. Sometimes we lynch wrong, sometimes we lynch right. Let's go with your logic of not voting. Cult grows. Town do nothing. Cult grow again. Town do nothing.

Yet this game if we do not lynch = a random player dies.

Now let's go to the situation on day one.

We are running out of time. The only chance of a lynch is a player. You are clueless as to whats going on. Your words. Now you don't vote along to get the lynch because why? You didn't agree with it to start with?

Did you provide an alternative? Did you give a reason we'd all agree with not to vote?


The only good thing to come out of it is that we got a lynch and we know that if we don't agree on a target then we ourselves could be killed.

[Serc]

Anomandaris, on 04 July 2012 - 02:05 PM, said:

You really love to spam, don't you? But I suppose I can count myself lucky that I only have 8pages to catch-up on and not 15.

A bit of it is me doing the PS role for a while.

[Telas]

No, I think Osseric is saying he is Mister Zeh Awesome and can win this game for town with his OMGZORZ night action powerz.

Thank goodness he is here to save us from our folly of actually playing the game we he can do it all himself!

@ Serc

Quote

The only good thing to come out of it is that we got a lynch and we know that if we don't agree on a target then we ourselves could be killed.

You seem awfully sure of this. Why couldn't this be a hidden mechanic like the full CF? I don't think we should assume one of our deaths is automatic if we don't lynch.

[Tellan]

Telas, on 04 July 2012 - 02:21 PM, said:

No, I think Osseric is saying he is Mister Zeh Awesome and can win this game for town with his OMGZORZ night action powerz.

Thank goodness he is here to save us from our folly of actually playing the game we he can do it all himself!

@ Serc

Quote

The only good thing to come out of it is that we got a lynch and we know that if we don't agree on a target then we ourselves could be killed.

You seem awfully sure of this. Why couldn't this be a hidden mechanic like the full CF? I don't think we should assume one of our deaths is automatic if we don't lynch.

I agree. It could have been inevitable day 1, it coupd've been a random death happens if wd no lynch, it couldve been a 1 shot day action, it could be an unlimited day action. We just really don't know at this point

[Serc]

Telas, on 04 July 2012 - 02:21 PM, said:

No, I think Osseric is saying he is Mister Zeh Awesome and can win this game for town with his OMGZORZ night action powerz.

Thank goodness he is here to save us from our folly of actually playing the game we he can do it all himself!

@ Serc

Quote

The only good thing to come out of it is that we got a lynch and we know that if we don't agree on a target then we ourselves could be killed.

You seem awfully sure of this. Why couldn't this be a hidden mechanic like the full CF? I don't think we should assume one of our deaths is automatic if we don't lynch.

Tellan, on 04 July 2012 - 02:23 PM, said:

Telas, on 04 July 2012 - 02:21 PM, said:

No, I think Osseric is saying he is Mister Zeh Awesome and can win this game for town with his OMGZORZ night action powerz.

Thank goodness he is here to save us from our folly of actually playing the game we he can do it all himself!

@ Serc

Quote

The only good thing to come out of it is that we got a lynch and we know that if we don't agree on a target then we ourselves could be killed.

You seem awfully sure of this. Why couldn't this be a hidden mechanic like the full CF? I don't think we should assume one of our deaths is automatic if we don't lynch.

I agree. It could have been inevitable day 1, it coupd've been a random death happens if wd no lynch, it couldve been a 1 shot day action, it could be an unlimited day action. We just really don't know at this point

In the OP it says "There is a lynch everyday"







I don't think PSD will clarify this for us. Maybe someone gets to pick who then.

[Serc]

I asked about it earlier and the consensus by you all was that there won't be more than one but with the timeout and subsequent lynch I begin to doubt the answers you gave.

[Path-Shaper]

About 20 min left in Night 1.