[Galayn Lord]

Karatallid, on 09 March 2012 - 07:09 PM, said:

Should I switch my vote to you GL and see what Thyr does? I'm definitely not doing that. But the fact that Thyr hasn't voted for me is odd imho.

Yes, that would be a bad idea, and yes, it is odd.

[Karatallid]

X-post.

Ok, sounds good. If you like I will remove my vote, but you will need it if Thyr doesn't satify your doubts. Your choice.

[Galayn Lord]

Karatallid, on 09 March 2012 - 07:10 PM, said:

Smiley's misinterpretted. So 5 minutes max. Should I just hope to see we won when I get home then? Let you wait for Thyr?

If you are town, yes. I'm as close to CI as any of us can be right now. As a townie, your vote can't go anywhere but Thyr. So yeah, that's what I would say.

[Karatallid]

One other thought: even though I hadn't written a full length case on Atrahal doesn't mean I wasn't considering him as well. I figured with the way you all were talking we'd be lynching him at dawn. And then I have to leave after the day times out and come back to Atrahal being the flavor of the month. I know it seems rushed, but considering my RL time constraint, it was.

And plus, I was hoping that the meeting would be short and I could sneak back on to make sure we weren't left with this threesome if we had eliminated all the symps. I was right about the threesome.

[Karatallid]

Ok, well gotta go. Next meeting is a walk and I have to get there at 2:30. Good luck GL and probably see you after the game is over. Make sure to grill Thyr.

[Thyrllan]

I'm here - sorry had about 3 customers come in to deal with

[Galayn Lord]

Thyrllan, on 09 March 2012 - 07:19 PM, said:

I'm here - sorry had about 3 customers come in to deal with

It's cool. But it's time to man up and put your thoughts down on paper (the Internet being our metaphorical paper now). What's going on in your head? Where are you going to vote?

[Galayn Lord]

I'm gonna eat some lunch. Back in a bit.

[Thyrllan]

Well, I've been suspecting Kara all game. I had just become comfortable with the idea that all my gut responses & insincts were wrong this game, including Kara. But he still feels wrong, I swear he seemed happy as though he had won the game with the edn of day lynch & NK.

[Galayn Lord]

Thyrllan, on 09 March 2012 - 07:30 PM, said:

Well, I've been suspecting Kara all game. I had just become comfortable with the idea that all my gut responses & insincts were wrong this game, including Kara. But he still feels wrong, I swear he seemed happy as though he had won the game with the edn of day lynch & NK.

Uh huh. He's also suspected you for awhile, and that's why he was happy - out of the three of us left now, he thinks you are the killer. So all he and I have to do is lynch you and town wins. But I also agree that it could be seen as scummy and too eager.

But, if you're town, why haven't you voted?

[Thyrllan]

If you lynch me, scum wins.



The day is nearly over (RL) and I don't want to go into the weekend not knowing who won. So I'm gonna vote in the next 2 hours. Why haven't you voted?



Notice Kara offered to remove his vote, but didnt

[Thyrllan]

Unless you're playing some weird angle I can't see just for kicks, if you were scum you've would've hammered me by now, for the win after one more NK




Vote Karatallid

[Galayn Lord]

Thyrllan, on 09 March 2012 - 08:05 PM, said:

If you lynch me, scum wins.



The day is nearly over (RL) and I don't want to go into the weekend not knowing who won. So I'm gonna vote in the next 2 hours. Why haven't you voted?



Notice Kara offered to remove his vote, but didnt

If all three of us are assuming I'm town - one of you knows for sure, because you're scum, and one should be pretty sure, due to the reveal and the lack of an NK - why are you being so cagey and weird? Of course Kara wouldn't remove his vote, that prevents me from being able to lay down a vote, lynch someone, and end the game. He said he would be gone for awhile.

Why haven't I voted? Because it's my vote that matters the most at this point. If you're both claiming town, you should be pointing fingers at each other, since I'm (obviously) town. But you are just not convincing me. If you're town and this is THE lynch, the final, possible D-Day lynch, why aren't you more interested? Where's the participation and discussion? I just can't pin you down as town right now.

[Thyrllan]

Well, see, after deciding I was good with you as town, I no longer have any control over what happens. So I'm cool. You're gonna make the right decision.

If it helps, a couple things to think about:

1. Hasn't been voted by anybody but me, I don't think, a little suspicion a various times from several, eluded it all - no trains on him
2. voted on every single train in the game I believe, has he expressed any doubts about accidentally hitting innos?
3. Did he ever talk to Anthras and was he the one who said that method of finding scum who knew each other was unreliable? (I'll look)
4. look at how he's responded today, pressure getting to him a bit maybe?



Edit: #1 wrong about the votes; can't find #3 right now, removed #5, had no info

This post has been edited by Thyrllan: 09 March 2012 - 09:45 PM

[Thyrllan]

Karatallid, on 08 March 2012 - 11:42 PM, said:

Well, I'm back home finally. And it feels like I've started another game of mafia. wb GL. Been awhile. I was doing a quick reread earlier and I too saw the initial burst of energy throughout Day 1, somewhat into Day 2, and then you just vanish as RL swallows you whole. And now you are back for the end game. I think the general gestalt actually makes sense, but I will need to examine the posts more closely.

The other pattern I noticed with the third and final suspect of our trio, Atrahal, is the beginning of the day sprees. Atrahal, from what I what I saw, basically popped on at the beginning of the day, made some larger posts and then melted into the background till the next day. This behavior alone warrants a closer look.

Really of the three of you, Thyr, GL, and Atrahal, only GL's play style is inconsistent almost to the point of believability. Thyr and Atrahal both hide in their own ways, adding content without really getting involved, and surviving all the way to the end.

So I am happy to also review my own game play. Other than jibes here and there, no one has looked into me and I was beginning to wonder if I was PI along with Korabas.

And he called me smooth?

[Karatallid]

Well I'm back home. And I see we are still discussing things.

[Galayn Lord]

Well, here goes nothing. See you guys on the other side.

Remove vote

Vote Thyrllan

[Karatallid]

Thyr, anyone who can act as scummy as you and be alive is smooth. The only reason you hint I am is because I have put a lot into this game trying to figure out who is scum and who is on my team.

[Karatallid]

Path Shaper, you around?

[Khellendros]

Game over.

One of the teams has won.

Congrats.