Help
Merrid, on 18 March 2011 - 12:15 PM, said:
I got another computer, I will reply to this and then have a look through
Omtose, it will tell us if you are scum or innocent, if you are scum then HP was innocent and it backs up Barghy even more, if you are innocent then HP was scum and we caught him leaving only one scum left, that's how I see it. You claim to be RI which was a good way to divert the train elsewhere, people followed you because of this, rather than us hit a roled town player I would prefer to lynch an RI or scum. I will have a look at what other people are saying and see if anything comes up I agree with, but with Barghy's partial reveal it leaves 2-3 players who are innocent that we know of, Liosan, let me find the post
Okay so if we believe Barghast then Liosan and Rashan are innocent, although just for thought why would he point these two players out for scum to kill? This highlights 2 town players, and if scum do not know each other then it helps them with their kills, that explains in one way why there was no kill night one, they were trying to figure who was on their team. Maybe, anyway I digress, to me Liosan's play has been the most innocent so far, as he is building cases and helping town where he can, Rashan's posts have been full of spam with only a good one coming every now and then.
Why do you think Korabas and GL are more likely to be scum?
I did say when signing up I may not have much time to post or play but will be on when I can, I want lynches like the rest of us and I am looking for the lynches that would give us the most information. For example we could lynch you to find out if you are scum, if you come up innocent then we definately know that Liosan and Rashan are innocent which gives us a better chance coming into endgame, however from what you say it looks like you are a powerful town and if we keep you around we might find out more information.
I am able to switch my vote from Omtose if needed to get a lynch but for now I think his lynch would give us the best information. That's my 2 cents anyway, i'll try and get online later
Omtose, on 18 March 2011 - 08:45 AM, said:
lynching me wont tell you whether or not HP was scum, just whether or not i am
Omtose, it will tell us if you are scum or innocent, if you are scum then HP was innocent and it backs up Barghy even more, if you are innocent then HP was scum and we caught him leaving only one scum left, that's how I see it. You claim to be RI which was a good way to divert the train elsewhere, people followed you because of this, rather than us hit a roled town player I would prefer to lynch an RI or scum. I will have a look at what other people are saying and see if anything comes up I agree with, but with Barghy's partial reveal it leaves 2-3 players who are innocent that we know of, Liosan, let me find the post
Barghast, on 18 March 2011 - 01:11 AM, said:
This is ridiculous. You guys are calling me scum over a guy like GL... incredible. I am not scum, and I do not know who is, but I do know some information about some of the other people in the game. I am not going to tell you how this information came to me.
I am reasonably sure (at this point) that Osseric was as close to "RI" as you're going to get in this game. He was a Syndicate Sentry. I believe the Sentries are the "generic" players for the Syndicate. Omtose has indicated he is "RI" and if you believe him, that means he is also a Sentry.
I know for a fact that Liosan is *not* a Sentry and Rashan *is* a Sentry. I don't know if they are Syndicate or Agents. However, I do know that neither one has a killing action. Maybe they didn't start with one and gained it, I can't say. But if you are trying to narrow down your list of suspects to people who have been able to kill, you have to rule out both Liosan and Rashan.
My bet would be on Korabas or GL... just for the stuff I've already said. I'm also somewhat suspicious of Merrid but that's because he's getting no attention. In a game like that, it usually indicates a good ability by the scum to hide their powerful members, but I don't know if it's vote-worthy.
I am reasonably sure (at this point) that Osseric was as close to "RI" as you're going to get in this game. He was a Syndicate Sentry. I believe the Sentries are the "generic" players for the Syndicate. Omtose has indicated he is "RI" and if you believe him, that means he is also a Sentry.
I know for a fact that Liosan is *not* a Sentry and Rashan *is* a Sentry. I don't know if they are Syndicate or Agents. However, I do know that neither one has a killing action. Maybe they didn't start with one and gained it, I can't say. But if you are trying to narrow down your list of suspects to people who have been able to kill, you have to rule out both Liosan and Rashan.
My bet would be on Korabas or GL... just for the stuff I've already said. I'm also somewhat suspicious of Merrid but that's because he's getting no attention. In a game like that, it usually indicates a good ability by the scum to hide their powerful members, but I don't know if it's vote-worthy.
Okay so if we believe Barghast then Liosan and Rashan are innocent, although just for thought why would he point these two players out for scum to kill? This highlights 2 town players, and if scum do not know each other then it helps them with their kills, that explains in one way why there was no kill night one, they were trying to figure who was on their team. Maybe, anyway I digress, to me Liosan's play has been the most innocent so far, as he is building cases and helping town where he can, Rashan's posts have been full of spam with only a good one coming every now and then.
Why do you think Korabas and GL are more likely to be scum?
I did say when signing up I may not have much time to post or play but will be on when I can, I want lynches like the rest of us and I am looking for the lynches that would give us the most information. For example we could lynch you to find out if you are scum, if you come up innocent then we definately know that Liosan and Rashan are innocent which gives us a better chance coming into endgame, however from what you say it looks like you are a powerful town and if we keep you around we might find out more information.
I am able to switch my vote from Omtose if needed to get a lynch but for now I think his lynch would give us the best information. That's my 2 cents anyway, i'll try and get online later
Once again Barghast didn't say that Liosan is most likely syndiacate he just said that he isn't an agent and that I am. As Osseric turned up as syndicate, Barghast assumed that sentry means syndicate. I for one would like to know what role that Liosan has in the game. Liosan has been pushing cases on people all game. I don't know if this is syndicate honestly trying to help find agens or an agent trying to look helpfull but really just trying to get people to look everywhere but at him. This is enough for me to put some pressure on him to get some answers.
vote Liosan
Great success! High Five!
