[Path-Shaper]

Resolving...

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 3. 3 hours and 53 minutes left when the last vote was cast.

8 players are left alive. Anomandaris, Atrahal, D'riss, Emurlahnis, Galain, Hood's Path, Kessobahn, Sorrit

5 votes to lynch, 4 to go to night.

4 Votes Night: Kessobahn, Sorrit, Hood's Path, Atrahal
2 Votes Hood's Path: Anomandaris, Emurlahnis
1 Vote Kessobahn: Galain

Players not voted: D'riss

A poor innocent meme has disappeared from the internet forever. Sorrit (dktorode) has been killed.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 4. 32 hours and 0 minutes remain.

7 players are left alive. Anomandaris, Atrahal, D'riss, Emurlahnis, Galain, Hood's Path, Kessobahn

4 votes to lynch, 4 to go to night.



Players not voted: Anomandaris, Atrahal, D'riss, Emurlahnis, Galain, Hood's Path, Kessobahn

[D'riss]

For fucks sake, seriously.

We're onto something, we try to talk about it, we even have some votes on some people.
Then onwards come someone who suddenly 'decides' to vote night, instead of giving us more time to get something intresting going on. I mean what the fuck. Atrahal, what the hell? It's not as if you left your vote where it stood, and eventually after discussing things we couldn't come up to a conclusion about someone, we would have had the same outcome. Why the hell force our hands into night?
It's not like we will 'push' for a lynch if we don't feel like it. This game so far, has had enough people unwilling to vote when they aren't convinced about a case, and decided that there's something else behind it.

I don't understand the reasons behind your actions, at all. It has been proved already that it's kinda 'hard' to lynch someone at this game (and it's always kinda hard to lynch scum) so why the turnaround right now? Why be bothered with something like this?

[D'riss]

And in all seriousness, dont tell me it's 'MATH'.
It's really stupid.

We had two options:

a) Leave the timer running, and try to talk things more, and perhaps have some intresting posts by other people, and more importantly people that haven't participated too much into the game so far. Judging from todays action, it seemed that there were a lot of people willing to talk things over, and get somewhere. Eventually if we weren't convinced by a case, we always have the option of allowing day to run out without a 'dangerous' lynch, or a lynch that would only fly out with the reasoning of 'lynching is better than nonlynching'.

b ) Vote night.

Why the hell choose option ( b ) when option (a) allows us with much more space to manuever and perhaps get something out of it?

Edit: So ( b ) doesn't appear as an emoticon.

This post has been edited by D'riss: 24 August 2010 - 12:50 AM

[D'riss]

Kessobahn, on 23 August 2010 - 08:36 PM, said:

well i think you did a good job of ignoring the reason i voted night. Its not in the hope of there being no nk, but that there is one and so we have less people to worry about tomorrow. I fail to see why as scum i wouldnt just push a lycnh today instead of going to night. Of the three you mentioned, i am clearly inno, sorritt is likely inno because he had kittens when i voted atrahal OMGUS btw, but i would vote hp, except i am going to bed.

my meme is a wild scorlax, my role is town. lynch at your peril.

Three night votes. Which means that in order to GET a lynch we would need the rest of the 5 of us to pile up onto someone. And right around THIS time, on a potential D-Day, people would NOT risk pilling on a 'weak' or 'leaking' case. They would prefer to let the timer run out, since that is always a vial option, if we weren't convinced by the arguements. But EVEN if we allowed the timer to run out, we would still have enough posts in here, and enough discussion to go on through after that.

Your night votes, and Atrahals night hammer, stripped us of that option. How the hell does that benefit team town exactly?
Even if we had 3 or 4 votes pilled up on someone, people would be aware that this can actually come down to a 'successfull' play from team scum, and still be hesitant a bit to hammer. But it would leave us with a potential train to analyse, and probably pinpoint some people in it.

And no, I'm not that pissed that we got ourselves another 'no lynch' day. I'm seriously pissed because team town allowed scum to get out of a situation that they could have made a potentialy 'game losing' mistake, by trying to push a lynch late in the hours, and possibly giving us enough info on the way to actually prevent it and catch them in their act.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 4. 26 hours and 10 minutes remain.

7 players are left alive. Anomandaris, Atrahal, D'riss, Emurlahnis, Galain, Hood's Path, Kessobahn

4 votes to lynch, 4 to go to night.



Players not voted: Anomandaris, Atrahal, D'riss, Emurlahnis, Galain, Hood's Path, Kessobahn

[D'riss]

vote PB

Cause he's nekkid luuuuuuuurking!

[Kessobahn]

well look at the bright side, sorritt was one of the three you thought was scum and is gone now. Not sure why atrahal didnt let day time out given the couple of hours left, but it dindt look like anyone else was on or posted after so despite your blustering i would say no harm no foul. According to galain this is going to be where we point the finger at ano and emur our low posters because a lynch target was killed. back in a bit.

[Galain]

Kessobahn, on 24 August 2010 - 07:06 AM, said:

<br />well look at the bright side, sorritt was one of the three you thought was scum and is gone now.  Not sure why atrahal didnt let day time out given the couple of hours left, but it dindt look like anyone else was on or posted after so despite your blustering i would say no harm no foul.  According to galain this is going to be where we point the finger at ano and emur our low posters because a lynch target was killed.  back in a bit.<br />

<br /><br /><br />

Wow the board is slow at the moment. Hopefully it's just me and not an impending forumpocalypse.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure pointing fingers at Ano and Emur was exactly what I said we shouldn't do. The point that I was trying to make the whole day yesterday is that we can't base any of our decisions today on who died during the night. The only thing we can be reasonably sure of is that the scum would be unlikely to kill someone they thought was their symp going into D-Day. Which doesnt help us at this point. To look any further than is just opening up a whole can of WIFOM.

If Emur and Ano are paired scum then the really don't deserve to win this game, they have had about zero influence on it. For the sake of narrowing the suspect pool today I am not going to consider them. There is a chance that one of them is the second killer or a symp, but we can look at them again if we hit a killer today.

My gut says that Atrahal isn't guilty. If he is scum he has played incredibly well, but to be honest I just don't see it being him. The two people that have struck me as scummy the last two days are Kesso and HP. HP for constantly insisting that any combination of players should still be considered possible partners purely for WIFOM reasons, Kesso for misinterpreting what I have said to make me look scummier on several occasions, the most recent of which is the post I have just quoted.

The one player I don't have a read on is D'riss - other than his righteous rant this morning I can't really think of anything else he has said. Could be a lurky scum, although it is difficult to guage who his partner would be. Will go reread the first page or two to see how people reacted to my vote on him on day one.

[Kessobahn]

well i dont know about atrahal, but i would vote in order - driss, hp, emur, you.

[Galain]

Hmm, if D'riss is scum, I don't think Kesso is his partner. Atrahal did defend him a little, not sure if that means anything. Most of the other players that are still alive weren't really involved with discussing the case against him. What I don't like is that the two other people that had votes against him early on day one are now both dead by NK. Bit too WIFOM to make a case out of though :/

[Kessobahn]

so whats your meme then? no one has countered mine and yet you still think i am scum.

[Galain]

Kessobahn, on 24 August 2010 - 09:05 AM, said:

so whats your meme then? no one has countered mine and yet you still think i am scum.

I'm not sure how this is relevant. We still have no idea what the scum actually are in this game - they could very well also be memes, in which case stating that you are a meme doesn't mean anything. Add to the fact that there are like a million billion memes, it is ridiculously easy to fake reveal in this game...

[Kessobahn]

well then you should be able to guess one that no one else has shouldnt you.

[Galain]

Kessobahn, on 24 August 2010 - 09:44 AM, said:

well then you should be able to guess one that no one else has shouldnt you.

Sad Keanu?
Chubby Bubbles girl?
Professor Awesome?
The Doubles Guy?

And those are just off the top of my head... Seriously, the chances of choosing the same meme as what someone was assigned with seven players left in the game is just so slim I dont see how it can be used as any sort of defense.

[Kessobahn]

i aint using it as a defense, i am just wondering now why you are so reluctant to say yours.

[Galain]

Kessobahn, on 24 August 2010 - 09:05 AM, said:

so whats your meme then? no one has countered mine and yet you still think i am scum.

So this is not you trying to use your meme as a defense? Because that is pretty much exactly what it looks like.

[Kessobahn]

evading the question galain? if you think i am scum then vote, you havent actually made a case against me. saying i am acting scummy is just that, saying it. Provide some evidence of my scumminess and make a case.

But i still want to know what meme you are.

[Galain]

Kessobahn, on 24 August 2010 - 10:50 AM, said:

evading the question galain? if you think i am scum then vote, you havent actually made a case against me. saying i am acting scummy is just that, saying it. Provide some evidence of my scumminess and make a case.

But i still want to know what meme you are.

Evading the accusation Kesso?

My meme is mentioned in the OP as having been killed, apparently the rumours of my death have been greatly exaggerated. I still don't understand how it is in any way relevant, I've just proven how easy it would be to name just about any meme to fake reveal.

And excuse me for not just dropping a vote after only you, D'riss and myself have been online today. If we do have three scum and I put one vote on an inno then it is in all possibility game over.